Enter your username and password below to sign in to your PewterReport account.
x close
okay so imagine now if caddy plays in detroit and reinjures himself on the turf...what then oh faithful gruden-ites?
Quote from: BucDaFackUp on November 17, 2008, 04:35:44 PMokay so imagine now if caddy plays in detroit and reinjures himself on the turf...what then oh faithful gruden-ites?Ruining a young man's career wouldn't sit well with me.Lets hope he stays healthy.
Quote from: TBTrojan on November 17, 2008, 12:45:06 PMYou wanna go with stats...30 year onld Bennett has a 1.7 YPC this year with a long of 4 yards23 year old rookie Smith has a 5.4 YPC this year.while we are skewing the stats...you might want to mention that smith is fumbling ONCE every FIVE offensive touches while bennett has ZERO fumbles.
You wanna go with stats...30 year onld Bennett has a 1.7 YPC this year with a long of 4 yards23 year old rookie Smith has a 5.4 YPC this year.
The fact is most coaches (and myself) would rather take the young guy that does something with the ball and has potential, then work on his ball security than have an oldish, never was that has failed everywhere he's been.
Quote from: All_da_way on November 17, 2008, 05:20:22 PMQuote from: BucDaFackUp on November 17, 2008, 04:35:44 PMokay so imagine now if caddy plays in detroit and reinjures himself on the turf...what then oh faithful gruden-ites?Ruining a young man's career wouldn't sit well with me.Lets hope he stays healthy.W T F are you two talking about?
Quote from: BuccanAy on November 17, 2008, 11:50:54 AMWhy do you cut a healthy RB who's shown the ability to be a playmaking RB, a veteran who's spent the offseason learining the playbook, who performed well in TC(I was there and saw it)and a RB who performed well in PS? Especially when your feature back is hurting, the next guy has a ton of miles on him and is also hurting. This was a VERY bad decision, I don't think you can debate it wasn't, and be honest about it.The problem I have with the move to let Bennett go is that Smith keeps putting the ball on the ground. I really like Smith's running style, but he needs to hold the ball up high and tight. Maybe Tiki can give him some tips. I hear we have a contact on the team.
Why do you cut a healthy RB who's shown the ability to be a playmaking RB, a veteran who's spent the offseason learining the playbook, who performed well in TC(I was there and saw it)and a RB who performed well in PS? Especially when your feature back is hurting, the next guy has a ton of miles on him and is also hurting. This was a VERY bad decision, I don't think you can debate it wasn't, and be honest about it.
Quote from: TBTrojan on November 17, 2008, 05:59:24 PMThe fact is most coaches (and myself) would rather take the young guy that does something with the ball and has potential, then work on his ball security than have an oldish, never was that has failed everywhere he's been.you know, that almost sounds like the garcia vs mccown comparison.