Will Carnell be in the same category as.........

[Feel Real Good]

Anthony Thomas

[Fresh]

Rashaan Salaam
or
ickey Woods?

both players had success in their first year, after that it just went down ever since

the one hit wonders pretty much

im tryna ask do you think cadillac can recover and go back to his rookie year form??

[mjs020294]

I fear Caddy's best games are behind him.  Hopefully he will be able to play again but he will never be a feature back. IMO

[Uncle Stan]

He hasn't been taking a roster spot since he was placed on IR.

[tbc_bucs]

Its really hard to tell especially since all we hear is bad news right now. The days are really dark as gruden said, and with reports of caddy still limping around it doesnt sound like we will find out in 08 anyways.

I hope he comes back but we need an answer by next January so we can prepare accordingly. Graham is good enough to start in this league but I think we should groom a second RB regardless.

Hoping for duplication of his rookie year performance is setting the bar pretty low IMO. His production was not spectacular and definitely not reflective of his lofty draft status.

[krazybuc]

i think it's safe to label caddy a bust. he will probably attempt a comeback and be riddled by injuries for a few more years before calling it quits. i dont see much success for this guy.

[Tampa Bay Todd]

Don't think you can call a guy a bust when it's an injury that causes his downfall. He was on his way to a pretty good year I think before the injury. I'll throw another Bear back into the bust mix and that was Curtis Enis. Compare Caddy more to someone like Kijana Carter who blew out his knee shortly after coming into the league.

[krazybuc]

then the pick of caddy was the bust and not caddy himself.

either way the bucs lose.

[Lord Freesus]

Let him rest a year or 2 then try again... or I may change or screen name.. sigh.. it rhymes so well...

[krazybuc]

ruud dude?

tjax attacks?

or

my personal fave...

clayton blows.

[Lord Freesus]

Haha, I claim Ruud Dude unless we draft a hotshot QB that I like... but Ruud is guaranteed to be a key player barring injury

[Pirate Zone]

I am hoping he's either cut or traded before the start of the '08 season.

[Lord Freesus]

Who trades for Kevin Jones II? He's damaged goods. Our o-line meshed by the time Graham was out there. Caddy would've probably done better with that line. Keep him on IR then send him out in competition. If he lost his elite potential... good back-up?

[krazybuc]

there's no reason to cut him. if he cant play then just put him back on ir for another year. then you see how he performs the following offseason.