SI Backfield ratings

[The White Tiger]

Biggs - you're clearly biased by the numbers.

You're completely ignoring the huge "Iwantittobeso" factor.

[TBayXXXVII]

right now McNabb is better than Rivers

(In 2008)
 
Rivers: 34 TD, 11 Int, 4,009 yards with a 105.5 rating.
McNabb: 23 TD, 11 Int, 3,916 yards with a 86.4 rating.

Try again. After all, "facts can't be disputed" a wise man once said.

And Rivers was yet again better than McNabb in 2009.

Rivers: 28 TD, 9 Int, 4,254 yards with a 104.4 rating
McNabb: 22 TD, 10 Int, 3,553 yards with a 92.9 rating

And yet again... McNabb is still better than Rivers.

[Biggs3535]

right now McNabb is better than Rivers

(In 2008)
 
Rivers: 34 TD, 11 Int, 4,009 yards with a 105.5 rating.
McNabb: 23 TD, 11 Int, 3,916 yards with a 86.4 rating.

Try again. After all, "facts can't be disputed" a wise man once said.

And Rivers was yet again better than McNabb in 2009.

Rivers: 28 TD, 9 Int, 4,254 yards with a 104.4 rating
McNabb: 22 TD, 10 Int, 3,553 yards with a 92.9 rating

And yet again... McNabb is still better than Rivers.

^^^LMAO^^^  What's the weather like on that planet of yours?

[TBayXXXVII]

Just because you drink a gallon-sized jug of Hater-ade when it comes to McNabb, it doesn't mean he's not a top 5 QB in the NFL.

[Feel Real Good]

McNabb is good, but not top 5.

[TBayXXXVII]

Peyton, Brady, Brees would be in the top 5... who else before you get to McNabb?

[Biggs3535]

Just because you drink a gallon-sized jug of Hater-ade when it comes to McNabb, it doesn't mean he's not a top 5 QB in the NFL.

Saying McNabb isn't better than Rivers isn't Haterade, chief.  It's a fact, backed up by literally every statistic that measures QB's.  Your opinion isn't fact.

Peyton, Brady, Brees would be in the top 5... who else before you get to McNabb?

Aaron Rodgers, Phillip Rivers, Tony Romo, and Ben Roethlisberger are no-doubters.  I could make an argument for a couple others, but I won't. 

It's ludicrous to put McNabb as a top 5 QB.  If you said Top 10, I wouldn't give you much an argument because he has the credentials to back that billing up.

[TheShadow]

What's the measuring stick here? Stats or Rings?

[Biggs3535]

Donovan McNabb's QB rankings since becoming starter in 2000:


                Yards     TD        Int     Comp. %     QB Rating

2000:        12          7         15          21                18
2001:        15          7         11          20                7
2002:        26          19        1           22                8
2003:        14          17        9           19               16
2004:         8            3         4           10                4
2005:        18          16       10          22               16
2006:        20          15        3           23                4
2007:        13          14        6           21                9
2008:         7            8         15         18                15
2009:        17           13       6           20                12

AVG:         15          11.9      8         20.6            10.9


McNabb isn't a top 5 QB.  Frankly, even top 10 is generous.

[bradentonian]

Donovan McNabb's QB rankings since becoming starter in 2000:


                Yards     TD        Int     Comp. %     QB Rating

2000:        12          7         15          21                18
2001:        15          7         11          20                7
2002:        26          19        1           22                8
2003:        14          17        9           19               16
2004:         8            3         4           10                4
2005:        18          16       10          22               16
2006:        20          15        3           23                4
2007:        13          14        6           21                9
2008:         7            8         15         18                15
2009:        17           13       6           20                12

AVG:         15          11.9      8         20.6            10.9


McNabb isn't a top 5 QB. Frankly, even top 10 generous.

And that's with the benefit of a pass-whacky offense

[TBayXXXVII]

Just because you drink a gallon-sized jug of Hater-ade when it comes to McNabb, it doesn't mean he's not a top 5 QB in the NFL.

Saying McNabb isn't better than Rivers isn't Haterade, chief. It's a fact, backed up by literally every statistic that measures QB's. Your opinion isn't fact.

Peyton, Brady, Brees would be in the top 5... who else before you get to McNabb?

Aaron Rodgers, Phillip Rivers, Tony Romo, and Ben Roethlisberger are no-doubters. I could make an argument for a couple others, but I won't.

It's ludicrous to put McNabb as a top 5 QB. If you said Top 10, I wouldn't give you much an argument because he has the credentials to back that billing up.

I disagree with every one of those guys.  Sorry if I need more than 2 years to put someone on a pedestal.

[Biggs3535]

Rivers and Romo have been starting for 4 years and Roethlisberger for 6.

And if Aaron Rodgers average of 4,236 yards, 29 TD, 10 Int, and 98.5 QB rating over two years hasn't sold you on his ability, then why keep pimping McNabb's 3,735 yards, 22.5 TD, 10.5 Int, and 89.65 QB rating over the same period?  Craziness.

[Hate]

Peyton, Brady, Brees would be in the top 5... who else before you get to McNabb?

Big Ben and Rodgers, without question.

[TBayXXXVII]

Numbers... just numbers.  McNabb TOOK.... yes, HE took (not the defense... though it did help), 5 INFERIOR teams to a conference championship and 1 to a Super Bowl.  How many has INFERIOR teams has Rivers, Ben, Rogers, and Romo taken?  ZERO?  Yeah, that's what I thought.  McNabb is Top 5.

[Biggs3535]

Numbers... just numbers.

Yeah, it's a shame when those silly "fact" thingamajiggers get in the way of an inferior opinion.

Denial sucks.