Baker Mayfield is younger, is as good as Dak (age 30) and far superior to Kirk Cousins (35). For less money, and equal/better winning percentage, in...

I have weighed & measured your reply and find it lacking. it is consistent with your viewpoint that Baker sucks, but goes too far in justifying...

well there are between 2 and 7 data sets missing. But I’m glad you can appreciate the total body of work. and to be quiet serious: you’re saying you...

Nice & concise, with context, and humor to drive home the point. This IS fun.

I think the Dilfer comparison to Kirk Cousins is spot on.

Well, the kid is only 28…2 seasons younger than Dak, and 7 younger than Kirk. And we’re comparing the first guy to get Cleveland to a playoff game i...

Depends on what you mean by “elite” - only QB’s that demonstrate they can make those around them, better, while winning games they should, and keeping...

funny, only two of them are still playing in this tournament. Also funny, all of them are not even coming up for the opportunity. I guess everyone has...

uh, Biggsy, I love ya, and I am never going to press YOU to prove your datasets…but this just in: 2023 Bucs won a playoff game, 2005 Bucs did not. I...

it was nice seeing him in a Baker Mayfield jersey while slobbering all over Baker during the interview…but you’re right

Well, to prove a point (you are the one attempting to minimizing the results, ie, the yards, TD’s, conference, title and playoff wins), who would you ...

and yet, it did. as I’ve said, I hijacked the debate (a bit). I think you may have, perhaps unintentionally, caused me to swerve into that. The 2005...

Well, in terms of draft slot determining worth/value. I believe Trask was taken a round higher than anticipated. I think the same has been said abou...

Maybe. It gets back to the context issue you avoid/discount. Which is more akin to how the odds-makers discounted the Bucs coming into this season. ...

Intended to post this - all I can say now is - I agree. Good post. I saw this and had the same reaction. Steve Young is a nice guy, but I thi...