I don't think you can go wrong with any of the 3 QBs. I don't think you can go wrong with Barkley tbh.
He'll get denied just like Jeanty...
Which btw, I don't care what anyone says Travis Hunter should not have won Heisman.
Barkley probably would have gotten it if Hurts didn’t vulture his TDs
lamar deserved it, allen is probably going to get it unless barkley breaks the rushing record and they give it to him as a compromise
"What is unusual and sets Burrow apart from his Pro Bowl peers, however, is that he has thrown for a league-leading 4,641 yards and 42 touchdowns, along with the fifth-lowest interception rate and the fifth-highest completion percentage, despite playing on a fringe playoff contender."
Josh Allen for MVP. He's done A LOT more with less than either Jackson or Burrow.
Hard to argue against this. However, Jackson is exciting to watch, especially with the improvement in his passing accuracy.
Josh Allen for MVP. He's done A LOT more with less than either Jackson or Burrow.
Hard to argue against this. However, Jackson is exciting to watch, especially with the improvement in his passing accuracy.
it probably is Allen
They are all great. I posted the Burrow info because he's done all of that on a bad team. Bills are 13 -3. Bengals .500?
Definitely NOT a knock on Allen and the Burrow info comes from an article pointing out that the MVP winner is often from a successful team
Jackson might get the lebron MVP fatigue.
And if I'm a ravens fan I want him to lose
The only reason Jackson wouldn’t win it this year is because he’s already won it twice. As good as Allen is, Jackson’s numbers are better all around.
I can't argue with the first four, but come on four players tied for 5th? Lame.Mine looks like this:
1a - Jackson
1b - Allen
1c - Burrow
4 - Barkley
5 - Baker/Darnold/Chase/Goff
Goff has the highest rating of the three QBs, but he has the most weapons. I like Bucky, but Gibbs is on another level. Baker has the best O-line in the league IMO, and he really relies on that. Darnold has a great WR in Jefferson, but in general his team has overachieved to a 14-2 record. Chase is incredible dominating in every catch category and zero fumbles.
5 Chase
6 Darnold
7 Mayfield
8 Goff
"What is unusual and sets Burrow apart from his Pro Bowl peers, however, is that he has thrown for a league-leading 4,641 yards and 42 touchdowns, along with the fifth-lowest interception rate and the fifth-highest completion percentage, despite playing on a fringe playoff contender."
I can't prove it, but I suspect Burrow has been able to pad his stats with extra possessions and playing from behind because of that God-awful defense in Cincinnati. He also has two top WRs in Chase and Higgins, and a pretty decent RB in Brown.
I can't argue with the first four, but come on four players tied for 5th? Lame.Mine looks like this:
1a - Jackson
1b - Allen
1c - Burrow
4 - Barkley
5 - Baker/Darnold/Chase/Goff
Goff has the highest rating of the three QBs, but he has the most weapons. I like Bucky, but Gibbs is on another level. Baker has the best O-line in the league IMO, and he really relies on that. Darnold has a great WR in Jefferson, but in general his team has overachieved to a 14-2 record. Chase is incredible dominating in every catch category and zero fumbles.
5 Chase
6 Darnold
7 Mayfield
8 Goff
I don't have any qualms with your ranking I just think the top 4 are way above the next 4.
I'd go:
Goff
Baker
Chase
Darnold
My reasoning is simple: Chase and Burrow can't both be that high with 8 wins... This is like Colorado with Sanders and Hunter wanting Heisman. You gotta win more games.
Goff and Baker have god awful defenses and have to carry more. Both have weapons.
Darnold has played great but they have avoided injuries and have a pretty dominant defense.
So that's the reasoning for my order. Goff has played amazing and yes he has weapons and elite play calling but so do all of these 4.
"What is unusual and sets Burrow apart from his Pro Bowl peers, however, is that he has thrown for a league-leading 4,641 yards and 42 touchdowns, along with the fifth-lowest interception rate and the fifth-highest completion percentage, despite playing on a fringe playoff contender."
I can't prove it, but I suspect Burrow has been able to pad his stats with extra possessions and playing from behind because of that God-awful defense in Cincinnati. He also has two top WRs in Chase and Higgins, and a pretty decent RB in Brown.
Oh of course but the same can be said of Goff and Baker needing to score plenty as well. They aren't playing from behind as much tho
