Freeman working out daily with Caddy and Clayton and others.

[grotesktruth]

I dont think he was a bust. He was serviceable for a few years and was a great pass protector for Freeman last year. Clayton on the other hand, big bust.

Even then he really became a bust with a capital B. when some heroic gm (i won't slander thy name oh great draft picker) thought it might be a good idea to keep him for 5 YEARS!!! For 20 mil!  can you say "ARE YOU KIDDING ME!?!?!

[The Anti-Java]

Well, Java disagrees with me, so that means I'm right.

If you think Derrick Ward was a great free agent signing, then yes, being opposite to my opinion is a good thing.    I was about the only person on this entire forum who continually from day one called the Ward signing a bad one.   


Now, everyone realizes it...

Well you know the old sayin, even a broken clock is right twice a day.
So the broken clock is one up on you.

[Captain Hindsight]

Well, Java disagrees with me, so that means I'm right.

If you think Derrick Ward was a great free agent signing, then yes, being opposite to my opinion is a good thing.    I was about the only person on this entire forum who continually from day one called the Ward signing a bad one.   


Now, everyone realizes it...

If I'm not mistaken, you said he wouldn't even crack 4.0 YPC, you gloated about being right in that instance. Great.

Now how can a #5 overall pick have a 3.8 YPC over his career and not be considered a bust? That's a high draft pick plus boat loads of cash.

[JDog]

Except that I've been right more times than anyone else on this forum.    It's not that one instance, it's MANY.   

[JDog]

If I'm not mistaken, you said he wouldn't even crack 4.0 YPC, you gloated about being right in that instance. Great.

Gloated?    I really don't care to gloat about that.   But I bring it up when people say I'm wrong all the time.   That is a lie.     

I don't know about 4.0.   I used to laugh at people saying Ward was a 5.2 ypc type of guy.   One look at him in any game (even his best ones) and you can see he's nothing.    The homers here didn't realize it, but it was damn obvious.

[Captain Hindsight]

Well, Java disagrees with me, so that means I'm right.

If you think Derrick Ward was a great free agent signing, then yes, being opposite to my opinion is a good thing.    I was about the only person on this entire forum who continually from day one called the Ward signing a bad one.   


Now, everyone realizes it...

If I'm not mistaken, you said he wouldn't even crack 4.0 YPC, you gloated about being right in that instance. Great.

Now how can a #5 overall pick have a 3.8 YPC over his career and not be considered a bust? That's a high draft pick plus boat loads of cash.

Williams = 6 years/$31m
Ward = 4 years/$17m

[JDog]

One look at Williams on the field compared to Ward and it's obvious that Williams is a better back.

[grotesktruth]

If I'm not mistaken, you said he wouldn't even crack 4.0 YPC, you gloated about being right in that instance. Great.

Now how can a #5 overall pick have a 3.8 YPC over his career and not be considered a bust? That's a high draft pick plus boat loads of cash.

why can't we all be glad that we have a 1-2 combo that almost works? I wouldn't worry so much to see Caddy play the back-up role as to anything that we would have to sacrifice (like good draft picks or players) in order to find a better back-up.

as far as pointing out who is right last time or the time before that or now... both of you : grow up.

[JDog]

Hey, I'm not insulting Caddy.   I'm defending him.   

[grotesktruth]

Hey, I'm not insulting Caddy.   I'm defending him.   

i was just responding to haters in general.

[Boid Fink]

Carnell sucks.

[JDog]

Hey, I'm not insulting Caddy.   I'm defending him.   

i was just responding to haters in general.

You mean like Boid?   I"m with ya.

[Boid Fink]

...and if I hear one more he is a serviceable third down back comment, I will **CENSORED** in your oatmeal.  Guys drafted that high should not be relegated to a mere third down, one trick blocking pony.  He should be able to toot the horn.  He can't.  Because he sucks as an NFL running back.  True.

[Boid Fink]

Oh yeah, did I mention this:

CARNELL SUCKS

[MUSCLE_HAMSTER]

I'm glad Freeman's been working with our skill players (y'know, what the article is on)