Home » Articles » Game Coverage » What We Learned: Bucs vs. Panthers
  • increase font size
  • Default font size
  • decrease font size

November 15, 2010 @ 12:57 pm
Current rating: 4.00 Stars/1 Votes

What We Learned: Bucs vs. Panthers

Written by Scott
Scott Reynolds


Publisher E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
Pewter Report publisher Scott Reynolds breaks down the Bucs' 31-16 bounce-back win over the Panthers and analyzes the play of the offense, defense and special teams. What was learned from the Bucs' sixth win of the season? Click here to find out.
Pewter Report's Scott Reynolds shares his opinions, insights and observations from Tampa Bay's 31-16 victory over Carolina on Sunday.

We learned that Josh Franchise is having a “super” season. Freeman is off to a fantastic start to his second NFL season. Against Carolina, Freeman had a career-high 134.2 passer rating, finishing the game completing 18-of-24 passes (75 percent) with two touchdowns and no interceptions.

With a career-high 12 touchdowns and only five interceptions, Freeman, the team’s franchise quarterback, is on pace to throw for 21 touchdowns, eight interceptions and 3,489 yards. Those numbers compare favorably to the numbers Super Bowl-winning quarterback Brad Johnson put up in 2002. Johnson threw for 3,049 yards with 22 touchdowns and six interceptions in 13 games that year, missing three games due to injury.

Should Freeman actually throw 21 touchdown passes that would tie Trent Dilfer for third on the most TD throws in a single season. Dilfer accomplished that feat in 1997 and 1998. Only Johnson has thrown more touchdowns in a single season. He tossed a franchise-record 27 TDs in 2003 and 22 the previous year.

We learned that LeGarrette Blount has new ways to dazzle us. It was just two weeks ago that Blount made the highlight reels by hurdling Cardinals safety Kerry Rhodes en route to a 48-yard run. On Sunday, Blount ripped off a 17-yard touchdown that finished a leaping, 360-degree spin in the air after being hit by Panthers safety Charles Godfrey at the 1-yard line. As Blount was coming to the ground he had the presence of mind to stick the ball over the goal line to score the touchdown that gave Tampa Bay a commanding 14-3 lead with 12:23 left in the second quarter.

Blount had a 12-yard run to start Tampa Bay’s 87-yard touchdown drive and also had runs of 24, 3 and 17 before his 17-yard touchdown scamper. With the second quarter just beginning, Blount already had six carries for 78 yards (13 avg.) and wound up with 91 yards on 19 carries on the day (4.8 avg.).

Even though Blount was contained in the second half, the Bucs were able to use play-action passing the entire game because of what Blount was able to do in the first half on the ground.

“The biggest thing is establishing the run,” Bucs middle linebacker Barrett Ruud said. “Play action is really never good if you’re stopping the run – it is not so much of a threat. It’s also a lot better when you get in situations where you are not expecting it, when you’ve got a second-and-short [where] you can take more chances. That’s probably the ideal situation, where you’ve got a second-and-3, second-and-3 as opposed to second-and-10 [where] you’re kind of expecting a pass a little bit more.  Being able to use [play action] in situations where you are not expecting a play pass or pass in general [is helpful]. When you’ve got guys like Josh Freeman and Mike Williams that are big play threats, and, for instance, for me in a Cover 2, I’m going to err on the side of reading the pass first, and then I’m going to come up. If there are guys that I’m not really worried about a vertical threat [from] or a quarterback who is going to throw it vertically, I’m not as fast to get back. That’s the biggest thing, I think: the [players] who are executing those play actions, [because] that is what is going to make it work well.”

We learned that the Bucs could win without Mike Williams being a factor. Tampa Bay’s offense put up 21 first half points before Williams recorded his first catch. The rookie from Syracuse has been the primary weapon in the passing game this season, but he was only thrown the ball twice in the first half as Freeman directed his throws to tight ends Kellen Winslow (three catches for 41 yards and a touchdown) and John Gilmore (one catch for 29 yards).

Freeman said that Williams was getting a lot of attention in coverage and the Panthers paid the price by leaving other targets in single coverage.

“We may start with Mike, if he’s not open, we’ll reset to the middle and John Gilmore is sitting wide open,” Freeman said. “Our team, we present a lot of matchup issues. If you’re going to play man-to-man, you’re going to have a linebacker matched-up on Winslow, and I’d take Kellen Winslow in that matchup. If you play zone, we have too many guys filling in the holes, and obviously Kellen working inside and Cadillac checking down.”

Blount’s running (75 yards on eight carries in the first half) made the Buccaneers offense balanced, and with the Bucs having the lead ever since they went up 7-0 in the first quarter, Tampa Bay didn’t have to have Williams carry the passing game as he has done so often this year. Williams caught his first pass, a 28-yarder, at the start of the third quarter and finished with a strong second half, catching four passes for 68 yards.

Williams now has 40 catches for 627 yards (15.7 avg.) and five touchdowns. He is on pace to post 72 catches for 1,114 yards and eight touchdowns this season.

We learned why Ted Larsen got the start over Jeremy Zuttah at left guard. Despite the return of center Jeff Faine, Larsen, a rookie, remained the starter at left guard over Zuttah, who was a 16-game starter at the position last year and filled in nicely for Faine this year. The reason? Larsen is a more physical blocker and the team has averaged over 147 yards rushing with him in the lineup.

On Sunday, the Bucs rushed for a season-high 186 yards on 30 carries (6.2 avg.) and Larsen helped spring Cadillac Williams, who had a phenomenal day as a third down back with 62 yards and a score on five carries, for a 45-yard touchdown. On third-and-11 from the Tampa Bay 45, Larsen pulled from left to right and sealed off Carolina linebacker Jon Beason to create the hole for Williams’ touchdown jaunt. Williams also received great blocks from wide receiver Preston Parker and tight end John Gilmore.

With Larsen, who was an adept waiver wire pick-up by general manager Mark Dominik prior to the start of the season, playing so well it would be foolish to take him out of the starting lineup. The one area of his game that really needs to be cleaned up is his penchant for penalties, though. Larsen was flagged for two false starts on Sunday against Carolina.

We learned that the Bucs got better in the first quarter. Why have the Bucs had so many come-from-behind wins this season? Tampa Bay has struggled to get off to fast starts in the first quarter. In fact, the Bucs had been outscored 42-23 in the first quarter heading into Sunday’s game. That’s a 19-point differential, favoring opponents. But offensive coordinator Greg Olson’s play-calling was sharp on the Bucs’ first series and Freeman’s execution was perfect as the Bucs traveled 47 yards in four plays with the drive covering 2:07.

After a 5-yard run by Freeman, Olson gave the Panthers a run-first look with two tight ends to the left and Freeman used a play-action fake to Blount to find Winslow open short and Gilmore open deep. Freeman wisely hit Gilmore for a gain of 29 yards down to the 13. Staying with a run-look formation that featured two tight ends on the next two plays, Blount picked up five yards down to the 8-yard line before Freeman hit Benn for an 8-yard touchdown to give Tampa Bay a 7-0 lead - a lead it would never relinquish.

Benn went in motion from right to left and acted like a was going to block the backside end, but Freeman again executed a play-action fake to Blount and hit Benn wide open in the flat as the rookie receiver outraced cornerback Richard Marshall to the pylon. Olson has done a great job of scheming ways to get Benn his first two touchdowns, his initial one coming last week at Atlanta out of a similar two-tight end formation that likely signals run-first to opposing defenses.

“Coach Olson is calling great plays; that’s made it a lot easier on myself,” Freeman said. “[Sunday] was another awesome day.”

We learned that the offense is carrying this Buccaneers team. Times have changed in Tampa Bay. For the better part of the last two decades, the Bucs were known for winning with defense. Not any more, and that has to upset Bucs fans and frustrate head coach Raheem Morris because he is in charge of that side of the ball as the team’s defensive coordinator. On Sunday, Tampa Bay recorded just two sacks, only one takeaway, and allowed more points (16) than the Bucs defense surrendered against a better and healthier Panthers team in Week 2 (seven).

With Freeman throwing for 241 yards, the Bucs rushing for 186 yards, the team converting 50 percent on third downs and the offense scoring a season-high 31 points, including four touchdowns, the offense carried the day. Over the last three games, the Bucs offense has averaged 370 yards and averaged 23 of the 30 points per game that Tampa Bay has averaged, which is more than acceptable for the youngest team in the NFL.

Meanwhile, the defense is surrendering 23 points per game over the last three contests, which is about six points more than ideal.

“That’s always our feeling,” Bucs cornerback Ronde Barber said. “One way or another whether it’s a defensive stop or a defensive score we can win with 17 points. It’s a number we’ve played with for years. [Former Bucs defensive tackle Warren] Sapp used to say that all the time. That’s the standard. I think it started with [former Bucs head coach] Tony [Dungy] in 1996.”

Until the Bucs scoring defense dwindles down to 17 points or less, which may not happen this season, Freeman and the offense will be carrying this team.

We learned that Tampa Bay’s defensive line simply cannot sack the quarterback. Through nine games, Tampa Bay has recorded only eight sacks and the Bucs defensive line has generated a woeful five quarterback captures. Tampa Bay’s defensive line got some pressure on rookie quarterback Jimmy Clausen, notably from defensive tackle Gerald McCoy and defensive ends Michael Bennett and Stylez G. White, but wasn’t able to finish.

Unlike the first meeting when the Bucs defensive line recorded three of the team’s four sacks in Week 2, both of Tampa Bay’s sacks on Sunday came off blitzes from middle linebacker Barrett Ruud and cornerback Ronde Barber. Only two members of the Bucs defensive line have sacks this season – White (three) and defensive end Tim Crowder (two).

Since the game at Carolina in the second week of the 2010 season, the Bucs defensive line has recorded just two sacks over the last seven games, which is pitiful.

We learned that Aqib Talib is becoming a complete cornerback. As good as Talib has been picking off passes as a cover corner this year, he has really shown improvement as a tackler. He has 41 (38 solo) through eight games after having 69 stops (62 solos) last year. After recording eight tackles (seven solo) on Sunday against the Panthers, Talib is on pace to notch a career-high 82 tackles.

Against Carolina, Talib fought through a block by Steve Smith to tackle Goodson for a gain of eight yards on a cutback run on second-and-14 to set up third-and-6. Had Talib not made the tackle near the sidelines, Goodson could have easily picked up the first down or even scored a touchdown if Talib had given up the sideline.

Considering the fact that cornerbacks Elbert Mack and E.J. Biggers both had shoddy tackle attempts on Mike Goodson in the second quarter that resulted in runs of 18 and 15 yards to total 33 yards, Talib stepped up big against Carolina. The third-year cornerback also had a monumental, tackle-saving tackle for loss on the backside of a Goodson run after he reversed field and cut back after running from right to left. That tackle also prevented a touchdown and showed that Talib can make money plays against the run – not just the pass.

“The last three weeks with what Aqib Talib has been able to do in what we call chute awareness or keep the cup has been unbelievable,” Morris said. “To watch him run up yesterday and watch him make some of the tackles that he made and do some of the physical things that he did not show in his first two years here – maybe sparingly – but to watch him become this complete corner is really fun to watch.”

We learned that Tampa Bay’s return game might be the most inconsistent unit on the team right now. A week after the Bucs return game was revved up and dangerous at Atlanta with Micheal Spurlock ripping off returns of 66 yards and an 89-yard touchdown, the special teams units against Carolina sputtered and were dreadful. One week their hot, the next week, they're not.

Dime corner Elbert Mack had a ball bounce off his leg on a punt and get recovered by Carolina, which went on to score a touchdown off that turnover.

Tampa Bay’s return game could not get going as Spurlock returned two punts for five yards (2.5 avg.) and returned four kickoffs 61 yards (15.3 avg.) with a long of 21. On one return, Spurlock bobbled the ball and Maurice Stovall turned around and essentially blocked him as he was trying to advance the ball. Special teams killed the Bucs and gave the offense terrible field position, especially in the third quarter. Spurlock did a poor job of returning kicks he should have downed in the end zone.

Panthers return man Captain Munnerlyn had a 37-yard punt return in the third quarter to set up a Carolina field goal.

“It wasn’t a good day for our special teams play,” Morris said. “We have to bounce back off the performance, but other areas of our football team lifted us up and that’s how it has to be. Last week, they almost won us a football game. This week, we had to get help from other areas and we had to do that to bounce back and win this football game. I’m proud of what these guys were able to do today.”

We learned that the Bucs are twice as good as they were last year. Super Bowl-winning head coach Bill Parcells is famous for saying that you are only as good as your record indicates. At 6-3, the Bucs have won twice as many games as they did during the 2009 season when they finished with a disappointing 3-13 record.

“I didn’t even notice it until you just said it,” Morris said. “It’s certainly nice, but it’s not the goal. We talked about the goal [the race to 10 wins], and we talked about where we wanted to be at the beginning and these guys have continued to march and continued to go in that direction.”

With six wins combined with being the youngest team in the NFL, head coach Raheem Morris and general manager Mark Dominik have done enough this year to earn the right to have their two-year options picked up by the Glazers. The only thing that would prevent that would be if the bottom fell out down the stretch and this team was to finish 6-10 after such a promising start. At this point, a 7-9 record or better would have to be considered a success.

We learned that the Bucs have yet to learn how to put a team away. Granted, Tampa Bay has only notched two wins with a margin of victory of 10 points or more twice this season, and both of them came against Carolina, but the Bucs should have beaten the Panthers by more points than they did. Tampa Bay opened up a 21-10 lead at halftime, but allowed the score to narrow to 21-16 in the third quarter.

Even in the fourth quarter after a Tampa Bay field goal, the Bucs were allowing the Panthers to hang around as the differential was only eight points at one point, which is just a touchdown and a two-point conversion. That didn’t sit well with Morris.

“I think that’s a part of the lesson,” Morris said. “When you go out every week – you don’t want to knock yourself on a win, and that’s not what I’m doing, but you know you got a John Fox-coached football team over there that’s going to keep fighting and keep playing and keep playing tough. For us, the beauty of it is that we’re learning lessons. I’m able to have teachable moments throughout the game and go out there and yell at people for doing some of the wrong things and also go out there and be able to congratulate people for doing things right, and that’s lovely for this young football team.”

The Bucs had eight penalties on offense – most of which were false starts or illegal shifts or formations – that played a significant role in the team stopping itself. Gilmore also said the players were frustrated that they didn’t come out with more of a sense of urgency in the third quarter.

“We were clicking on that first couple series,” Gilmore said. “We got up on them and we let go. We let go of the reins. I think that’s something that we need to improve on. This is no disrespect to Carolina, but we’ve playing to the level of our opponent. Big games on the road we’ve been getting up for. In games like these in the third quarter, we are not putting them away like we should. That’s something that we should try to improve on.”

We learned that winning games alone is not going to get Bucs fans back into Ray-Jay. Tampa Bay returned home from a two-game road swing with a surprisingly pleasant 5-3 record through the first half of the season. Sunday was an absolutely beautiful day weather-wise and the fans were treated to an expected victory over the hapless Panthers. Yet there was only a paid attendance of 44,264. That’s roughly 21,000 less than a sellout, which is why this game and the rest of the home games this season will be blacked out.

The Glazers were wise to come out on Friday with the announcement that ticket prices would be lowered for some seats and that there would not be any ticket price increases in 2011. The Tampa Bay area economy is still hurting and local unemployment numbers are over 12 percent. The Bucs should see a rise in season ticket sales next year given the development of Josh Freeman and the team’s improved win total, but it would be a stretch to think that the Bucs’ season ticket base would climb above 50,000 even with a big increase. That likely means more blackouts in 2012 as the gap between the current attendance and a sellout is around 20,000 tickets.
Last modified on Monday, 22 November 2010 15:52

Only registered users can rate articles!


  • avatar

    the Glazers are to little to late......they should have slashed prices 25 per cent this year and next year....what they did for next year is way way to little and nrxt year we will also be blacked out......are they that stupid.....this is not new york......the fans here do not make that kind of money......they need a new pr guy and if they had half a brain slash the prices for next year before its to late.
  • avatar

    Well maybe it seems to be a good idea today to pay to watch the Bucs on TV for blacked out games, but I for one don't. It's just like when the goverment proposes a new tax for a specific purpose, after it is paid for, the tax never ever goes away, it is just re-purposed. Unfortunately, I have always suspected that the NFL would eventually go to all-encompassing pay per view model(s). It may start (as you suggest) just with the blackout games, but the NFL owners will find that they like the additional revenue and come up with new and costly (to fans) marketing schemes, so that eventually it will spread to involve every single game to the chagrin of all fans. Also, don't think for one minute that the horrendous commercials will go away just because you have to pay for it either! Be careful what you wish for! I'm for delaying the inevitable as long as possible. If it's free is for me.
  • avatar

    I would speculate that the NFL has already spent millions on research and already has in place a roll out strategy and timeline of incremental changes to move to a full pay per view model.
  • avatar

    Well said scohad.
  • avatar

    I paid 70 bucks for two tickets. My tickets came down 50% this year and I understand they are going to be the same price next yr. If this team is above .500 this yr, That is a great value. I think we are developing an incredible offense and we are seeing a few players emerge that are going to be superstars in the next few yrs.
  • avatar

    Maybe the NFL should look at different ways to sell their product. A lot of people would pay $5/game per household to watch the Bucs play on TV in a blacked out area. I agree with the other poster, why not lower ticket prices just before game time and sell out the upper decks at $25/ticket first come/ first served/ best seat available. Patrons are going to spend more money when they get into the stadium. Just like on the Priceline commercial, "Do you allow a perishible commodity to spoil?" Well, there's a lot of money they won't be able to get back. Not smart. I think it's time to look at some other progressive marketing/sales schemes and abandon the old at least temporarily. They should experiment with different markets and different schemes to fill their stadiums. If it doesn't work, don't use it again. If it works, you're genius. In the past, the NFL has been progressive enough to make it the #1 sport in America. And the NFL really has to work to destroy what they have achieved. But I believe they are in jeopardy of that happening, especially with the younger "skateboard/xbox" generation. Unfortunately, I think the NFL is trying to use the economy/bad ticket sales to renegotiate the CBA to their advantage. What a shame for the fans...
  • avatar

    Gotta add to the comments about ticket prices. I couldn't get in, even at 1:25, for less than $75 per seat. Are you Shi77ing me?? I can see the entire third deck is mostly empty and you won't sell seats for less than Seventy Five dollars?? I drove a hundred miles to see the game and was willing to "splurge" but no way was I paying $200 for two lousy seats and a couple of beers. They are doing nothing to solve the embarrassing problem of a vacant stadium. Why not have $40 upper deck passes? I'm only gonna spend even more money when I get inside. When I wasted thousands of dollars on season tickets I was lucky to get $20 for any extra seats. Yesterday, I didn't see a single person scalping. I don't completely understand the economy of NFL tickets, but I know this much: no way the Bucs sell out a single game this year, even if they are 11-3 for the last home game. If you plan to go to a game, don't expect to stroll in to an empty stadium for cheap. Get $30 tickets online at stub hub first.
  • avatar

    When I had season tickets they started out at $49 in '98 which were the highest non-club and were $85 in '07 after my 10yr commitment was up. They kept raising ticket prices by justifying that the demand was high for them. Now that the demand is low they need to lower them closer to the prices back in '98. And I mean lower all of them, not just a fraction of 3rd level seats that are in the corners.
  • avatar

    Just wanted to correct pne thing. On Blount's spinning TD leap, he didn't get hit at the one yard line as you say. Watch the replay. He leaps from the 5 yard line. That's 15 feet. A 250lbs shouldn't be able to do that. Beast Mode.
  • avatar

    This is probably your best article format, PR. Keep up the good work!
  • avatar

    We also learnt that the panthers and cards are the 2 worst teams in the nfl.
  • avatar

    What we learned... defense has long way to go on the line first, LB's second. Have to draft or get via free agent - Ruud needs to go... On filling the stadium, as the saying goes, "it's the economy stupid..." maybe the Glazers are just too dumb to figure this out... same with the Rays...
  • avatar

    what i learned is Josh Freeman should be in the conversation for league MVP! why not? the Bucs might be 2-7 w/o him.
  • avatar

    If we get to 10 wins and grab a wildcard spot...I think Freeman will be in that conversation. Blount is really helping things open up now, but Freeman single handedly carried this entire team for most of the first half of the season.
  • avatar

    It is tough to fault the scheme when there are no playmakers playing the defensive end position. It was encouraging to see Raheem adjust his past rush by blitzing Rudd and some of the other guys more. The problem is the blitz packages will not be as effective against better quarterbacks like Flacco, Ryan, and Brees (maybe even McNabb) in our last few games. It will be interesting to see how effective our pass rush will be at containing a running QB like Troy Smith. I'd like to be able to say our speed at linebacker will help contain him but Geno is struggling with his knees and Qunicy has a troublesome ankle. With Gore and Vernon Davis to worry about as well, this game concerns me despite the 49ers record. Also here is to hoping the Bucs deactivate Mack for the rest of the season in favor of Lewis. I don't know if I have ever seen a DB be responsible for so many bad plays in such a short amount of time. I swear Claussen called a timeout in the first half because he looked across the field and didn't see Mack in the game and therefore didn't know who to throw to.
  • avatar

    @Horse - ticket prices, completely agree. Though it's not the Glazers, it's the NFL in general - all professional sports really. Owners have to understand that most people just can't pay that kind of money anymore. Luckily for me, I'm in Charlotte so the NFL Sunday Ticket is my friend.
  • avatar

    Did you really just say the Bucs don't know how to put teams away? What game were you watching? I believe the drive that ended with Cadillac's touchdown "put them away". Despite their lack of offense the Panthers still have a tough defense! Come on Son!!!!!!!!!!
  • avatar

    What's going to get the stadium filled is realistic ticket prices and i am not talking about the nose bleed areas and the corners. The days of high ticket prices is over. The economy and the failure of the Buc Owners to market a younger audience and provide a real youth discount is now causing them problems. They can fix it by not being so greedy. I hope we can still do something with our DL. Is this really a coaching problem and not a player problem? I'm starting wonder if this defensive line scheme will work here.
Only registered users can write comments!
  • Blog

  • Articles

  • Around the Web

more RSS feed
moreRSS feed


View Magazine Front
2014 Buccaneers Future Forecast 2014 Buccaneers Future Forecast After a disappointing 2013 season, the Buccaneers are about to embark on the beginning of the 2014 offseason. PewterReport.com breaks down the team’s free agents and salary cap room and previews what’s ahead for Tampa ... [+] Read more
Missed an Issue? Archive
View Magazine Front


What two guards should start for the Buccaneers?

Pewter Report: Your source for inside and breaking news on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Hide Tools Show Tools