Home » PR Reacts » Articles » PR's All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 1-5
  • increase font size
  • Default font size
  • decrease font size

July 11, 2014 @ 11:46 am
Current rating: 4.00 Stars/1 Votes

PR's All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 1-5

Written by Pewter
Report Staff
Pewter Report Staff

Report Staff

Staff E-mail: This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it
PewterReport.com ranks the 25 All-Time Greatest Buccaneers in this five-part series. Who is the greatest player in team history –Lee Roy Selmon, Warren Sapp or Derrick Brooks? Find out as we rank players 1-5 in this installment.
Recent inductions into the Pro Football Hall of Fame and the Buccaneers Ring of Honor, in addition to the emergence of some star players on Tampa Bay’s current team has prompted PewterReport.com to review the careers and rank the 25 best players in Buccaneers history. In this five-part series, PewterReport.com’s Scott Reynolds and Mark Cook analyze each Buccaneer legend and offer their own commentary on some of the most beloved players in Tampa Bay history.

Some of the rankings – and omissions – are sure to cause some controversy among Bucs fans. PewterReport.com wants to hear from you, and Bucs fans are encouraged to leave their opinions in the article comments section, on the PewterReport.com message boards and on PewterReport.com’s Twitter page.

In Friday’s installment, PewterReport.com concludes this five-part series by introducing the all-time greatest Buccaneers ranked 1-5.

PewterReport.com’s All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 1-5

5. Buccaneers MLB Hardy Nickerson – 1993-1999
By Scott Reynolds

No one “willed” the Buccaneers into winners like Nickerson did in the mid-1990s. His arrival from Pittsburgh, a playoff team, in 1993 sparked a culture change that helped turn the franchise around and into a perennial postseason contender. Nickerson’s leadership and competitiveness set the ultimate example for players like defensive tackle Warren Sapp, linebacker Derrick Brooks, strong safety John Lynch and cornerback Ronde Barber, who developed into Bucs legends under Nickerson’s guidance.

The Compton, Calif. native was an elite player in Tampa Bay and became a five-time Pro Bowler. Nickerson set the franchise record with 214 tackles in 1993 – a record that still stands today. Nickerson, who was one of the most intellectual and hardest-working players in Tampa Bay, also became the first Bucs defender to top 1,000 tackles in his career, and his 1,028 stops rank third in team history behind only Barber (1,428) and Brooks (2,198). Nicknamed “Hardware” by the players, Nickerson also contributed 13 forced fumbles, nine fumble recoveries, nine sacks and seven interceptions in red and pewter.

Nickerson was a beloved figure in Tampa Bay due to the toughness and swagger he brought to the Buccaneers. Fans are enthused about his return to Tampa Bay as the team’s linebackers coach on Lovie Smith’s staff. His overall impact on the franchise as a member of the famed 1997 and 1999 defenses cements Nickerson’s status as one of the top 5 Greatest All-Time Buccaneers.

SR’s Take: “Nickerson was the ultimate seek-and-destroy linebacker in Tampa Bay and is truly a legend for helping to lay the foundation that ultimately resulted in the Buccaneers becoming Super Bowl champions in 2002 despite his departure after the 1999 season. Nickerson and his ‘Incredible Hulk’ poses excited and fueled the crowd and his aggressive style of play helped him became an instant fan favorite.”

For a Hardy Nickerson highlight video, click here.

4. Buccaneers CB Ronde Barber – 1997-2012
By Scott Reynolds

In ranking the All-Time Greatest Buccaneers, Barber has moved his way past Nickerson and into the fourth spot behind the franchise’s three members of the Pro Football Hall of Fame – defensive end Lee Roy Selmon, defensive tackle Warren Sapp and linebacker Derrick Brooks. With a legendary, 16-year career – the longest of any Tampa Bay player – Barber seems destined to join those three with his own enshrinement in Canton, Ohio in a few years.

Barber, a five-time Pro Bowler, is the franchise’s all-time interceptor with 47 picks. He also amassed 200 pass deflections and 12 defensive touchdowns – both team records – in addition to 28 sacks and a safety in red and pewter. Barber became the first player in NFL history to record 40 interceptions and 20 sacks, and his 14 non-offensive touchdowns (including two blocked punts returned for touchdowns) are the fourth-most in NFL history behind Devin Hester and Deion Sanders (19 each) and defensive back Rod Woodson (17). He’s also one of only two players (linebacker Shelton Quarles) to record a defensive touchdown and a safety as a Buccaneer.

Barber, who is blessed with incredible instincts and intelligence, is remembered for his epic 92-yard interception return for a touchdown in the 2002 NFC Championship Game that helped propel the Bucs to Super Bowl XXXVII. That play is widely regarded as the most important play in team history. In addition to his interceptions, sacks, touchdowns and his Super Bowl ring, Barber has more starts (232) and games played (241) than any other Buccaneer and didn’t miss a start in his final 13 years. The toughest Buccaneer pound-for-pound, Barber is the second-leading tackler in team history with 1,428 and defined the nickel cornerback position in the NFL.

SR’s Take: “Barber is the epitome of the word ‘class’ – on and off the field, and he and Nickerson were my favorite player to cover during my nearly two decades of reporting on the Buccaneers. Having the leading role in the best and most significant play in Tampa Bay history endeared Barber to the hearts of all Bucs fans.”

For a Ronde Barber video, click here.

3. Buccaneers DE Lee Roy Selmon – 1976-1984
By Mark Cook

Lee Roy Selmon was the very first superstar in the history of the franchise. Selmon was a dynamic football player but maybe an even better human being. As the very first draft pick in franchise history out of Oklahoma in 1976 the expectations and pressure to turn an expansion franchise into a winner were huge but Selmon did his part. As a rookie Selmon struggled with some injuries, missing six games, but was still named the team’s MVP.

But the player Selmon was to become really began in 1978 as he was named first- or second-team All-Pro five times over the next seven years. He also was also All-NFC choice five times, and selected to six straight Pro Bowls up until his final season in 1984.

Four times the NFL Players Association named Lee Roy the NFC Defensive Lineman of the Year and he was a unanimous choice as NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 1979. Selmon was a major force in the Bucs' first winning season, which was ended with a 9-0 loss to the Los Angeles Rams in the 1979 NFC Championship Game. Selmon had 11 sacks and a career-best 117 tackles that year. A back injury suffered in the 1984 Pro Bowl, which forced him to miss the entire 1985 season, ended an outstanding career that led to him being selected as the Buccaneers first member of the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 1995.

Cook’s Take: “Lee Roy was one of the most humble players to ever play for the franchise and obviously one of the most talented. It was a shame that the back injury he suffered put an end to a career that could have possibly eclipsed the 100-sack mark. Even with a shorted career Selmon is still the franchise sack leader. I spent 15 minutes interviewing Lee Roy out back of the old One Buc Place back in the mid-90’s and he talked to me, a nobody radio station reporter, like I was the most important person in the world. It is something I will always cherish.”

For a Lee Roy Selmon highlight video, click here.

2. Buccaneers DT Warren Sapp – 1995-2003
By Scott Reynolds

Sapp brought ferociousness, swagger and toughness to the Buccaneers defense upon his arrival as a first-round pick in 1995, as well as uncanny athleticism and quickness to the famed under tackle position in the Tampa 2 defense. Sapp’s name must be mentioned with the likes of John Randle in terms of defining the three-technique defensive tackle and his greatness was recognized as a first-ballot Hall of Famer in 2013.

Sapp, who was enshrined in the Buccaneers Ring of Honor this year, helped linebackers Hardy Nickerson and Derrick Brooks change the culture at One Buccaneer Place and turn the Yuccaneers into Buccaneers in the late 1990s and was the driving force behind the team’s famed Super Bowl season in 2002. Nicknamed “The QB Killa,” Sapp posted three double-digit sack seasons, including a franchise-record 16.5 quarterback captures in 2000, and he was also named the NFL’s Defensive Player of the Year in 1999 as the Bucs marched into the NFC Championship Game.

The Apopka native, who is a member of both the NFL’s All-Decade Teams in the 1990s and 2000s, had seven straight Pro Bowl appearances from 1997-2003, including from straight All Pro berths from 1999-2002. Sapp’s 77 sacks rank second in Buccaneers history behind Lee Roy Selmon’s 78.5, and he also contributed 19 forced fumbles, 12 fumble recoveries, four interception, including one he returned for a touchdown. Sapp’s five playoff appearances, including a Super Bowl title in 2002, push him past Selmon on the list of All-Time Greatest Buccaneers now that No. 99 has become a Hall of Famer.

SR’s Take: “Sapp gets plenty of accolades for his on-field success on Sundays, but where he provided tremendous value to the Buccaneers under both Tony Dungy and Jon Gruden was his high motor during practice. Sapp loved to practice like no other, and his ultra-competitiveness during the week made his teammates on offense and defense better players come game day.”

For a Warren Sapp highlight video, click here.

1. Buccaneers OLB Derrick Brooks – 1995-2008
By Scott Reynolds

If there was any question that Brooks is the best player in Buccaneers history that was answered with his enshrinement into the Pro Football Hall of Fame this year. With that distinction, no other Buccaneer has accomplished more than Brooks has in his famed 14-year career in Tampa Bay. Brooks set the records for most games started (221) and played (224) until cornerback Ronde Barber broke them in 2012. But it wasn’t longevity that made Brooks special – it was his ultra-high level of play on the gridiron.

Brooks was an 11-time Pro Bowler and a five-time first-team All Pro – both franchise records. The Florida State product also won the NFL Defensive Player of the Year in 2002, which was the same year he became a Super Bowl champion, and won the Walter Payton Man of the Year honors in 2000. In Super Bowl XXXVII, Brooks’ 44-yard interception return for a touchdown helped clinch Tampa Bay’s 48-21 victory over Oakland.

Brooks, who is the franchise’s all-time leading tackler with 2,198 stops, logged 25 interceptions, posted 24 forced fumbles, had 13.5 sacks, and recovered four fumbles in his illustrious Tampa Bay career. His seven defensive touchdowns rank, including four during the 2002 campaign, rank second in franchise history behind Ronde Barber’s 12. Brooks, who was Tampa Bay’s leading tackler for five seasons, was named to the NFL’s All-Decade Team of the 2000s and was the Pro Bowl MVP in 2005. He will also be the latest member of the Bucs’ Ring of Honor later this year.

SR’s Take: “A great person, a great player, a great athlete, a great community philanthropist, a great leader, a great man and a great Buccaneer. That’s the legend of Derrick Brooks. If you were to start an NFL franchise, Brooks would be the player you would want to lead your team. Tampa Bay was blessed to experience the sheer greatness that made Brooks the greatest Buccaneer of all time.”

For a Derrick Brooks highlight video, click here.

PewterReport.com’s 25 All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 21-25
PewterReport.com’s 25 All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 16-20
PewterReport.com’s 25 All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 11-15
PewterReport.com’s 25 All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 6-10
PewterReport.com’s 25 All-Time Greatest Buccaneers: 1-5

Last modified on Friday, 11 July 2014 13:58

Only registered users can rate articles!


  • avatar

    Brooks definitely is worthy of being a 1-3 pick. Really you can interchange Sapp, Selmon and Brooks as the best Buc. Even though Sapp was way rough around the edges, I have to say he was the face of the franchise nationally and think he should be at the top spot. But then again, Sapp's head (and mouth) are already big enough. As far as all,around off the field and on the field, then Brooks is your guy. Man was he skinny looking coming out of high school - they feed 'em good at FSU don't they?
  • avatar

    I welcome an editor from PR to come to my site and offer up an explanation to this... How could Pewter Report do a Top 25 Bucs of all time without including Doug Williams? The debate ensues!! http://bucstop.com/uncategorized/pewter-reports-top-25-all-time-bucs-omits-doug-williams.html
  • avatar

    Leaving off Doug Williams is a joke and political. I don't want to hear about his completion % because Bradshaws is just as bad. This was a pre west coast era, everyone had lower % back then. Williams was asked to throw low completion passes. He improved each year, and the team rallied around him. How many wins did Bucs have after he was allowed to leave? For 14 years? You have players on the list with good numbers who didn't mean anything to the Bucs like Doug Williams. You couldn't even mention his name when you listed Jimmy Giles acquisition. Doug can bea tough person to defend some times, but no more so than Sapp. Stats are for losers. Doug , and the Bucs when he played for them, we're winners. How many of your OrangeBucs would you be writing about had Doug Williams not played in Tampa Bay?
  • avatar

    Angelina or Jennifer? C'mon. if I was BP I would have found a way to have both! Horse_ you're showing your age man. Angelina would be my pick but not because of helping others..I'm sure Jen does as well. Anyways, I pick Selmon and even though SCUBOG makes good points I disagree with his "defining" a position. That statement is overused way to much IMO. I do think that the top 5 could go either way and dream of what it could've been to have the top 10 playing right now. Thanks PR it was an entertaining week going back and reliving some great Bucs.
  • avatar

    jme0151: If you and others (including Hugh Culverhouse) are going to speak with high regard of Lee Roy Selmon, you should at least spell his name right. Having been a fan since 1976, it's hard for me to try to rank these top five in a proper order so as to not offend anyone. But I really see the point of I Love Me Some Fire. Warren Sapp absolutely defined the DT position by which all future ones will be compared. Brooks absolutely defined the WLB position that will be the benchmark for others to follow. Barber may have defined the nickle CB position that may never be repeated. That puts these three, not just in the top five of Buccaneers, but the top five in the league. As much as I loved Lee Roy (picture of me in his living room is hanging on my wall behind me), as great as he was, I don't think he defined the DE position, nor do I think he is as highly regarding on a national scale as Sapp and Brooks. Horse: It wasn't the surgery that Lee Roy feared. When Lee Roy told me about the back injury it had not yet been made public. He told me he feared the anesthesia because he had a previous bad experience. Every time I had the chance to see him he was always so gracious. Nothing like that boorish Sapp. But this piece isn't about class. But if it was, we'd have to choose between Selmon or Brooks. That's the Brad Pitt Dilemma; Hmmmm Angelina or Jennifer? Me, I'll take Jennifer. What say you Horse?
  • avatar

    Angelina; done more to help others.
  • avatar

    Rather than take issue with one poster in particular (other than the 'politics' comment which was a low class, undeserved cheap shot), I will just say that while Lynch was more of a glam/fan favorite, Barber's contribution to the team's success, to me, was clearly more significant. Personally I continue to believe Saap was more dominant, on a play by play basis, than anyone who has ever been a Buccaneer. But total respect for all of the top 5. Can't wait for the season to begin!
  • avatar

    matador, that's not a cheap slap and I would not call it low class. Get real with the politics; it's there. If Lee Roy Selmon was alive I bet you anything he would have been No. 1. Selmon was unstoppable; double/trible teamed. Everybody else from time to time were one on one and were handled. Not Lee Roy Selmon; he was unique. He got hurt in an Pro Bowl game and that was it for him. IR the next year and he retired because he didn't want the surgery. The Man was a Man on and off the field. Brooks is too, but Lee Roy Selmon had no impact players around him. Back then; they took the Pro Bowl more seriously. Lee Roy lost 3-4 years of play time for a useless game. Bar none; Lee Roy Selmon will always be the best of the best Buccaneers. My opinion. Yeah I guess I am low class for defending Lee Roy Selmon as he was beyond amazing. I have watched my Bucs since 1976 and he was beyond the best ever. Pewter Report got it wrong. An insult to put him behind Sapp who by the way said Selmon was the best Buc ever.
  • avatar

    I can't believe Doug Williams, Ricky Bell, Joey Galloway, and Hugh Green were not on here... but Kevin House and Karl Williams are. Not a knock on those two as they are definitely a pair of the greatest Bucs of all time. But better, more significant, more impactful than Williams? Bell? Galloway? I have a hard time with that.
  • avatar

    I don't care about rankings......only one I do see is Leroy Selmon as MR. BUC!
  • avatar

    How many pro bowls did Lynch have; how many did Barber have. Barber was a great support team player. Selmon, Brooks, Sapp, Lynch, Rice, Nickerson, Green, were defensive impact players from the get go; Barber was not. Giles, Farrell, Wilder, Gruber, and Doug Williams were offensive impact players from the get go. Some of these player had no support around them at all.
  • avatar

    I am very surprised about House and Carl Williams.
  • avatar

    How many pro bowls did Lynch have; how many did Barber have. Barber was a great support team player. Selmon, Brooks, Sapp, Lynch, Rice, Nickerson, Green, were defensive impact players from the get go; Barber was not. Giles, Farrell, Wilder and Doug Williams were offensive impact players from the get go. Some of these player had no support around them at all.
  • avatar

    I think you guys got it right... First off Barber is right where he needs to be because he is by far our best CB of all time and set records at his position to make him one of the best CBs of all time in the NFL and is a future HOF'er... Second off you could make an argument for Selmon to be #2 or # 1 but Sapp was not only our best DT of all time but was the best DT in the NFL of all time... The same goes for Brooks that he was not only our best LB of all time but might also be the best WLB in the NFL of all time ... So although Selmon was our best DE of all time the fact that Sapp and Brooks have more of an argument for being the best at their position ever in the league gives them the slight nudge to put them over... You could say they all tie for #1 but to me those facts are what rounds out the top 3... Great rankings guys...
  • avatar

    How many pro bowls did Lynch have; how many did Barber have. Barber was a great support team player. Selmon, Brooks, Sapp, Lynch, Rice, Nickerson, Green, were defensive impact players from the get go; Barber was not. Giles, Farrell, Wilder and Doug Williams were offensive impact players from the get go. Some of these player had no support around them too.
  • avatar

    No Doug Williams anywhere?
  • avatar

    It would be interesting to compare this list with a list of the top Seahawks, since they came into the league with us. Both franchises have Super Bowls. Of course, Seattle has more overall wins than the Bucs over our mutual history. Yet, in looking at our list, I cannot believe the Seahawks have had as many outstanding individual players as the Bucs, even though Bucs teams didn't produce as many wins.
  • avatar

    Nobody could stop Lee Roy Selmon; nobody, but I do understand the Super Bowl probably over rides it. Rhonde is too high, but I understand the politics. Some of the bottom 20-25 I have some issues with like no Hugh Green, Shawn Farrell.
  • avatar

    have no idea why you think barber is too high on this lis but thats your opinion. Guy only played for us for 16 years, was probably the best tackling corner of all time. Made plays time after time after time, sealed our ticket to our only super bowl victory, was the first player EVER in NFL history to have 40 ints and over 25 sacks. id say that barber is well deserving of his overall status.
  • avatar

    This is why I HATE these kind of "opinions." In ranking players like HOFamers Brooks, Sapp and Selmon are you REALLY typing that Lee Roy Selmon is LESS than any other Buccaneer? That ANY of the three are LESS THAN each other? The pinnacle is the National Football League Hall of Fame. There IS no LESS THAN after that. Lee Roy Selmon THIRD best? Freaking ludicrous and frankly insulting to his memory IMO.
  • avatar

    Really Garv? A subjective piece where any of the top 3 are interchangeable and you are going to complain? You have your Top 3, I have mine, SR has his, Ryan24 has his, Uncle Stan has his and so on... there isn't any science behind it, so why get so upset? Beatles or Zeppelin? Kate Upton or Christie Brinkley? Ford or Chevy? Larry, Moe or Curly? See my point?
  • avatar

    Well sapp and brooks are in the hall of fame..brooks may not be going in until this season, but hes still a HOF player....i never saw selmon play, but considering that brooks and sapp both are going into the HOF AND have both won a super bowl, i have 0 issues with this. its not insulting to Selmons memory that he isnt the number one buc of all time. Sapp and Brooks were catalysts in putting the Bucs on the map and quite honestly are 2 of the 4 reasons i became a fan in 98-99 when is was 10-11 years old. this was opinionated and thats all any of these lists are. however, as great as selmon was, its hard to argue against hardware when your talking about all time greats in ANY sport.
  • avatar

    I would say that you all pretty much got it right. It has been a thrill to watch these Bucs play..
Only registered users can write comments!
  • Blog

  • Articles

  • Around the Web

more RSS feed
moreRSS feed


View Magazine Front
The Buccaneers’ Christmas Wish List The Buccaneers’ Christmas Wish List The Bucs may be on Santa’s naughty list after posting a worse record in 2013 than the team did last year, but they might as well make a Christmas wish list anyways to get some ... [+] Read more
Missed an Issue? Archive
View Magazine Front


What two guards should start for the Buccaneers?

Pewter Report: Your source for inside and breaking news on the Tampa Bay Buccaneers

Hide Tools Show Tools