Thinking about taking this trade

[swashbuccaler]

Dont take it.

[LoganBucs37]

somebody offered me Clinton Portis and Dwayne Bowe for Cedric Benson and Calvin Johnson. Should I accept or decline...your feed back is very appreciated!

Hold tight.

[BuckEmUp]

Yea, it would depend on who the other WRs and RBs are on your team.  I would rather have Johnson than Bowe but I would rather have Portis than Benson.  If you have 2 other good WRs and were counting on Benson as your #2 back then do it.

[Wilson]

QBs-Kyle Orton, Shaun Hill
WR-Calvin Johnson, Anthony Gonzalez, Donnie Avery, Mike Walker
RBs- Tomlinson, Addai, Benson, Felix Jones, Rashard Mendenhall, Jamaal Lewis, Laurence Maroneey
TE- Zach Miller
DEF - Tampa Bay
K- Kris Brown

I've got way to many running backs.

[Booker]

trade for a QB. You have no chance with those guys running your team

[swashbuccaler]

I like your team alot as is.

[TRJ997]

I've got way to many running backs.

You can never have enough RBs.

I wouldn't make the trade because your WR depth is thin compared to your RB depth. What would this guy give for Benson by himself? Could you offer Benson and either Orton or Hill for an upgrade at QB? Don't go overboard trying to trade for a QB if you don't get a favorable offer, though. Orton/Hill have potential and you will have all season to upgrade the position. You should constantly be on the lookout for the QB currently on your waiver wire who will finish in the top 10.

That assumes that you only have to start 1 QB, because every QB should already be picked up if you start 2. I can't believe there have been 18 responses without anyone asking about your scoring rules and starting requirements. In order to be able to give the best advice, I would really need to know if its PPR? How many RBs, WRs, and QBs you start? And if its a redraft, keeper, or Dynasty league? These criteria make a big difference in fantasy decisions.

[Wilson]

Passing TD Pass 4   Every 25 passing yards  1   
300-399 yard passing game 2   400+ yard passing game 3   
2pt Passing Conversion 2   Interceptions Thrown -2   
 
Rushing TD Rush 6   2pt Rushing Conversion 2   
Every 10 rushing yards 1   40+ yard TD rush bonus 2   
50+ yard TD rush bonus 3   
 
Receiving TD Reception 6   2pt Receiving Conversion 2   
40+ yard TD rec bonus 2   50+ yard TD rec bonus 3   
Every 10 receiving yards 1   200+ yard receiving game 3   
 
Miscellaneous Fumble Recovered for TD 6   Each Fumble Lost -2   
Kickoff Return TD 6   Punt Return TD 6   
 
Kicking FG Made (50+ yards) 5   FG Made (40-49 yards) 4   
FG Made (0-39 yards) 3   Total FG Missed -1   
Each PAT Made 1   
 
Team Defense / Special Teams 0 points allowed 10   2-6 points allowed 7   
7-13 points allowed 4   14-17 points allowed 1   
Blocked Punt or FG return for TD 6   Each Interception 3   
Each Fumble Recovered 3   Blocked Punt, PAT or FG 2   
Each Safety 2   Each Sack 2   
Kickoff Return TD 6   Punt Return TD 6   
Interception Return TD 6   Fumble Return TD 6   
Each Tackle for Loss 1   22-27 points allowed -1   
28-34 points allowed -4   35-45 points allowed -7   
46+ points allowed -10   
 

[Wilson]

Here's how your lineup is set each week.

QB
RB
RB
RB/WR
WR
WR
TE
K
Def.

[BuckEmUp]

I would not make the trade.  Your WRs would be dead. 

[Wilson]

Well...it's done...I rejected it. I would like to thank all my fellow Buccaneer fans for their feedback. You guys were a huge help. Anybody have any questions for me throw them my way.....GO BUCS!!!!!!!