Is This A Fair Trade?

[bucs1]

I'm not sure if I should make this trade.  Can you guys help me?  Here's the trade:

I would trade:                                                 I would get:
T.J. Houshmanzadeh and Warrick Dunn     for     Ryan Grant and Chester Taylor

[kmitchell]

Don't do it. T.J. is playing for a contract this year. Drop Dunn and pick up Bennett.

[Booker]

Why do you have Warrick DUnn anyways?

[bucs1]

Why do you have Warrick DUnn anyways?

I had him because the draft was before Earnest Graham's holdout was over and people were saying that he would be the starting running back.  They said he would rush for 1,000+ yards and catch 60 balls.  Anyway, what do you think of the trade?

[kmitchell]

This trade is basically TJ for Grant and Taylor. It really depends who your other RB's and WR's are. TJ is worth more than Grant and Taylor is really only a backup. If you are really strong at WR then I would do the trade.

[Biggs3535]

I would take Grant over Housh.  You can always find a WR in the FA list, not so much with stud RB's.

[bucs1]

This trade is basically TJ for Grant and Taylor. It really depends who your other RB's and WR's are. TJ is worth more than Grant and Taylor is really only a backup. If you are really strong at WR then I would do the trade.

My other WRs are Braylon Edwards, Greg Jennings, Dwayne Bowe, Bernard Berrian, and Joey Galloway.  What do you think?

[BuckEmUp]

Chad Johnson is semi hurt and has had a bad offseason.  Palmer and Hush may have gained a lot of trust in each other during the offseason.  I dont think I would make the trade.

[Bucs_Rule]

What are your other starting RB's?

[bucs1]

What are your other starting RB's?

My other starting RBs are Frank Gore and Willie Parker.  My backups are Darren McFadden, Chris Johnson, and Warrick Dunn.

[BuckEmUp]

I really like chris Johnson and think that he might have a big season.  McFadden might be the next Peterson. 

[kmitchell]

Your team is better how it is, TJ will most likely be a top 10 WR again. Edwards, Housh, and Bowe is a really good WR corp. If I were you, I would try to package Parker and Jennings for a top 10 rb. Maybe try to get a Lynch or Portis out of it.

[bucs1]

Thanks for the advice guys.

KMitchell, I already tried to package T.J. Houshmanzadeh and Willie Parker for Clinton Portis, but the trade was rejected.

[benchwarmer69]

Portis is a hard guy to get in trade. Better off picking him from the get-go.

[krazybuc]

Grant has BUST year written all over him.

No way. Nobody's gonna respect Rodgers. Defenses will play the run and try to make Rodgers beat them (which isnt likely)

Dont do it!