Enter your username and password below to sign in to your PewterReport account.
x close
You rightwingers need to stay on script. Not more than a couple of days ago your news network was complaining about the administration NOT doing anything. BTW, this kind of action doesn't require Congress's approval.
Quote from: Skull and Bones on March 20, 2011, 06:14:24 PMQuote from: Illuminator on March 20, 2011, 05:19:35 PMQuote from: Skull and Bones on March 20, 2011, 05:15:57 PMExactly what would the US government do if it faced a heavily armed citizen uprising? Waco Texas ring a bell? You seem to be confused between a psychotic pedophile with a messiah complex and an "armed citizen uprising."Maybe a poor example but let's say the Nation of Aztlan movement gains momentum and poses a serious threat to national security and the President orders the military to crack down on it. Would the UN intervene on behalf of the uprisers? Like him or not, Gaddafi is the established ruler of Libya, has been for 40 years Doesn't he and his govt. have the right to defend their power base against a coup d' etat? What right does the U.S., Britain, or France have in getting involved in a Libyan civil war? And what are the real reasons for it? Did we get involved in Zimbabwe in the 1980s when thousands were massacred?Oh, the whole thing is hypocritical; I agree. But it's not valid to compare Waco to the citizens rising up to overthrow a tyrant. Still, we're only getting involved because we don't like their current government and we're just seizing an opportunity. If Libya was closer or more pertinent to our political agenda, we would have manufactured said opportunity long ago. But the whole thing is subjective, as the saying goes "one man's terrorist is another man's freedom fighter."
Quote from: Illuminator on March 20, 2011, 05:19:35 PMQuote from: Skull and Bones on March 20, 2011, 05:15:57 PMExactly what would the US government do if it faced a heavily armed citizen uprising? Waco Texas ring a bell? You seem to be confused between a psychotic pedophile with a messiah complex and an "armed citizen uprising."Maybe a poor example but let's say the Nation of Aztlan movement gains momentum and poses a serious threat to national security and the President orders the military to crack down on it. Would the UN intervene on behalf of the uprisers? Like him or not, Gaddafi is the established ruler of Libya, has been for 40 years Doesn't he and his govt. have the right to defend their power base against a coup d' etat? What right does the U.S., Britain, or France have in getting involved in a Libyan civil war? And what are the real reasons for it? Did we get involved in Zimbabwe in the 1980s when thousands were massacred?
Quote from: Skull and Bones on March 20, 2011, 05:15:57 PMExactly what would the US government do if it faced a heavily armed citizen uprising? Waco Texas ring a bell? You seem to be confused between a psychotic pedophile with a messiah complex and an "armed citizen uprising."
Exactly what would the US government do if it faced a heavily armed citizen uprising? Waco Texas ring a bell?
Quote from: morgan on March 20, 2011, 03:51:27 PMYou rightwingers need to stay on script. Not more than a couple of days ago your news network was complaining about the administration NOT doing anything. BTW, this kind of action doesn't require Congress's approval.^^^^This.We are not declaring war on Libya. No ground forces are being committed. The president is complying with U.N. mandate to enforce a no fly zone. He has the obligation to brief congressional leaders on the matter within 48 hours, which was done. Congress has the power to end U.S. involvement if they see fit, which they will not. There is overwhelming support from the congress to take action against Libya.
As for comparing Japan to Katrina, the ridiculousness of this comparison is so mind boggling, I can only hope it was done in jest. Let's start with the obvious, Katrina was a hurricane that we saw coming days in advance. Japan was an earthquake and tsunami, both hit with little warning. Japan is a 5,000+ mile flight from the nearest U.S. city over the Pacific Ocean (excluding Hawaii, which wouldn't have had the resources alone to assist in the crisis). New Orleans is right here. One would have had to coordinate with Japanese leaders in order to asses exactly what kind of aid was needed and the best means in which to allocate it. Homeland Security was already in place here to do just that. Grasping at straws about sums it up.
Actually, there is some validity behind the Katrina-Japan comparison. Mainly, we actually had MORE relief resources (including Carriers and ships capable of water purification, hospitalization, etc.) near Japan than we did near NOLA. We literally had rescue forces waiting for the word go within miles of the quake, but instead of the word go, they got static. If an entire carrier group had been with in a few hundred miles of NOLA, history would have been quite a bit different. Unfortunately, after Katrina, a big chunk of the Navy was off the coast of Iraq, not Louisiana. But in Japan there was a fleet awaiting orders that have still yet to come. we are keeping an entire Carrier group in the area in case NK starts to play naughty, that group includes all kinds of search and rescue folks, hospital ships, water purification facilities, copters, thousands of Marines, all waiting to help but they can't until the CoC gives the word go. And the CoC is busy playing golf and flying to Argentina.Any wonder why the Sec. of State has quite publicly stated "I'm done"
No need for the CinC to hunker down in DC when our military performs a little dirty work. Our military leaders were given their mission - President Obama doesn't need to sit home - he's a good multi-tasker (something I can't recall GWB doing much of).
Quote from: morgan on March 21, 2011, 04:47:34 PMNo need for the CinC to hunker down in DC when our military performs a little dirty work. Our military leaders were given their mission - President Obama doesn't need to sit home - he's a good multi-tasker (something I can't recall GWB doing much of).Easy on the multi-tasking - seems he missed contacting a whole bunch of Congressional democrats....