Enter your username and password below to sign in to your PewterReport account.
You were simply too smart for me.
Moving Forward.....Who Would You Want....Josh Freeman or Cam Newton ?
Cam. Younger. Higher ceiling. More athletic. Better leader.
To answer the question in the title... no brainer... Freeman, flaws and all. Cam Newton is the ULTIMATE fool's gold. He will always have above-average stats and highlight reel plays, but IMO he will never be a winning QB. Maybe he somehow matures into one but I don't think a guy can change like that. He doesn't have that kind of mental makeup if you ask me. Freeman on the other hand... I still give him a large pass for '11. Last year had parts that you simply cannot excuse/explain away. HOWEVER, he HAS demonstrated the "killer" instinct and ability to pull out come from behind wins. I don't think Cam will be that. Freeman's growth in our system will show this year and let that natural ability come out.