Post count: 2560

This is a tough question to answer. On one hand the safety position is under-represented. Otoh he is not the best safety not in the Hall. I’d go Shell, Robinson then either Lynch or Atwater. Harris, while good, was probably never one of the 5 best on the Dallas defense. Cherry it’s ver close. But only 6 Pro Bowls. Of course Robinson was only 7 and Shell 5 so you get 9 and a championship and you can make a very strong case. But I don’t buy the if there’s a doubt then no argument. Lynch would not be the weakest player if he was chosen.

Please wait…