It is no secret 2019 is a big year for Bucs general manager Jason Licht. After five seasons in charge of running Tampa Bay’s front office, the Buccaneers have yet to make the playoffs and have a record of 27-53 under Licht’s leadership.

While Bucs’ fans continue to debate Licht’s performance, the Glazer’s have shown faith in Licht and his staff. But how much patience they will continue to have in Licht is unknown. The bottom line is, if the Bucs can turn things around in 2019 and reach, or at least get close to the playoffs Licht, will most likely be rewarded with a multi-year extension.

Bucs head coach Bruce Arians and GM Jason Licht
Bucs head coach Bruce Arians and GM Jason Licht – Photo by: Cliff Welch/PR

But a recent article by USAToday.com’s Steven Ruiz doesn’t paint Licht in a very favorable light. Ruiz recently ranked all 32 of the NFL’s general managers, and had Licht 31st out of 32.

“Seriously, how does Jason Licht still have this job? He’s spent a TON of money in free agency and those moves have not paid off. He’s also botched most of his first-round picks, which have been near or in the top-10. And, oh yeah, he’s drafted TWO kickers! He justified this year’s pick by claiming that kicker is one of the most important positions on the roster. Let that sink in.”

While Licht would be the first to tell you he has made some mistakes, to say he has botched most of his first round picks isn’t a fair assessment. Wide receiver Mike Evans is a superstar, quarterback Jameis Winston many feel still has plenty of potential to live up to his first round status but O.J. Howard was on his way to being in the Pro Bowl conversation last year before an ankle injury ended his season prematurely. While cornerback Vernon Hargreaves has been a disappointment, Vita Vea showed flashes of being worthy of his draft status, and many feel this year’s selection of linebacker Devin White could be a home run.

2019 will be a turning point in Licht’s career in Tampa Bay, but with a new staff of proven successful coaches, Licht’s future with the Buccaneers is looking better. Now the team just has to prove it on the field and get back to the playoffs sooner rather than later.

You can see the full GM rankings by clicking here.

Previous articleBucs’ Howard, Vea, Named As Top Players Under 25
Next articleBucs Monday Mailbag: Moving On From JPP, Leftwich Qualified?
Mark Cook currently is the director of editorial content and Bucs beat writer and has written for PewterReport.com since 2011. Cook has followed the Buccaneers since 1977 when he first began watching football with his Dad and is fond of the 1979 Bucs team that came within 10 points of going to a Super Bowl. His favorite Bucs game is still the 1979 divisional playoff win 24-17 over the Eagles. In his spare time Cook enjoys playing guitar, fishing, surfing and family time at the beach. In addition, Cook can be found in front of a television or in Doak Campbell any time the FSU Seminoles are playing. Cook is a native of Pinecrest in Eastern Hillsborough County and has written for numerous publications including the Tampa Tribune, In the Field and Ya'll Magazine. Cook can be reached at [email protected]

37 COMMENTS

  1. Gee, that’s funny. I recently ranked NFL writers, and what a coincidence! Steven Ruiz ranks 31st out of 32 (in a tie).

    +30
    -6
    Rating: +24. From 36 votes.
    Please wait...
  2. Yup, if the Bucs first rounders play lights out that Licht will ascend the rankings because his free agent record is worse than Bruce Allen’s.

    The 2019 season is a make or break season for Licht as a GM in this league IMO. This is because we will find out if it was a lack of coaching or lack of talent holding this team back?

    +11
    -3
    Rating: +8. From 14 votes.
    Please wait...
  3. You guys always stick up for Licht despite all of the very clear and obvious evidence to the contrary. There was literally no excuse for not trading D-Jax and McCoy halfway through last year to a super bowl contender for third round picks. Any competent GM would have done so. How many bottom feeding teams have the same salary cap issues we have? None. “Winston has plenty of potential” lol. You don’t pick a guy number one overall to HOPEFULLY be good by his fourth year in the league (see Mayfield, Wentz, Goff, Mahomes, Trubisky, and even Darnold already playing pretty good). Our running back picks have been so bad over Licht’s tenure it’s literally a statistical anomaly. Look at all the undrafted free agent RBs producing at a high level while Licht has DRAFTED RJ3, McNichols and Charles Simms. Why is that every announcer and writer knew we shouldn’t have taken Aguyo and knew we should’ve Derwin James, but Licht was the only one that couldn’t figure that out? Guy should’ve been long gone by now, he’s awful.

    +21
    -20
    Rating: +1. From 41 votes.
    Please wait...
  4. Eagles GM #1 on this list? Haahhahahahaha. This writer’s credibility is in question. He wrote, “His trades always seem to pay off.” Hahahahahahahahahahahahaha

    Howie is the same guy who traded a 3rd at the trade deadline for Golden Tate who was a free agent after the season. Total fail.
    Same guy who traded the farm for Wentz who is always broken.
    Same guy who traded for slow Alshon Jeffrey who has missed half his games.
    Same guy who traded for Jay Ajayi who is always hurt.
    Same guy who has missed on 85% of his draft picks over the last 5 years.
    $12 million in dead cap space.

    +20
    -8
    Rating: +12. From 28 votes.
    Please wait...
  5. How is Ruiz wrong? I agree with the quote in the article completely. How does this guy have a job?

    +15
    -13
    Rating: +2. From 28 votes.
    Please wait...
  6. #1 GM vs #31 GM

    Last 6 drafts for each GM: 1st round picks

    Eagles/Roseman : Marcus Smith II, Nelson Agohlor, Carson Wentz, Derek Barnett, (none), Andre Dillard
    Bucs/Licht : Mike Evans, Jameis Winston, VHIII, OJ Howard, Vita Vea, Devin White

    Advantage Bucs.

    +32
    -14
    Rating: +18. From 46 votes.
    Please wait...
  7. Licht deserves the criticism and i think he will agree too. I really don’t care who is the #1 GM as that doesn’t help the BUCS in anyway. That being said – by the end of this season Licht is either out of a job or will have moved to the Top 10 GMs in the league for bringing in Arians and sticking with Winston. There is no middle ground .

    +12
    0
    Rating: +12. From 12 votes.
    Please wait...
  8. I’m pretty sure you didn’t include Peyton Barber into your running back equation.

    +5
    -2
    Rating: +3. From 7 votes.
    Please wait...
  9. Big Sombrero. Just 2 seasons ago the Eagles won the Super Bowl with a back up that Roseman signed.. Wentz was playing at an MVP level before getting injured that season. They had a top 5 O-line and D-line. A good running game and just a solid all around roster. They made the playoffs again last year despite Wentz getting injured again.

    He may not be the best, but Roseman but he’s damn close is significantly better than Licht. Oh it’s worth Mentioning that Roseman
    Survived the Chip Kelly coup and also hired Doug Pederson to replace him the same year Licht hired Koetter.. So you protesting his placement as best in the league just makes you look foolish guy.

    +17
    -7
    Rating: +10. From 24 votes.
    Please wait...
  10. Ruiz is right. Licht has spent tons on FA, with not many of them working out. He has done poor in the draft, with lots of mistakes. The biggest two coming in ’18 and ’19 drafts. Taking Vea over James, followed up this year with taking White over Allen.

    If the Bucs fail to make the playoffs this season, Licht needs to be fired.

    +9
    -5
    Rating: +4. From 14 votes.
    Please wait...
  11. 27-53
    A game worse than what got Dominik Fired.
    One Pro Bowler (alternate)
    Consecutive 5-11 seasons
    A team in cap hell.
    Very richly deserved second to last place

    The only players Mark Cook is citing are first round picks, many of which are top 10 or like Winston top overall. Like Mike Evans? Great! I’m sure if Licht had gone a different route and taken Odell Beckham or Aaron Donald with the pick it wouldn’t have changed that fact that they, like Evans, would’ve been the best player on the roster. It was a great year to have the seventh overall pick. He has made a poor roster for much of 6 years and for that he should be fired.

    +11
    -2
    Rating: +9. From 13 votes.
    Please wait...
  12. Wow, Licht stays out of last place because Gase has been handed the reins in NY.

    I’d actually give him the edge over Licht at this point because Licht has done so little with SO MUCH capital.

    +6
    -3
    Rating: +3. From 9 votes.
    Please wait...
  13. Kinda tired of rankings, poles, and stats in general. I imagine that’s all we will see until training camp. You know I have always wandered in which pre-season game are the most hotdogs consumed at the RayJay. Careful, this is a trick question.

    +3
    0
    Rating: +3. From 3 votes.
    Please wait...
  14. Nobody gives a damn about what he or any other writer thinks really. If Bucs win 8-10 games this year will be huge turn around and success and Licht will be here many more years. If they don’t then will have see ho patient Glazers are.

    Jury is out still on Licht and plenty of criticism is fair but musical coaches and GMs doesn’t work either. If this a great draft and Bucs play better as expected he deserves to stay in my book.

    +4
    -4
    Rating: 0. From 8 votes.
    Please wait...
  15. I think this year will be make or break for Licht weather you want him here or gone. I’m ambivalent about him if they win 8-10 games and this kicker actually is good lol I say give him more time.

    Remember Licht is why we have Arians and that will be clear of good or bad too soon enough.

    Go Bucs I think it’s time for us fans that have waited long time to see a better team.

    +2
    0
    Rating: +2. From 2 votes.
    Please wait...
  16. FYI : “Cap Hell” is typically referencing DEAD CAP SPACE. The Bucs are the #1 best team in the NFL in dead cap space at $90k. They are not in cap hell.

    Miami is truly in “Cap Hell”. They have $37.5 MILLION counting against their cap on players who are NO LONGER WITH THE TEAM because of signing bonuses and front end cash that is prorated over the entire contract.

    +7
    -9
    Rating: -2. From 16 votes.
    Please wait...
  17. BigSombrero – you’re clueless.

    First, since taking back over GM duties Roseman has averaged 9.7 wins. And a SUPER BOWL win. So please, compare Roseman to Licht & his many playoff appearances.

    Second, you seem hopeless unaware that Roseman did not draft Marcus Smith or Agholor. And his drafts have been largely successful (as has his team building and hiring). Again – 9.7 wins/season.

    Third, you again are clueless about compensatory picks. Roseman traded for Tate, got a half season tryout at a position of need (from a very good WR) and now gets a 4th in 2020 as a result. So he gave up a 2019 3rd and received a 2020 4th with the chance to evaluate Tate. That’s called smart GMing, and while this trade didn’t work out ideally it had minimum downside. Which is, again, very smart.

    Fourth, and again I don’t know why you bother posting, “cap hell” fundamentally refers to a team that is unable to make necessary moves because of cap space issues. Historically that has been “dead cap”, but with salary cap changes now largely means a lack of cap space. Which the Bucs have… Seeing as they HAD to cut McCoy to free up the $14 million they needed for signings and draft picks (and they will HAVE to cut more players to get under the cap).

    As for the Dolphins they are rebuilding and unloaded contracts in 2019 to free up future space. And they still have $27 million in cap space. You think that’s “cap hell”?

    +9
    -3
    Rating: +6. From 12 votes.
    Please wait...
  18. “Cap hell” is when you can’t sign needed players because of your salary cap. BigSombrero conflated “dead cap” with it to try to justify himself. I’m glad tog could set him straight. Please justify 27-53 dear postee. The mental gymnastics some people do to shower praise on their Emporer with no clothes is surely as sad as it is entertaining. Though this is effectively Scott Reynold’s site, so I’m not surprised the last remaining members of the USS Lichtanic refuse to leave the ship as it sinks.

    @fredster opines that if Licht goes as low as 8-8, which would take his record to a sterling 35-61 that our GM-for-the-ages (not in a good way) will be around for “years to come.” For anyone with the slightest bit of rationality, that would amount to a 36.4% winning percentage and a sixth year out of six for Licht’s teams not making the playoffs. Quite the accomplishment, by all means give Licht the keys to the city in that case! Right guys? 😂😂

    +9
    -3
    Rating: +6. From 12 votes.
    Please wait...
  19. Also it should be noted, and rarely is, that cap space that remains available on a given season can be rolled over to the next. The reason why the Browns spent big this off-season and still have space is because they rolled over their space from previous years.

    The reason why Licht can’t sign anyone that isn’t a result of a player being released is because he’s spent like drunken sailor the first five seasons and had little to no money to roll into this year. It’s also why you never see the team with any compensatory picks. So keep playing your “dead cap” swan song to the masses Licht Apologists, if they have a clue they’ll know to ignore it.

    +6
    -1
    Rating: +5. From 7 votes.
    Please wait...
  20. Could care less about the definition of “cap hell”.

    Bottom line is our teams under Licht don’t win. The roster has plenty of holes. We have paid and are paying high salaries for players that have not produced to their contracts. Maybe the influence of Arians and Bowles will help this year.

    And for those who’ve pointed it out, I agree Pewter Report is part of the Licht rose-colored-glasses-brigade – and that’s putting it nicely.

    +9
    -3
    Rating: +6. From 12 votes.
    Please wait...
  21. I am probably the leader of the “Licht-is-horrible” pack but I disagree with both Ruiz and Cook in this piece:

    1) I think the draft is incredibly difficult for all GMs. Assessing GMs based on whether their draft choices were “botched” or still have “potential”, would be like picking between which of your 32 cousins you want to take the prom. They are all going to look bad.

    2) The reason I regularly rail against Licht for his drafting is because he either has no strategy, or a really bad one (as statistically measured over the years), when going in. I have written before about the failings of his approach to “never trade-up in round 1; always trade down if you can in round 1”, as well as his “ignore obvious positions of need” (e.g., when we didn’t have an OG on the roster and he passed by the top ranked OG in Gabe Jackson to draft a 3rd down RB); not to mention his “picking a kicker in round 2 – based on a completely flawed analysis of that kicker’s potential (as pointed out by several on draft day)”; and finally now we have the apparent “flood a position in order to find some reasonable player” – spending 6 of his top 10 picks in the last two drafts on DBs (none in the 1st round – meaning he’s really shooting in the dark to try and get a JAG DB or two – not that there’s anything wrong with a few JAGs – every team will have them – but 60% of our top picks is overkill, and neglects the rest of the roster, not to mention not playing to that particular draft’s strength)

    3) Free Agency – here Ruiz nails it on the head…our best FA acquisition by Licht would be…..Cam Brate? The bigger money guys have all bombed for one reason or another (the reason doesn’t really matter in the Just Win Baby league): Collins, Johnson, Johnson, Verner, Jensen, Sweezy, DJax, Swaggy, Grimes, Ayers, Allen, Unrein, Curry, and so on. It’s hard to argue that Licht hasn’t thrown cap money away luring the wrong guys to town – and missing on better ones.

    4) Speaking of the cap – yes we have Greenberg to manage that, but he of course works for Licht. As I was once told in my career, “you can delegate work but you cannot delegate responsibility”. The decision to move on from McCoy for football reasons would have been one thing, but being forced to effectively cut one of your best players to make room under the cap is the definition of failing in cap management!

    5) He never plans for the future. Not just when it came to McCoy (he must have seen this coming ages ago), but how did we end up in a position where we had to resign D Smith to a big contract – where was the up and coming LT in our system to allow Smith to move over to RT two years ago, and allow us to move on from Dotson as he’s fallen off? Why is Peyton Barber (no offense – i like the kid) still our starting RB? Why have we replaced the worst RG in the league, with Earl Watford? Why are we trying to fix a secondary that had too many rookies in it, by adding more rookies?

    The only line of reasoning that I could possibly have symapthy with is “we’ve spent 5 years suffering through Licht’s growing pains as he tried to learn how to be an effective GM in the NFL, we should stick with him because he surely must have learned by now”.

    I am skeptical.

    +10
    -3
    Rating: +7. From 13 votes.
    Please wait...
  22. I agree with PR that the assessment of the first round picks is unfair. Even though it is too early to rank the pick of Vita Vea, I am still hurting over not picking Derwin James. I do agree with the writer that Licht (Lite) is not a successful GM and I think the rating of near bottom is deserved. His main failures are woeful record in the second round and not fixing either the OL, DL or DB position groups despite opportunities to do so. He seem to have no strategic feel for how to work the draft and his free agents have mostly been expensive busts.

    +6
    -2
    Rating: +4. From 8 votes.
    Please wait...
  23. @tog Hey there buddy. Howie Roseman has been with the Eagles since 2000 and he’s been the GM since 2010. Get your facts straight if you want to debate. Roseman was lucky to have hired Pederson. Without that lucky hire, the Iggles are garbage as per usual.

    The Bucs didn’t have to cut McCoy. They could have restructured Evans. They could have extended Winston at a lower number. They could have cut Benenoch and Evan Smith to save the $4m. Arians called McCoy out about 10 times, or did you think it was a mind game? He isn’t counting fake pro bowl hardware as accomplishments. He reviewed McCoys tape. Passive PUSSY. That is why McCoy is gone, OBVIOUSLY.

    +3
    -5
    Rating: -2. From 8 votes.
    Please wait...
  24. @Devasher Which “needed” player did the Bucs miss out on exactly because of their cap hell? Adam Humphries? Kwon ALexander? Both have been upgraded in a big way. Maybe you thought the Honey Badger or Landon Collins was coming to Tampa. Thankfully the Bucs didn’t wast big money on shitty safeties.

    Not in cap hell. The Bucs can make space in lots of ways to keep players or bring in players that the coaches want or need.

    +4
    -7
    Rating: -3. From 11 votes.
    Please wait...
  25. @tog Admittedly I hate the Eagles. I do not follow them. In my humble opinion, even after eventually earning a comp pick, Tate was still a failed desperation trade by the Eagles.

    How exactly do you effectively evaluate a player who is on your team for 2 months and has no rapport with the QB or knowledge of the playbook?

    Detroit won that trade, not Howie Roseman. The Eagles gave up pick #81 in 2019 and will get a comp pick in the #135-#138 range in 2020 for a 4 game rental. That is NOT a win. If Licht had done that, the same people defending Roseman would be roasting Jason Licht right now.

    +4
    -5
    Rating: -1. From 9 votes.
    Please wait...
  26. @bigsombrero maybe you are comfortable with Earl Watford as your starting RG, with Peyton Barber as your starting RB, with Carl Nassib as your best healthy pass rusher, with starting defensive backfield of Jordan Whitehead, (currently injured) Justin Evans, VHIII, Carlton Davis and Sean Murphy Bunting but I’d say that’s a lot of people who haven’t proven much of anything in the NFL, except for Watford who’s proven to be a fringe player at best.

    To your point, and what you appear to miss, is that the contracts doled out to Michael Johnson(16 mil in cap for one year of substandard play), Swaggy Baker, Anthony Collins(9 mil in cap for 1 year of substandard play), JR Sweezy, Alterraun Verner (19.25 mil for 2014-16) DeSean Jackson (23.5 mil for 2017-8) , TJ Ward (4.5 mil in 2017), Robert Ayers (14 mil for 2016-7), Vinny Curry, the unguaranteed deals of Vincent Jackson (12.2 mil in 2016), Doug Martin (5.8 mil in 2017) were not only HUGE wastes of Glazer cash, it not only cost them SEVERAL compensatory draft picks, but it also clogged up cap room that could’ve been rolled over to the following year which could’ve been rolled into THIS year. Talk about “dead cap room.” There’s no shortage of “dead cap” noted in the contracts above.

    +6
    -4
    Rating: +2. From 10 votes.
    Please wait...
  27. @devasher I could be wrong, but I think the GM targets players his head coach requests. It has been completely collaborative under Jason Licht to my understanding. The previous coaching regimes gave targeting input and spoke with any potential free agents before they were signed.

    A recent example is that Suh came to Tampa because of Todd Bowles and Bruce Arians, not Jason Licht. The positional coach, coordinator, and head coach all signed off on the idea of bringing him in first and foremost. I actually don’t remember Jason Licht saying anything about Suh and very little about McCoy before he was cut. Maybe that’s your point, that he should shop for groceries and tell the HC what to cook and how to cook it?

    I think Jason Licht found a way to give each of his head coaches the players they felt they needed to compete. I definitely agree that those coaches were wrong about how to use the players he brought in. The fact that M.Johnson, Sweezy, Curry, and D.Jax have all returned to their previous team and had (or will likely have) success is a testament to the player being underutilized by Bucs coaches, not necessarily an indictment on their talent or worth by the GM.

    Regarding the offensive line: I believe obvious playcalling based on personnel groupings, offensive design, and Winston over-extending plays (when he should take what’s available) are big time contributors to the effectiveness of the line.

    We shall see.

    +4
    -7
    Rating: -3. From 11 votes.
    Please wait...
  28. People keep saying how bad our salary cap issues are and being in Salary Cap Hell. Salary Cap He’ll is having to cut 3 stars because you are over the cap like we used to be under Bruce Allen. Letting a #3 WR and hurt MLB take ridiculous dead in FA and choosing to release an aging DT to pick up another one is not Salary Cap Hell. We may have ranked low on Salary Cap Space and not been able to spend wildly this year but it was not a mess and will only get better from here… In My Opinion…

    Licht has not been in contention for GM of the Year but his choosing of Smith was seen as a great pick by most at the time, not knowing he was going to be so out of touch and promoting Koetter seemed like the right move as every team was looking for the next up and coming O.C. and he would have been poached as having the success he did with Matt ryan and Winston early seemed him worthy only to find out later he is not HC material. Those moves can hardly be blamed on him. And though his Drafts have been 50/50 it’s truly hard to measure with the terrible coaching it turned out they had.

    So as most are saying this is the year to prove his worth and find out what this team is truly made of and get this Organization back on track and if the Bucs don’t at least show promise then yes, it will be time to move on no question. So that’s just another reason why this year will be so exciting to watch!

    A lot is on the line! Especially the possibility we may never see Ass post again once we are doing well!!!

    +3
    -2
    Rating: +1. From 5 votes.
    Please wait...
  29. I agree with Big Sombrero, the choice of Philly GM was “pee your pants laughable”. Upon further review, I noticed Ruiz is from the “City of Brotherly Love” aka in these parts as Rondelphia, so again, no surprise at this choice.

    2nd most absurd was Bruce Allen at #20, for the record I think Haskins will be another in a long list of ‘Skins 1st round QB busts (Heath Shuler, Patrick Ramsey, Jason Campbell, and of course RG3…..).

    Ruiz obviously knows dip-spit of all 32 NFL teams and their GM’s. Licht wouldn’t even be in my top 20 GM’s (and I am one of his few defenders…for now), but busting on his 1st round picks proved Ruiz is more like Louise when it comes to his knowledge of our Bucs. His 2nd round picks however garner much criticism. He’s done well bringing in UFA’s (Hump, Barber, Brate, etc), and signing/retaining our (few) star players like Mike Evans, Gerald McCoy, and soon Jameis Winston, and has improved with experience regarding free agency.

    I agree with all that mentioned this season is a big one for Licht, as much or more than it is for Winston. Except for Ron Wolf (1976-78) no GM has gone on to greatness after leaving Tampa Bay, and one was never hired by another team in any capacity…..so every season from hence forward is big for Licht, needless to say.

    Lastly, no existing NFL GM was an overnight success, even Belichick. Most need 4-5 years but don’t necessarily get it. Oh and any GM that says Kickers are not a vital cog to the success (or failure) of their team is referenced as a “Former” GM. For you kids, Oakland drafted Sebastian Janikowski as the 17TH OVERALL PICK in ROUND 1 in 2000. He went on the greatness, unlike some other 1st round picks in history -kicker or otherwise. If Roberto Aguayo had turned out to be another Janikowski, Licht would have been deemed a genius. How many games have we lost by virtue of a missed FG or extra point?? Let me count the gray hairs……

    +4
    -7
    Rating: -3. From 11 votes.
    Please wait...
  30. Almost forgot…….what’s with the reader(s) wasting our Pewter/Bucs forum/discussion on licking the Browns up and down? They have been insignificant LONGER THAN WE HAVE and lost to us just a few months ago. Who cares about their salary cap surplus and/or carryover? Let’s see how their use of the surplus carries out in 2019, after reading press clippings since February about being perennial Super Bowl contenders. Go BUCS!!

    +3
    -3
    Rating: 0. From 6 votes.
    Please wait...
  31. @bigsombrero there’s a BIG difference between working with the coaches on personnel and giving the head coach the blame for signings and draft picks that don’t work out over the GM. Jon Gruden/Bill Belichick don’t work here.

    At the minimum Licht has had two very different HC’s but with consistent record of failure in free agency and no one is saying that Dirk Koetter had the same level of influence in roster decisions that Lovie Smith had (power over final 53 in his contract). Either we give Licht credit for Mike Evans and Ali Marpet and give equal blame for ASJ, Roberto Aguayo/the entire 2016 draft class or we take away credit for some of his rare successes. You can’t have it both ways.

    Coaches have a primary role to coach the players on the roster and game plan. The GM and front office’s primary role is to provide the best talent/fit for what the coach wants to do. If that’s not their role what exactly are the Glazers paying him for?

    There’s no evidence that the past 5 years head coaches were taking over free agent negotiations or taking over the draft room to trade up for a kicker. You are what your record says you are. Only an apologist would say otherwise.

    +6
    -3
    Rating: +3. From 9 votes.
    Please wait...
  32. Good post Devashar and for the most part I agree with you. Well said.
    Licht’s biggest failures have been in the second round and you are right, so far 2016 was his worst draft by far.
    I really believe his drafting has been better than the Dummynick but so far the record doesn’t reflect that, mainly because of our stinky defense.

    +3
    -2
    Rating: +1. From 5 votes.
    Please wait...
  33. @bigsombrero

    We’ll have to disagree about the Eagles trade. It may have been a bit of desperation, but it was a desperation play with limited downside. If they loved what they saw from Tate they could’ve resigned him. They decided they wanted to let him walk and recoup the 4th.

    Not all trades work out. But to “lose” a trade and drop a year and 50 spots only? That’s smart.

    +2
    -2
    Rating: 0. From 4 votes.
    Please wait...
  34. @ East End Boy: Loved your Prom analogy. Very Scubog-like. LOL

    I’ve always believed that it is the general manager’s role to acquire the best players that are suited for what they will be asked to do. “The Patriot Way” and teams like my hometown Steelers, succeed, at least partially, due to the consistency and stability of “what they do”. With our seemingly continuous turnover in coaching staffs, each likely requesting a different skill set, there’s little doubt that the player acquisitions have been unsuccessful on the field. The dilemma for me is whether the “groceries” are poor or the coaching staff unable to prepare a palatable meal even with the best of ingredients.

    The results on the field have not been good since Licht arrived. On the other hand, two of his acquisitions (Alexander and Humphries) were good enough to get huge paydays elsewhere. Licht’s Draft and free agency record has been a mixed bag of moderate successes and failures. My opinion is that the roster is about average and that, up until now, our weak coaching and fragile player psyche, has been the real cause of the less than mediocre won-loss record. We have a coaching staff that is highly respected. They immediately began addressing the team’s confidence. They have proclaimed the roster to be talented. Let’s hope they can cook us up something edible.

    +2
    0
    Rating: +2. From 2 votes.
    Please wait...
  35. I like Jason Licht but it’s hard to defend his W-L record, 2rd draft busts, FA Flops and poor roster management with salary cap issues. Licht’s on his 3rd coach in 5 years and at some point one runs out of excuses and the blame needs to get placed where it belongs.

    +5
    0
    Rating: +5. From 5 votes.
    Please wait...
  36. Look, the jury is still out. And it’s fair to criticize him for his lack of success at GM. But I think his faults are either being piled on, or not evaluated fairly. For starters, if you’re gonna judge GM’s based on the draft, then Belichick is a bottom 5 GM, because his work in the draft over the years has been downright laughable. What has he produced out of the draft since he’s been the Pats coach? Other than lucking into a 6th round 1st ballot hall of famer? His track record is worse in the draft. To me, Licht’s weaknesses have not been draft picks, it’s been FA signings 1st by a landslide, his affinity for wasting draft picks(and non day 3 draft picks) on kickers, and to this point, bad coaching hires. Now granted, I think he finally brought the right coaches in. But his biggest downfall so far has clearly been FA signings. If he hit on big money FA signings as often as every good GM does, and hired the right coaching staff from the beginning, we’d be talking about a playoff team, because his work in the draft has been above average(outside trading up to draft a kicker in the 2nd round. Which may have been the worst draft day move I’ve ever seen in my life as a football fan)

    0
    -1
    Rating: -1. From 1 vote.
    Please wait...
  37. Same guy who has a Superbowl ring. How many rings for Licht? Its a bottom line league, dude, and the bottom line is, under Licht, this team has been a perennial cellar dweller. I don’t give a rat’s tail which one has more first round ‘stars’ or which one has the better free agent signings. Its all about wins, baby. Roseman is a winner and Licht ain’t.

    +2
    0
    Rating: +2. From 2 votes.
    Please wait...