Anonymous

Inactive
Post count: 648

How did that pro style offense translate for Ponder and Manuel ??

I don't really have a dog in this fight and am actually leaning more toward Mariota but you can't compare Manuel and Ponder to Winston.. He has a way better skill set than either of those two guys.. Ponder LOL!

Actually you CAN compare them , in the context I am doing it .Both of those guys were 1st round picks , who became 1st rounders partly because of how "pro ready" they supposedly were . If people are going to use the "pro ready" argument as a reason Winston is SUPPOSEDLY superior to Mariota , I am going to call bullshlt and point to the other highly rated QB's from that school who were clearly NOT ready afterall , and fell on their faces.Jimbo's system has a piss poor record of making pro QB's in actuality, even going back to JaMarcus Russell , so spare me that argument . Judge these guys on their own merit , not systems.

Hey i would love to hire you as a sales guy but there is no comparison between those three qbs. If Winston wasn't a knucklehead his skill set is perfect for the nfl. I don't think he is smart enough to be great at the next level. I am also not convinced mariota can step up in the pocket and make throws but i would rather go with the high character smart kid. We have to try something!

Please wait…