Who's the one player you DON'T want the Bucs to draft 4th overall?

[fanofdabucs]

Java wrote:

"Steve Young is in the Hall of Fame.  If that's not a "franchise" QB, I don't know what is.
Doug Williams in reality was a franchise QB.   He was the heart and soul of the team back then and one of the top QB's in the league.
Vinny Testaverde had rough years in Tampa.  But the guy played in the league for 20 years and started almost all of them.   He was actually a franchise QB as well, he just had absolute crap to work with in Tampa and horrible coaching."

LMAO. Steve Young wasn't a hall of fame QB when he was with the Bucs.

Doug Williams!! In whose "reality". LMFAO.  He was not one of the top QB's in the leauge. Do you just make this stuff up as you go? He completed like 40% of his passes and just happened to have a great D and was good at throwing the long ball. He was NOT and any way, shape or form a franchise QB.

Doug Williams: 1978   Comp 37%  Rating 53.5
                       1979   Comp 41     Rating 52
                       1980   Comp 48     Rating 69
                       1981   Comp 50     Rating 76
                       1982   Comp 53     Rating 69
 
Dilfer? 

WOW. As you can see, the Tampa Bay fans expectations for QBs are pretty low. If you think any of these players really comes close to a franchise QB (Montana, Elway, Manning, Marino, Farve, etc, etc.)you go back and watch some tape.

No matter how you spin it, the Bucs have NEVER had a franchise QB and don't have one on their roster right now. 

[mjke3041]

>

[The White Tiger]

Jamarcus Russell, Branch, Peterson

I want CJ but I'm cool with Quinn. I agree with Java - we've had good Qb material but never before have we had the luxury of sitting one while he learns the system from a pretty good QB tutor & personell that could also participate in development. Quinn would be a good, longterm, fit in our current system.

[karen anderson]

No, no, no! Not Quinn! Next you'll want Troy Smith!

[The White Tiger]

No, no, no! Not Quinn! Next you'll want Troy Smith!

Not a bad idea

[karen anderson]

No, it's a terrible idea!

[biased buc]

Why? Then maybe Alan Branch should be our choice because he is who frees up Woodley and they held Wisconsin to something like 12 yards rushing. Of coarse you know more than all the scouts and Thomas didn't deserve that Outland Trophy.

That may have been a joke(can't tell) but I wouldn't be surprised if the Bucs did take him if the draft fell that way. I've seen a couple scouting reports compare him to Shaun Rogers.

[The White Tiger]

Why? Then maybe Alan Branch should be our choice because he is who frees up Woodley and they held Wisconsin to something like 12 yards rushing. Of coarse you know more than all the scouts and Thomas didn't deserve that Outland Trophy.

That may have been a joke(can't tell) but I wouldn't be surprised if the Bucs did take him if the draft fell that way. I've seen a couple scouting reports compare him to Shaun Rogers.

Besides the obvious reason that this guy is a Wolverine: The Buckeye's stacked up over 500 yds of offense against the Branches - Wolverines - 187 RUSHING yards. The Buckeyes destroyed Michigans Defensive Line...USC showed them the door too.

I don't think the Buccaneers need a slow footed 2 gap Nose Tackle - especially don't need him at #4 overall - IMHO!

[MBF]

No, no, no! Not Quinn! Next you'll want Troy Smith!

Quinn is pretty good, we should really look at drafting him or Russell at 4 if CJ and JT are gone.

[Feel Real Good]

No to Russell !!!!!! Reminds me sooo much of Culpepper and I really dont know why. I just dont like him, my opinion only.

Culpepper may have fallen off the map now, but he's thrown for way more yards than anyone wearing a Bucs uniform in a long time, has been to 3 pro bowls, was 2nd in MVP voting in 2004 and has played in a conference championship game. I'm not fond of Russell either, but if a Bucs QB accomplished what Culpepper did, I'd be ecstatic.

[The White Tiger]

Quinn is pretty good, we should really look at drafting him or Russell at 4 if CJ and JT are gone.

If CJ is gone then I'm OK with Quinn or Thomas.

Not Russell...never Russell...

 No to Russell !!!!!! Reminds me sooo much of Culpepper and I really dont know why. I just dont like him, my opinion only.