Vick or Grads?

[DanTurksGhost]

With all of the rancor around the Bucs QB situation and with the embarrassing display in Atlanta, I thought I'd pose the following query:

If the Bucs could trade Bruce Gradkowski straight up for Michael Vick and could do so without any negative cap implications at all (so throw the salary out of the equation), and assuming that Vick must play QB and could not be converted to another position, would you make the trade?

If so or if not, why?

[ZenBuc]

yes, but then I'd trade Vick to some desperate team for a high draft pick

[karen anderson]

Even I wouldn't do it. Vick is a prima donna & a jackass.

[BucsGuru]

Absolutely.  The guy is a freak of nature.  Grads will never play like Vick IMO.  No brainer.

[Boid Fink]

Are you serious dude?

I mean seriously, what kind of dumb ass would not want Vick, even as a bencher, before Grads?

I'll stick with our number 7

[karen anderson]

I'll stick with our number 7

At least our #7 is not contageous!

I'll stick with our number 7

At least our #7 is not contageous!

as a black man, I'm appauled.

[karen anderson]

I'll stick with our number 7

At least our #7 is not contageous!

as a black man, I'm appauled.

Not again, RJ. We're going to need to see a family tree, geneology papers, something!

esto insulta mi apellido

[ufojoe]

Vick in a heartbeat.

[karen anderson]

esto insulta mi apellido

sorry, I definately wouldn't want to insult your apellido. Only 2 & a half want Vick.

[Boid Fink]

Actually the majority so far in this thread want Vick.  And you would be a jackass to not want him.  He is a good runner at least.

[caradoc]

Actually the majority so far in this thread want Vick.  And you would be a jackass to not want him.  He is a good runner at least.

Vick over Grads?  Based on current, yeah, vick.  But you can't just "assume no cap implications" because that is part of the package with any QB.  And I'd be very upset if we got Vick.  Mora Sr was 100%, and the guy will never win it, he's bring the class level of this whole franchis down along with him. 

Although it would be neat to see that primadonna getting his ass chewed on the sidelines by chucky...

[karen anderson]

I bet he'd stomp off the field & have a temper tantrum. Or a hissy fit.  Sorry, Boid, I read you answer wrong. But I think he'd blow up our team. And fans wouldn't put up with his abusive crap.