Cadillac to Practice on Wednesday...

I love EG and Dunn but pure running skills Caddy is nasty.

Nasty, u say? When I think of nasty running skills, I think LT, Portis, Jackson or "All Day". I wouldn't put Carnell in that class. Would you?

FYI.... i don't "Hate" the guy. I just don't think he's as great as some make him out to be. I was being serious with that question because I don't think he brings anything to the field that we can't get from Graham or Dunn. And they bring far more in the passing game.

Its all good though...... we can agree to disagree. This debate, while ongoing on this board, will be settled on the field.

[keeponbucn]

Nasty, u say? When I think of nasty running skills, I think LT, Portis, Jackson or "All Day". I wouldn't put Carnell in that class. Would you?

FYI.... i don't "Hate" the guy. I just don't think he's as great as some make him out to be. I was being serious with that question because I don't think he brings anything to the field that we can't get from Graham or Dunn. And they bring far more in the passing game.

Its all good though...... we can agree to disagree. This debate, while ongoing on this board, will be settled on the field.

Well I feel he does add another threat to this run game. He isn't LT or AP, not many RB's are though. He can only help with the mounting injuries in the backfield.

So you feel he immediately brings more to the field than Bennett.... who can't get a sniff?

[Snake Pliskin]

He doesn't have to be to help us out.

[rpc1978]

i'm a little concerned that we are rushing him back.  I'd rather see him take a redshirt year.  that being said, i'm definitely curious to see how he holds up in practice.  

[Snake Pliskin]

So you feel he immediately brings more to the field than Bennett.... who can't get a sniff?

Definitely. If Bennett had anything the Bucs wanted we'd have used him by now. Bennett is just holding Caddy's roster spot until he gets back.

[GameTime]

so who do you deactivate?  is it graham or dunn?

[yuccaneers]

In his rookie season he was lighting in a bottle as he would see a whole and hit it hard and fast the two season after he was very tentative and was doing way too much dancing in the backfield, while he may have better vision and explosion in the running game compared to Dunn or Graham unless he improved his blitz reconigation and blitz pickup he is a two down back which would actually hurt the offense as with Graham and Dunn in the game teams have to do a little more guessing as to weather or not it is going to be run or pass where as with Williams in the game the chances are it is a running play

[SunnyD]

I know a lot of you aren't huge fans of his but my opinion he can do nothing but help us.

I beg to differ. All it takes is one missed blitz pickup by Caddy, which is totally inevitable, and Garcia may be hurt again. That would mean we're looking at Dr. Pick-6 again and then we'd struggle.

First of all thats a little extreme.

Second of all if thats the case then don't put him in that situation.

Give him 4 carries a game all on first or second down. Don't keep him in there to pass protect.

[keeponbucn]

So you feel he immediately brings more to the field than Bennett.... who can't get a sniff?

At the moment, no, but if Caddy is 100% healthy no question.

[SunnyD]

so who do you deactivate? �is it graham or dunn?

Neither.

Dexter Jackson.

[Snake Pliskin]

I trust that he's been doing more for the past 13 months than running steps.

[ktownbuc47]

Looking forward to seeing Caddy run behind this line.

[OpTiOnMaStA]

It'd be great to have him back but I don't think this year he'll do much for us. After coming back from an injury like that I don't think he's going to be the same player he was his rookie year and that's what we want him to be.

[olafberserker]

You don't wanna say that around here...lol

oh HE does.