Bill Sheridan

[mooil]

The Bucs secondary is porous, that goes without saying. But you have to wonder how much of that is attributed to Sheridan's scheme as opposed to talent. This Sheridan guy was a scrub as a D-coordinator with NYG, and he shouldn't be returning next year based on merit. It will be interesting to see who will be available in the off-season to   replace him. I personally would like Romeo Crennel, but what do you think?

[rpc1978]

i hate to switch things up after only 1 year.  you have to like how they are defending the run.  as for the bad pass defense, its not on sheridan that we have a bunch of scrap heap guys signed off the street out there playing CB.

[J-Train]

Maybe Jack del Rio....hell maybe Monte?

[youngone]

I would hope that if they made a switch they would keep the same front 7 coaches for the purpose of continuity. They are definitely worth keeping IMO.

[The Anomaly]

This guy was FIRED in nymph.  Why?  Worst Giants D in fifty years.  He sucks here.  Anyone who defends him is stupid.   Bad hire.  Crappy DC.

[The Anti-Java]

Can Sheridan tommorrow, make Butch Davis DC.

[bradentonian]

how much of that is attributed to Sheridan's scheme as opposed to talent.

It's Schiano's scheme

[lyronmewis]

Not hard to have a good run D when your LBs sell out on every play against the run.

[JohnBuc06]

i hate to switch things up after only 1 year.  you have to like how they are defending the run.  as for the bad pass defense, its not on sheridan that we have a bunch of scrap heap guys signed off the street out there playing CB.

Normally I would agree with this ...give him some better talent in the defensive backfield and see how it goes.  Especially when you're playing guys that at best are another teams Special Teams players only.  But man this pass D has got to be historically bad.  I wouldn't be opposed to him getting the boot.  Maybe promote one of the front 7 guys if they merit it to keep some continuity.

[The Anomaly]

how much of that is attributed to Sheridan's scheme as opposed to talent.

It's Schiano's scheme

Fine...dude still can't call a defense.  He stinks out loud.

[VinBucFan]

Actually, the Sheridan-led Giants defense gave up points not passing yards

[The Anomaly]

Actually, the Sheridan-led Giants defense gave up points not passing yards

Are you arguing he's a good DC?  Feel free to provide proof.

[VinBucFan]

Actually, the Sheridan-led Giants defense gave up points not passing yards

Are you arguing he's a good DC?  Feel free to provide proof.

no just pointing out the results are not identical. I dont like the scheme

[Bschucher]

Actually, the Sheridan-led Giants defense gave up points not passing yards

Yeah, i just looked that up a few ago and they were 15th against the pass that year. As mentioned, they gave up unreal points that year. He needs to go IMO. Considering how Schianos assistant coaching search went last year, not even sure Sheridan was really who he wanted. I dont recall how that hire went.

[Benchwarmer#1]

Actually, the Sheridan-led Giants defense gave up points not passing yards

Yeah, i just looked that up a few ago and they were 15th against the pass that year. As mentioned, they gave up unreal points that year. He needs to go IMO. Considering how Schianos assistant coaching search went last year, not even sure Sheridan was really who he wanted. I dont recall how that hire went.

I believe he's so bad at calling plays, that if they fire him, I'll promise to buy season tickets next season.

The guy is #1 vs the run for a reason, and it's not because of the defense overall, but rather the constant attack on the run. I understand the theory. Get them lopsided on one side of the ball and make them have only one form of attack, got it. But seriously, we don't have to have every guy in the box or out at the endzone on every play.