http://espn.go.com/espn/fp/flashPollResultsState?sportIndex=sportsnation&pollId=4115695 I guess people are caught up in the moment and forgot what happens come playoff time.
It's the teams around them that will sway the value, even if it's not supposed to.Brady is usually money in the playoffs, but damnit, manning is still one of the best qb's, by himself, to ever play the game.But I do see what you're getting at.
both are good. but if you wouldn't take Peyton then you are out of your mind.
both are good. but if you wouldn't take Peyton then you are out of your mind.
In the playoffs I'm taking Brady 100% of the time.
It's the teams around them that will sway the value, even id it's not supposed to.Brady is usually money in the playoffs, but damnit, manning is still one of the best qb's, by himself, to ever play the game.But I do see what you're getting at.
See when I saw this question I was putting it in strictly who is the better QB come playoff time. Putting aside the teams. It doesn't really specify so I guess it's how you interpret it. If the talent is equal for both of them I'm not sure how you choose Manning over Brady in the playoffs.
both are good. but if you wouldn't take Peyton then you are out of your mind.
haha really man? Peyton Manning, regular season rockstar, postseason flop. Almost every time he's in the playoffs. Yes I know he won a Super Bowl but I've been watching Peyton since he was at U of T and it was great watching him lose to the Gators every year. He just doesn't win big games like Brady does. Brady has been in 4 super bowls, and won 2. Peyton is 1 for 1, but most of his playoff appearances have been one and done IIRC
If you're asking me which QB I'm taking in the playoffs not which team then I'm taking Brady 100%
The best part of Peyton failing in the playoffs is that the NFL changed the rules so he'd beat Brady and he's only been able to do it once.
both are top 3 in the leaguemanning is a better qb hands downwould have 2 super bowls if his defense had not screwed him over last year.will probably win his second this year.there has never been a better qb ever in the league.i understand the temptation to take Brady, but i would never pick anyone but Peyton over him.personal preference. cant really go wrong picking either
It's the teams around them that will sway the value, even id it's not supposed to.Brady is usually money in the playoffs, but damnit, manning is still one of the best qb's, by himself, to ever play the game.But I do see what you're getting at.
See when I saw this question I was putting it in strictly who is the better QB come playoff time. Putting aside the teams. It doesn't really specify so I guess it's how you interpret it. If the talent is equal for both of them I'm not sure how you choose Manning over Brady in the playoffs.
Depends. Are you saying better qb, or better playoff qb?Both are different answers imo.
both are top 3 in the leaguemanning is a better qb hands downwould have 2 super bowls if his defense had not screwed him over last year.will probably win his second this year.there has never been a better qb ever in the league.i understand the temptation to take Brady, but i would never pick anyone but Peyton over him.personal preference. cant really go wrong picking either
Both QB's switch teams and I bet Brady does even more than Manning did this year. When Brady had all that talent in 2007 you saw how unstoppable that offense was. Despite having no talent he carried a last place in the division team to a division winner and a top 2 seed.
It's the teams around them that will sway the value, even id it's not supposed to.Brady is usually money in the playoffs, but damnit, manning is still one of the best qb's, by himself, to ever play the game.But I do see what you're getting at.
See when I saw this question I was putting it in strictly who is the better QB come playoff time. Putting aside the teams. It doesn't really specify so I guess it's how you interpret it. If the talent is equal for both of them I'm not sure how you choose Manning over Brady in the playoffs.
Depends. Are you saying better qb, or better playoff qb?Both are different answers imo.
Brady in the playoffs. You can say Manning in the regular season, but they aren't far off of that either.
I know who JDud would take in this situation.
Don't think it's even a contest no matter what angle you look at it from. Brady is the superior QB. The gap just gets wider in the postseason.
both are good. but if you wouldn't take Peyton then you are out of your mind.
Manning's 9-11 post season record might suggest that it is you thats out of YOUR mind.