Pewter Report’s PR Roundtable
presented by PrizePicks
Sign up for PrizePicks with code: HMA then play a $5 lineup and get $50 in bonus lineups by clicking HERE.
A new Pewter Report Roundtable debuts every Tuesday on PewterReport.com. Each week, the Pewter Reporters tackle another tough Bucs question. This week’s prompt: Which player can help the Bucs upset the Lions?
Scott Reynolds: Bucs Will Need An INT From Zyon McCollum

Bucs CBs Zyon McCollum and Keionte Scott – Photo by: Cliff Welch/PR
McCollum will have his hands full in Detroit against Jameson Williams and Amon-Ra St. Brown. Both of those Lions receivers have had big days against the Buccaneers in the past. Not only does McCollum need to prevent either receiver he is covering from going off, he also needs to continue his interception streak and pick off Goff on Sunday. If Tampa Bay can win the turnover margin in Detroit thanks to McCollum, the Bucs should have a good shot at winning their first game after the bye week.
Matt Matera: It Needs To Be The Bucky Irving Show
Bucs running back Bucky Irving has been the driving force for any success that Tampa Bay’s offense has had this season. He’s top five in the league in rushing and has constantly been making big plays. If the Bucs are going to win, they have to lean on Irving once again.

Bucs RB Bucky Irving – Photo by: IMAGN Images via Reuters Connect
Due to the uncertainty of who’s playing quarterback for the Bucs, there’s even more of an emphasis to run the ball with their star running back. And if the Bucs are going to win this game, they are going to have to control the time of possession by keeping the Lions’ high powered offense on the sidelines. That’s where having Irving is a necessity.
Tampa Bay will have opportunities to run the ball against this Detroit defensive unit. Typically, when a team wins a ball game, their best player is a big reason why. Irving is hands down the best player on Tampa Bay’s offense and needs to be fed the ball early and often.
Adam Slivon: Vita Vea Must Be At His Best Against Lions

Bucs DTs A’Shawn Robinson, Vita Vea and Calijah Kancey – Photo by: Cliff Welch/PR
I look at Vea as a critical part of the operation in stifling Gibbs, but also in collapsing the pocket against Jared Goff. Goff is as efficient as they come and is cool as a cucumber under pressure. Affecting his throws gets a little easier when a 350-pound behemoth sheds his block and races after him. The entire front seven has to be on its “A” game, but the leader of the group — by seniority and salary — remains Vita Vea.
Bailey Adams: Bucs’ MVP Chase McLaughlin Could Be The Difference
If we know one thing about the Bucs in the last 365 days, it’s that they tend to find themselves in tight games no matter who they play. Seven of the team’s nine games in the 2026 season have been decided by a single possession, and from Nov. 16 through the end of last season, it was also seven out of nine games that were single-score contests.
So, even though they’re 3-6 and headed into a tough environment in Detroit to play the 7-2 Lions, I think these Bucs are going to be in a close game yet again coming out of their bye week. And in a close game, I think Chase McLaughlin could be the difference maker that helps swing things in Tampa Bay’s favor for the upset.

Bucs K Chase McLaughlin – Photo by: USA Today
McLaughlin is 22-of-22 on field goals this year, and with the inconsistency of the Buccaneer offense and the possibility of undrafted rookie quarterback Jalon Daniels making his fourth start of the season in place of Baker Mayfield, Tampa Bay might need its kicker to be a weapon from distance in order to beat the Lions. A couple of 50+ yard field goals may just be the difference, and who knows? Maybe playing indoors at Ford Field could put McLaughlin in a situation where he can boot one from 60+ yards out. That could be a weapon for Todd Bowles’ team as it eyes a road upset.
Josh Queipo: Emeka Egbuka HAS To Step Up
The Bucs now have a question mark at quarterback. And with the signing of Cooper Rush to the practice squad and Easton Stick moving to the active roster the signal is that Baker Mayfield is not going to start. No matter who the quarterback is they are going to need a receiver to step up and become a reliable playmaking option.

Bucs WR Emeka Egbuka – Photo by: IMAGN Images via Reuters Connect
Enter Egbuka, who has just 31 catches for 278 yards and two touchdowns. His 40 yards per game average is significantly down from his rookie campaign. His catch rate is up slightly from last year’s sub-50% mark, but it’s still not in the range it should be for a receiver that a quarterback to reliably count on beyond 10 yards down the field.
The Lions offense will test the Bucs’ defense, and the smart money is on Tampa Bay needing more than 24 points to pull out a win in Detroit. They will need more than their impressive run game to get those points. And no matter who is lining up under center, Egbuka will have to find ways to get open and pull in throws to keep the offense on time and ahead of the sticks.
Nick Geddes: Baker Mayfield Or Jalon Daniels Must Show Up
It’s the nature of the current state of the NFL that if you’re going to upset one of the best teams in the league, then you need to have adequate quarterback play. Unfortunately, that’s something the Bucs haven’t gotten enough of in 2026.
Sunday’s contest in Detroit presents a favorable matchup for Tampa Bay’s passing attack if the quarterback and receivers are up for it. The Lions are 26th in EPA on defense and they are 25th against the pass. They are dealing with significant injuries on that side of the ball, from linebacker Jack Campbell to defensive end Aidan Hutchinson. The Bucs, however, are last in EPA per pass, so while it might be wishful thinking that it will suddenly click, I struggle to see how Tampa Bay can simply ground and pound its way to victory.

Bucs QB Baker Mayfield and RG Ben Bredeson – Photo by: Cliff Welch/PR
Of course, we still don’t know which quarterback will be under center come Sunday. Baker Mayfield’s status is in doubt due to a new lower leg injury. If he can’t go, Jalon Daniels will make his fourth start of the season. Whoever it is, limiting turnovers and mistakes will be key, as it is in every game.
If Mayfield does go, you would expect his mobility to be limited, so being able to get the ball out quick and on time will be of high priority. Again, that’s been an issue for much of this season, but it has to change for the Bucs to have a shot in Detroit. Hopefully a less than 100 percent Mayfield is up for the challenge.



