"The tackling machine had his first multi-missed tackle game of his career"

[Biggs3535]

Luck is leading a team who almost went winless last season to playoffs this season, when his HC has left to team to fight cancer.  And RGIII has more TD's, less INT, a higher rating and completion percentage.  When there are two rookie QB's performing like that, no other offensive player has a chance.

Martin would win this award in most years, but not this one.

[The Anti-Java]

Wilson has done a nice job also, but he won't win it.

Having said that, I wouldn't trade Freeman for him straight up.  Wilson is not the tallest guy.

[kbl117]

Kalil doesn't have it.

So glad we didn't go after him last offseason. If I was MD, I would've drafted him. Would'a been a dumb move in retrospect.

hes been one of the best LTs in football so far

[barbernbrooks]

Luck is leading a team who almost went winless last season to playoffs this season, when his HC has left to team to fight cancer.  And RGIII has more TD's, less INT, a higher rating and completion percentage.  When there are two rookie QB's performing like that, no other offensive player has a chance.

Martin would win this award in most years, but not this one.

That's fine. The question is why is he also behind a guard, a tackle, a qb with subpar stats and a top tier defense, and a cb.

[Biggs3535]

Luck is leading a team who almost went winless last season to playoffs this season, when his HC has left to team to fight cancer.  And RGIII has more TD's, less INT, a higher rating and completion percentage.  When there are two rookie QB's performing like that, no other offensive player has a chance.

Martin would win this award in most years, but not this one.

That's fine. The question is why is he also behind a guard, a tackle, a qb with subpar stats and a top tier defense, and a cb.

The CB doens't matter since there is an Offensive and Defensive ROY.

I would agree that Martin should be in front of Wilson and Zeitler.  But Matt Kalil has been a dominant LT.  That dude looks like the next Tony Boselli minus the injuries.  Martin has been great this year, but he's just drawing some bad luck with his peers.  QB's and LT's are more valuable than RB's.

[Feel Real Good]

Luck is leading a team who almost went winless last season to playoffs this season, when his HC has left to team to fight cancer.  And RGIII has more TD's, less INT, a higher rating and completion percentage.  When there are two rookie QB's performing like that, no other offensive player has a chance.

Martin would win this award in most years, but not this one.

That's fine. The question is why is he also behind a guard, a tackle, a qb with subpar stats and a top tier defense, and a cb.

PFF grades players by compiling scores for every play over the course of the season. While Martin has had a good statistical season as far as running backs go, he's basically done it on three awesome games and a couple more average games. He's had five completely forgettable games and probably didn't get graded very highly for those games. He may be getting pulled down from these games where other players have been more consistently above average over the entire season.