Throughout his tenure here, he's played more bad than good. What gives you the confidence that he can play above average consistently?
2 good seasons, 1 bad season.
That's more good than bad if you ask me. And that bad season happened when the entire team was in disarray.
Do you really believe that Freeman has played more good games than bad?
I'm not sure. I don't feel like going through every game, but I think he has had more good/average games than bad ones. I agree that he is inconsistent, but so are guys like Eli and Flacco. Their teams have done just fine with them because they have good supporting casts and defenses.