Did Belichick not have final say in Cleveland?
Frankly I don't know but I don't see how his lack of success in Cleveland tarnishes his great success in New England. Is brett Favre a loser because he didn't play as well in Atlanta as he did in Green Bay?
I'm not questioning his coaching ability...it's all of the people who are saying he is the best talent evaluator in the world! If that was the case, he would have been a great scout at Cleveland, and he wasn't. It's mostly the front office and pro scouting that has that team with all of the players that they have, not Belichick.
But he has done an unbelievable job at coaching them.