Enter your username and password below to sign in to your PewterReport account.
x close
What we don't get is that the offense has had three #1's , 2 # 2's, and 2 #3's in the last three years, and none of these players can be considered to be a core player for the 07 squad.
I honestly don't remember who coached the Bengals back then except to say that they were an expansion team back then too, so I hope you are not refering to a finished and LOOOONNNNNGGGG Past his Prime Paul Brown as your "proof."
I can buy that. It does appear that the Bucs have taken the safer guys over the more talent guys in general. Clayton is a perfect example. A hard worker in college who was a good but not great type that should have projected into a solid but not game changing #2 WR in the pros. Not exactly the stuff that you want from the 15th pick in the draft, but solid nonetheless. He had a great rookie year, then fell apart in year 2 and 3. Why?Caddy is a complimentary player. A good one, but a complimentary guy nonetheless. His game translates well into the NFL well, as he is shifty and seems to pick out the right holes. Used as a 10-15 carry guy, he has value. That isn't a knock per se, since many NFL teams that dont have a Jackson (ARRRGGGGH) have found that splitting carries works well. Again, he isn't a guy one would consider 5th pick in the draft material. After a brilliant first 3 games, he fell apart in year 1. By year 2 he clearly wasnt running as hard as those first 3 games, and the result is under 800 yards rushing, a 3.5 average, and 1 TD. Again, a seemingly solid guy regressed in his 2nd year. Not one would expect from a rookie.Ruud, Im sorry, but this guy isn't a guy anyone should have considered for the top of the 2nd round. He isn't an NFL caliber MLB. I know folks will argue this, but show me the proof? If he cant beat out a 35 year old MLB on a rebuilding team by year 2 then I am not sure why folks think he is anything other that what he is; a hard working special teams guy. Tatupu was clearly a better fit here. Joseph and Trueblood were need picks. I hate drafting for need because you almost always pass up a superior talent, and your needs change so much year over year that by the time they fill the need, the team had other needs that would have been filled by simply taking a great player, regardless of postion. Both started, and played below average football. They are both rookies, so that can change, but still not the sign of a successful draft, at least not yet.But, the point is progress. We all understand that the defense would have issues as they aged. What we don't get is that the offense has had three #1's , 2 # 2's, and 2 #3's in the last three years, and none of these players can be considered to be a core player for the 07 squad. The offense has fallen to 31st in points, 29th in yards. The running game, which was given the 5th pick in draft AND a 1 and a 2, finished 29th. The plan was solid, draft guys to help the running game. The results haven't been there. Either the talent drafted was subpar, or the coaching they received was sub par. It is one or the other. Which one do you pick?
Did the TBBBBB close or something?
Quote from: dbucfan on January 05, 2007, 06:11:24 PMDid the TBBBBB close or something? lol i dont know...why?