Enter your username and password below to sign in to your PewterReport account.
x close
I dont think Manning is a choker either. I think the biggest problem Indy have is that they allow Manning too much control over the offense at crunch time, i.e last year against pitt they were 7-0 when manning took the field, came out gunslinging, went 3 and out and were down by 14 the next time he was back on the field. They went 3 and out again.They needed to run the ball. Offcourse manning with his talent ego and pressure felt like he needed to pass to get them a score and back in the game, thats bad coaching, playcalling.Manning is still the best QB i have ever seen live, i am only 22 though so wasn't in position to really appreciate Elway / Marino / Young etc.
Joe Montana was the greatest QB I've ever seen play live. Terry Bradshaw was a hell of a QB too. I saw him play when I was a kid. Joe Namath was the stuff of Hollywood legend, but I didn't much care for him. Dan Marino was a great QB, but I think he will always be known for not being able to win the big one. I think Manning will be remembered the same way; if they don't win a title soon.
I can't believe they gave up a 2nd as well, but they're really thin at DT and so both teams did well on this trade.
It's a generation thing i guess - those before you prob though Johnny U and Otto Graham were the bestIf Manning wins a SB someday his stats may prove he is the best ever. It's a big IF though