If Rice plays better down the stretch his value will increase. I can see a team giving up a first for him but I doubt it becuase Freeney will most likely hit free agency. At this point I would gladly take a second for him. As for Kelly with his turf toe injury a third would be the best you can hope for.
...and I don't think we'll get either a 1st or a 2nd for him, just because of the timing. We got a 2nd for McFarland becuase the Colts felt he could be the difference between just making the playoffs and winning a SB. Timing. The Colts don't make this deal in the offseason. Same applies to Simeon. It will be a challenge to unload him because of the price tag he carries.