Bucs draft question

[cvillebucfan]

Unreal, how can people (in general) argue someting that makes zero sense...................

Name ONE SINGLE GOOD WIN BROHM HAS EVER HAD IN HIS CAREER..................Who has he beaten that was worth a gee whiz? WV this year, a game that was circled as one of the 2 important games on the schedule and ticketed as a thursday NIGHT game, get real.....He played 3 weeks ago against Rutgers their BCS hopes on the line and was AWFUL against the same defense a freshman played against last week, that walked out with a win.

Fact is this some people will argue anything, the sky is blue...........no its not. Its stupid. First of all Brohm isn't even going to be in the draft. Brady Quinn is light years ahead of Brian Brohm as of 11/21/06 @ 12:33 and to argue it is insanity. 

You just do not like Quinn. Maybe you are scared to death the Bucs would take him and you have a man crush on grads, not sure. I think you are safe if that is the case but to sit here and compare Brady Quinn and Brian Brohm is nuts. What is even more nuts is to disregard Quinns stats because of weak competition knowing that Louisville plays in literally a HS conference and plays 2 games season that are meaningful.

[alldaway]

Unreal, how can people (in general) argue someting that makes zero sense...................

A lot of things with the draft do not make sense but that is how things are as of today and who knows how it will be in April.

The thing with Quinn is he sometimes plays down to the level of his competition and there are concerns over his accuracy/decision making.

[cvillebucfan]

Hilarious  ok guys whatever you think.....32 TD's 5 INT's, 65% completion %. Last year he threw 32 TD's and had 7 INTS and 65% completion % again.

He has made some collosally bad decisions I know, the stats show it 32 TD's 5 INT's, geez........

I don't even really care for Quinn but this is just nutty, whatever you guys think....

Barring him being busted in a porn/drug ring or having a crazy injury he will be the 1st QB taken in the draft this April.

[mjs020294]

The thing with Quinn is he sometimes plays down to the level of his competition and there are concerns over his accuracy/decision making.

I have seen him make some really bad decisions, even facing crappy Ds.  Quinn is highly overrated IMO.

[mjs020294]

Hilarious  ok guys whatever you think.....32 TD's 5 INT's, 65% completion %. Last year he threw 32 TD's and had 7 INTS and 65% completion % again.

College stats mean nada.

YARDS      Pass%      TDs      INTs      Rating
3210   ~   71.2   ~   29   ~   7   ~   161.53
3518   ~   70.2   ~   27   ~   8   ~   162.56

Gradkowski 

[cvillebucfan]

HAHA, I love you guys, its great!

I just thought those bad decisions would be indicative of his TD and INT thrown throught the past 2 years.


That is all Grads could muster in the MAC

[alldaway]

The thing with Quinn is he sometimes plays down to the level of his competition and there are concerns over his accuracy/decision making.

I agree.

[mjs020294]

How about these stats:

Attempts   ~   Yards   ~   TDs
91   ~   504   ~   1
91   ~   191   ~   9
61   ~   291   ~   4



Grads's college rushing stats  

[mjs020294]

That is all Grads could muster in the MAC

yes he was awful, the only QB in college history to have back-to-back years with a pass completion percentage above 70%   

[alldaway]

To give you an idea as to why some people perceive Quinn overrated some scouts have already graded him out as being just as good as Peyton Manning was.

Without the year being finished, no combines, or pro days that is an example of how loaded with a lot of hype Quinn is.  Quinn has the physical tools to be a first round QB but to be compared to Peyton Manning when he was coming out is over the top in my very honest opinion.

The Palmer comparisons to Quinn I can buy to a degree and even then have my objections but not the Peyton Manning one.   

[cvillebucfan]

haha, strong rushing numbers right there, wow!!!!!!!!!!!

I don't like the Irish either buddy but just trying to enlighen you guys on few points that you either fail to comprehend or just don't want to admit. You are and ADW are comical though I will give you that I LMAO everytime I come here

[cvillebucfan]

To give you and idea of why some people perceive Quinn overrated some scouts have already graded him out as being just as good as Peyton Manning was.

Without the year being finished, no combines, or pro days that is a huge leap loaded with a lot of hype. Quinn has the physical tools to be a first round QB but to be compared to Peyton Manning when he was coming out is over the top in my very honest opinion.

The Palmer comparisons to Quinn I can buy but not the Peyton Manning one.

Thanks for the insight Mel, we all appreciate it.

[alldaway]

I don't like the Irish either buddy but just trying to enlighen you guys on few points that you either fail to comprehend or just don't want to admit. You are and ADW are comical though I will give you that I LMAO everytime I come here

I am trying to elighten you why most fans and scouts that follow the draft (before Apri)l why they feel Quinn is being overhyped too much.

[mjs020294]

haha, strong rushing numbers right there, wow!!!!!!!!!!!

I don't like the Irish either buddy but just trying to enlighen you guys on few points that you either fail to comprehend or just don't want to admit. You are and ADW are comical though I will give you that I LMAO everytime I come here

As do many posters everytime they see your ID  

Quinn is overrated IMO.  Will he be a good NFL QB, yes of course if he finds the right team and situation.  Is he worth a top five pick and $50+ million deal, NO.  A top ten QB is very bad value for money because they never 'produce' in their first two, sometimes three season.  They usually sit for over a year and then have the usual baptism of fire when they start, AND if you get lucky they might start to return on the investment in year three.