QB Carousel 2023 ga...
 
Notifications
Clear all

QB Carousel 2023 game

106 Posts
19 Users
11 Reactions
8,136 Views
Avatar Of Badabingbucs
(@badabingbucs)
Posts: 2629
Quartermaster
 

Posted by: @alldaway

Cooper Rush is not bad working the short game.  But if you want to push the ball downfield you go with Case Kennum. Heineke and White are better but they may attract a lot of money which puts the Bucs out of contention for either one. 

 

if these are our best options, just go with trask and gabbert and hope for top pick to get potential next burrow, Lawrence, Hebert, Allen, mahomes 

 

give me rodgers, carr or jimmy G or give me absolute tank, cap freedom in 2024

 


 
Posted : Feb. 4, 2023 1:39 pm
Alldaway 2.0
(@alldaway)
Posts: 1587
Quartermaster
 

Trask will compete with one those UFA QBs and let the best man win the job. 


 
Posted : Feb. 4, 2023 5:51 pm
Avatar Of Donkey_Hunter
(@donkey_hunter)
Posts: 4776
Captain
 

Posted by: @alldaway

But if you want to push the ball downfield you go with Case Kennum

Based on what?

Please don't use the outlier year he had in MIN.


 
Posted : Feb. 4, 2023 9:31 pm
Alldaway 2.0
(@alldaway)
Posts: 1587
Quartermaster
 

I like what I have seen from Kennum when he was a Bronco.  To me he is a good player to bring in to push Trask.

https://heavy.com/sports/buffalo-bills/bills-case-keenum-commanders-starting-job/


 
Posted : Feb. 5, 2023 7:03 pm
Avatar Of Badabingbucs
(@badabingbucs)
Posts: 2629
Quartermaster
 

While I would hope trask can grab the bull by the horns here, the fact of the matter is the only reason he was 3rd string is that his draft status would keep him off practice squad over griffin 

he was likely closer to 4th string then he was 2nd

not his fault, just had a limited ceiling 

 

let’s see what happens with Carr and jimmy G. If we can’t land one of those, just tank for a franchise QB in 2024. what’s better? Go 6-11 with jacoby brissett and miss out on top pick, go 3-14 with trask and get top pick, or go 10-7 and make playoffs with Carr/jimmy G

Id argue the later 2 are debatable where bridge shit QB is clearly not a good option. 


 
Posted : Feb. 6, 2023 1:22 pm
Avatar Of Donkey_Hunter
(@donkey_hunter)
Posts: 4776
Captain
 

New Orleans and Las Vegas have reportedly already agreed on compensation for Carr. 

Carr to visit New Orleans this week.


 
Posted : Feb. 7, 2023 10:13 pm
Avatar Of Parnelldickinson
(@buckandear)
Posts: 147
Gunner
Topic starter
 

I would be interested in Baker Mayfield. He has had shootouts with mahomes, lamr jackson, hebert..games were 40 pts scored. He has ability and we have good wrs


 
Posted : Feb. 8, 2023 4:02 am
Avatar Of Trask Force
(@catherder)
Posts: 2283
Quartermaster
 

Posted by: @Anonymous

Posted by: @donkey_hunter

New Orleans and Las Vegas have reportedly already agreed on compensation for Carr. 

Carr to visit New Orleans this week.

New Orleans had draft picks to burn via the Payton trade. We don't. 

Don't want Carr anyway, not for his price. 

 

According to PFT Carr to NO is not a done deal.  In fact it's unlikely that Carr gets traded at all. He'll probably be cut before the 2/14 deadline.  

 

 


 
Posted : Feb. 8, 2023 2:05 pm
Alldaway 2.0
(@alldaway)
Posts: 1587
Quartermaster
 

Posted by: @buckandear

I would be interested in Baker Mayfield. He has had shootouts with mahomes, lamr jackson, hebert..games were 40 pts scored. He has ability and we have good wrs

 

I would be only okay with Baker if the Bucs are committed to a balanced offense or ground game to work with play action. Baker requires an offense with play action and motion to help him out read coverages pre snap.   But that requires upgrading the interior OL and also drafting another RB and TE. 

 


 
Posted : Feb. 8, 2023 7:28 pm
Avatar Of Parnelldickinson
(@buckandear)
Posts: 147
Gunner
Topic starter
 

Carr to the Stains is gaining steam as their new qb


 
Posted : Feb. 8, 2023 8:26 pm
Avatar Of Firebowles2023
(@firebowles2023)
Posts: 4274
Captain
 

I'd take Baker over Trask...that's for damn sure.

But I'm also good with giving Trask a shot, drafting Hooker, signing a cheap vet... then seeing if our weapons can mask average qb play


 
Posted : Feb. 9, 2023 3:58 pm
Avatar Of Badabingbucs
(@badabingbucs)
Posts: 2629
Quartermaster
 

here's how i rank it

 

if Bucs want to try and keep Superbowl window or say playoff contender window open

 

1. Aaron Rodgers - he would have to restructure his deal and could likely do wonders with Godwin and Evans.  Ultimately, do not think Green Bay would trade him within the NFC so to me it's Jets, Raiders, Packers, or retirement for him.

2. Derek Carr - he would have to restructure his deal or if he were to sign as a free agent but looking more and more like he is going to the Saints.  

3. Jimmy G - the dude gets hurt all the time.  that's a problem.  however, he has done pretty good with San Fran and the best of the crap after Rodgers and Carr

4. Baker Mayfield - he's been on 3 teams in 15 months.  However, still young enough that maybe turn his career around

5. Lamar Jackson - dude's always hurt, a run first QB, and while the team would be 8-3 for the first 2/3s of the season, cant really rely on him to stay healthy.  Plus, he's going to want a mega -45-50 million per year deal.  Also went do the wheels fall off ala Cam Newton.  

 

if the Bucs aren't trying to compete and maybe test their lock with new coaching staff and top pick

6. Blaine Gabbert/Kyle Trask combo 

 

why waste time with any other journeyman QB to win 5-7 games.

 


 
Posted : Feb. 9, 2023 5:54 pm
Avatar Of Trask Force
(@catherder)
Posts: 2283
Quartermaster
 

Darkhorse QB Candidate:  Drew Lock.  He has an arm.  He has mobility.  He has affordability.  Before the season he had a hard-fought battle for the starting job and lost out to perrenial backup Geno Smith.  At the time you had to wonder if you can't even beat out Smith, who can you beat out?  But Smith has turned out to be a legit starting QB.  In retrospect it's no shame that Lock lost out to Smith. He's coming off a $1.4 mil one year contract, so he'll be available for maybe $2 or 3 mil at most.  This will be his 5th year kicking around the NFL without much success.  He's been a team player, and maybe that experience has made him better.  He could provide some competition for Trask.  

Guys like Danny Jones and Sam Darnold have struggled but may be finding their footing after four or five years in the league.  Maybe it takes that long for some guys to figure things out.  If you are looking for a dirt cheap QB who can battle for the starting job, Drew Lock could be the guy.  


 
Posted : Feb. 9, 2023 9:02 pm
Avatar Of Badabingbucs
(@badabingbucs)
Posts: 2629
Quartermaster
 

contract projections per PFF

 

Jackson - 5 years, $260 million or $52M per year.

Geno Smith - 4 years, $150 million or 37.5M per year

Daniel Jones - 4 years, $160 million or $40 per year

Jimmy G - 1 year, $15 million

Jacoby Brissett - 2 years, $16 million

 

good lord, could you imagine paying that for Smith or Jones.  talk about setting a franchise back 


 
Posted : Feb. 10, 2023 8:47 am
Avatar Of Trask Force
(@catherder)
Posts: 2283
Quartermaster
 

Posted by: @badabingbucs

contract projections per PFF

 

Jackson - 5 years, $260 million or $52M per year.

Geno Smith - 4 years, $150 million or 37.5M per year

Daniel Jones - 4 years, $160 million or $40 per year

Jimmy G - 1 year, $15 million

Jacoby Brissett - 2 years, $16 million

 

good lord, could you imagine paying that for Smith or Jones.  talk about setting a franchise back 

That's too rich for the Bucs' blood.  I think they'll bring in somebody for less than $10 mil for two years.  But they have to be able to throw the deep ball, because there is so much money invested at the WR spot.  So that's the catch.  I don't think Brissett has that ability.   

 


 
Posted : Feb. 10, 2023 9:23 am
Page 2 / 8
Share: