Football Perspectiv...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Football Perspective on Mike Glennon and Geno Smith

36 Posts
23 Users
0 Reactions
619 Views
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

He has the potential to be a Top 15 QB.

Does he?  I'm not sure

that's accurate

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 10:32 am
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I think it is way too early to determine how good or bad Glennon will be.He has shown flashes of potential and at the same time made some goddamn awful mistakes at the same time. If nothing else that article demonstrates that a QB's rookie season may or may not be indicative of his career path.

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 12:00 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

Let's throw away another third down....

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 12:06 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

Benchwarmer#1: "Freeman goes 27th in any statistical category and it's fire the bum.Glennon does it, ...and excuses are made."Too dumb to tell the difference between a rookie and a fifth year veteran

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 1:04 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

these numbers tell us nothing about what route these guys careers will take.

That's exactly what several people have been saying all year in response to those who tout Glennon's "record breaking" rookie numbers.

and vice versa

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 1:07 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

Good question, but I would have to say no.Schiano's system protected him from the real qb world. If he has to go out there to win games in another guy's more complex/demanding system, he will be worse than average.

I suppose you realize there is at least the possibility you have it exactly backwards, right? In other words, Schiano's "system" could have just as easily held him back and it seems that a complex system would not be as much an issue, right?  He is supposed very bright?Who knows who is right on this one, its just too soon to say with any certainty . .  although that doesn't stop many lol

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 1:10 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I don't get the Glennon hate...  Doesn't make any logical sense given the situation.Meh - to each his own.

 
Posted : Feb. 19, 2014 9:32 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

Benchwarmer#1: "Freeman goes 27th in any statistical category and it's fire the bum.Glennon does it, ...and excuses are made."Too dumb to tell the difference between a rookie and a fifth year veteran

You act like all fifth year vets, play like fifth year vets.Glennon did nothing in my eyes that says he should be the qb going forward.

 
Posted : Feb. 20, 2014 2:07 am
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I don't get the Glennon hate...  Doesn't make any logical sense given the situation.Meh - to each his own.

Haters gonna hate , as they say...

 
Posted : Feb. 20, 2014 8:30 am
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

Stats tell us very little about a QB. The eye test is even more important with QB's. The problem lies there in. Some people put their eye on JFF and are blown away. Some put their eye on him and are underwhelmed. It's just so subjective.

 
Posted : Feb. 20, 2014 10:04 am
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I don't get the Glennon hate...  Doesn't make any logical sense given the situation.Meh - to each his own.

Is there any Glennon hate?

 
Posted : Feb. 20, 2014 11:10 am
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I don't get the Glennon hate...  Doesn't make any logical sense given the situation.Meh - to each his own.

Is there any Glennon hate?

while hate is a strong word, I don't think calling Glennon a giraffe or napolean dynamite clone are endearing pictures being painted. Just not sure why people can't sit back and see what a real coaching staff (we hope) will determine with where the Bucs are at, and can #8 be the guy. (the plus is, then that #7 pick can be used on another hole, like OL, DE, LB, or trade down to recoup picks and get a TE and maybe a third round pick plus a late round pick)If Tedford and Lovie determine that Glennon is incapable of leading the team, we will see another qb.

 
Posted : Feb. 20, 2014 11:55 am
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

What a stupid article. Glennon doesnt compare to gradkowski in the least bit. This is why 120 pound SABR nerds whove never touched a football, shouldnt be allowed to analyze the game. Statistics/numbers without a sharp football mind behind them lead to misleading assertions

 
Posted : Feb. 22, 2014 12:51 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I think it is way too early to determine how good or bad Glennon will be.He has shown flashes of potential and at the same time made some goddamn awful mistakes at the same time. If nothing else that article demonstrates that a QB's rookie season may or may not be indicative of his career path.

Honestly - to me - Glennon has shown flashes when he wasn't terrible.  Not the same as showing potential to become a NFL starting qb. 

 
Posted : Feb. 22, 2014 4:00 pm
F807B5609Eae64257Bf4877652Ea49Fee40Ac2451C152C12Fa596Ffeda647157?S=110&D=Mm&R=G
(@Anonymous)
Posts: 0
Cabin Boy Guest
 

I think it is way too early to determine how good or bad Glennon will be.He has shown flashes of potential and at the same time made some goddamn awful mistakes at the same time. If nothing else that article demonstrates that a QB's rookie season may or may not be indicative of his career path.

Honestly - to me - Glennon has shown flashes when he wasn't terrible.  Not the same as showing potential to become a NFL starting qb.

He's shown more than just not being bad. He has shown big time NFL ability and not just really intermittent flashes like a Gradkowski. The problem for me isn't that he hasn't shown he can start but that he hasn't shown me enough flashes to say he is more than a Flacco/Dalton level starter. Yes, playoff capable but always a "problem" once you get there - and I know Flacco won a SB but he also went unconscious doing so and played in a way he has never played before.

 
Posted : Feb. 22, 2014 4:07 pm
Page 2 / 3
Share: