Feel free to cut and paste the quotation of where I said I put "so much faith in what Bills fans have said." What was the definition of a straw man argument again?
My bad. I have no idea where I got the idea you put faith in some Bills fans...
Not my conclusion. The conclusion of the people who actually watch him play week in and week out. Bills fans...
http://boards.buffalobills.com/showthread.php?t=354749
But I'm sure you know more about it than they do.
Obviously, if there was as big a difference talent wise between the two that some on this board would lead you to believe there is, then shouldn't it be apparent to the fans that watch Poz play every Sunday?
Well if he has, Bills fans surely haven't seen it. They watch the guy every week. You watch him on highlight reels and nationally televised games. So I find it strange that you can claim to have seen something that they haven't.
I also pay more attention to what Bills fans say,
...and you go on to quote multiple posts of theirs.
In your dilligent efforts to recant my quotes, I am utterly shocked that you neglected to recant this one...
My reasoning for continuously bringing it up is that so many on the Bucs board seem to think that Poz is hands down better than Ruud against the run and some have even asserted just as good against the pass. If that were so glaringly apparent, then one would think that Bills fans wouldn't be criticizing the guy for those exact two things. Clearly, it's not as cut and dry as that. There are obviously flaws in his game that have lead to Bills fans developing these opinions of him, whether fair or unfair.
In other words, I have the same amount of faith in Bills fans assessment of Posluszny as I do with Bucs fans' assessment of Ruud. Some of it is fair, some of it is not.
You're right. I'm clearly misrepresenting you here on the Bills fans.
Thank you, Biggs! That's mighty "Bigg" of you to admit!
