The NFL has changed a lot over the years. From becoming more of a passing league, with rules favoring offenses, the days of hard hits on quarterbacks and defenseless receivers are becoming a thing of the past. And while player safety should be a focus of the league as more and more comes out on the issues of concussions and their long-term effects, young fans will rarely get to witness the ferocity of days gone by.
Tampa Bay linebacker Scot Brantley came to the Buccaneers from the University of Florida and brought a hard-hitting reputation with him. A third-round draft pick from the Gators, Brantley missed most of his senior season with a head injury (surprising huh?).
Still, Brantley was a high round draft pick and spent eight seasons in the NFL with the Buccaneers. However his most well-known play is still this hit on Lions quarterback Eric Hipple back in November of 1985.
Not only would this hit most likely resulted in a penalty in today’s NFL, it would have also warranted a suspension from the league. Tampa Bay’s overall history in NFL lore isn’t great, despite winning a Super Bowl title, but even during the lean years, the Bucs were known for a tough punishing defense. Players like Brantley, Mark Cotney, Hugh Green, Davis Lewis, and John Lynch would all have a hard time staying on the field in today’s NFL.
This isn’t a commentary on the NFL and their rules, just stating facts.
Share On Socials
About the Author: Mark Cook
Looks like a legal hit by today’s standards. But, they would probably flow a flag.
Opp. I meant throw. I hate auto correct sometimes.
Brutal! THE most vicious hit in Buccaneer history. I have seen this many times and still wonder how Hipple ever recovered. Type about a car crash!
That looked clean to me. , but there is no doubt there would’ve been a flag in today’s game. Probably the cleanest and most recent bomb I can remember is pre-season two years ago, when Kwon leveled poor Mccown . It was the purest most beautiful tackle I’ve ever seen. They were parallel for a split second, and that’s when I knew I loved me some Kwon. haha.
I was there watching that one live.
The hardest hit in team history was Curtis Buckley’s called shot on Brian Mitchell. Read about it here: http://bleacherreport.com/articles/243598-buckleys-knockout-hit-by-jack-bechta. Curtis Buckley was a beast and a bright spot on some bad teams as a guy who gave 1000% effort.
Why would that have been illegal by today’s standards?
A) Hipple was across the line of scrimmage and would have been considered a runner, not a protected QB
B) Brantley, didn’t leave his feat launching into the opposing player, didn’t use his helmet as a weapon, hit Hipple in the shoulder and chest, with his shoulder.
C) Even though Hipple lost his helmet, replay clearly shows there was no helmet to helmet contact.
D) The hit was in bounds.
Seriously, what about the rules today make that an illegal hit?
Sorry, but I disagree.
Hardest hit I ever saw was when Mark Cotney connected with Redskin receiver Frank Grany who was running a deep cross in 1977.
Cotney got his shoulder pad up in Grants face mask and not only decleated him, he KO’d him and broke his nose.
The last we saw of Grant in that game was the trainer walking him off the field with Grants nose hangiing down to his chin.
Hipple, I believe, came back to finiish and win the game for the Lions.
Not bad but please…. That was a slow weekend for John Lynch.
He knocked out his own brother in law!
Here’s just a few highlights –
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l_1Qsqo5w9M
I remember a pretty brutal hit by Lynch on his own brother in law. It knocked him out cold.
I’ll look for some more had hits for next week.
Like many on this board, I too witnessed the hit live. Hipple’s helmet flew into the air and nearly into the stands which made it even more dramatic.
The best thing about the Lynch hit was as they walking the woozy bro in law off the field Brad Culpepper shouted at him, “hey buddy, He’s sleeping with yur sister, too.”