Welll, maybe not 100%... There are differences in respective skillsets; maybe just 90% alike

.
Freeman is much more of a running threat than Eli. Eli is a way better decision maker up 'til now. If Dallas Clark stays healthy, we got an edge there. And IMO Blount could evolve into a better RB than Jacobs, who has levelled off, if not regressed.
Defense is where they are way ahead of us...