Pewter Report’s Scott Reynolds answers your questions from the @PewterReport X account this week in the Bucs Mailbag. Submit your question to SR each week via X using the hashtag #PRMailbag. Here are the Bucs questions we chose to answer for this week’s edition.
QUESTION: When is the earliest the Bucs can get out of Baker Mayfield’s contract?
ANSWER: As I said in last week’s 2-Point Conversion column following Baker Mayfield’s two-interception performance at Chicago in the 27-24 loss on Sunday Night Football, the Bucs made a huge mistake extending Baker Mayfield’s contract when they did. As much as Mayfield didn’t like it, the Bucs had all of the leverage heading into the 2026 season. Mayfield didn’t hold out at any point. He pouted in two press conferences and said he was going to have a great season and make the Bucs pay for waiting until 2027 to get a deal done.
The Bucs should have just said, “Fine, do it – and we’ll gladly pay you more if that’s the case.” After all, this franchise made Mike Evans, the greatest offensive player in team history, play out his contract year twice past the age of 30. Chris Godwin Jr. had to play out his most recent contract years twice, and so did Antoine Winfield Jr. during the 2023 season. All three of those players are Pro Bowlers and Super Bowl champions. General manager Jason Licht should have stuck to his guns and made Mayfield do the same this year.

Bucs QB Baker Mayfield and GM Jason Licht – Photo by: Matt Matera/PR
Don’t get it twisted. I’m not opposed to extending Mayfield’s contract at all. I genuinely like the guy and appreciate his leadership, toughness and competitiveness. I’m all for a Mayfield extension if it’s warranted – after the 2026 campaign. The problem for Mayfield has been ineffective play and injuries over the past year – literally the last calendar year. He has not played good football since the Patriots game, where he threw three touchdowns and no interceptions after the bye week in a 27-24 loss.
The NFL is the ultimate “what have you done for me lately?” league. Mayfield turns 32 in April and his play has not been the same since the early part of the 2025 campaign. He and new offensive coordinator Zac Robinson have not meshed well when it comes to the passing game. His three touchdowns and four interceptions as part of the league’s worst-ranked passing game is proof of that.

Bucs OC Zac Robinson and QB Baker Mayfield – Photo by: Cliff Welch/PR
Now that I’ve laid all that out, I’m going to get around to answering your question. The problem with Mayfield’s contract extension is there is no easy escape route for the team. If Mayfield’s play continues to tank, the Bucs could have walked away in 2027 or just used the franchise tag and only be on the hook for one more year to give the QB the chance to rebound with yet another play-caller next year. But the $165 million contract extension through 2028 with a team option year in 2029 prevents that.
Pewter Report’s Josh Queipo tells me that if the Bucs do part ways with Mayfield this offseason and go in a different direction at quarterback in 2027, the team will owe him $50 million in cash and his 2027 dead cap hit will be $65.715 million. If Tampa Bay cuts him after 2027, the team would owe him $20 million in cash and his dead cap is $29.395 million and they save $36.32 million from his cap hit if they keep him. But that’s only if they don’t restructure him next year.
QUESTION: Every single player and coach that has anything to do on the offensive side of the football needs to look in the mirror and should also be re-evaluated. And yes, it pains me to say it but this includes Baker Mayfield. The only person who is exempt is Bucky Irving.
ANSWER: There is no doubt that running back Bucky Irving, who is having a career year so far, has been the team’s runaway MVP on offense. It’s not even close. And unfortunately, on the other side of the spectrum, quarterback Baker Mayfield is playing the worst on offense. When the team spends $55 million on its quarterback and he’s thrown more interceptions (four) than touchdowns (three) and he’s also lost three fumbles, that’s never a good thing.
It doesn’t help matters that Mayfield hurt his foot/ankle when he was awkwardly sacked by Daniel Hardy and Grady Jarrett in Chicago on Sunday Night Football. Mayfield has reportedly been in and out of a walking boot during the Bucs’ bye week, and had the team had a game on Sunday rather than the day off, Mayfield likely wouldn’t have played.

Bears DE Austin Booker and Bucs QB Baker Mayfield – Photo by: IMAGN IMAGES via Reuters Connect
As NFL Network’s Mike Garafalo reported on Sunday, Mayfield could be deemed questionable to play in Detroit this week. Jalon Daniels, who is 1-2 in three starts this year as a rookie, could be making his fourth start of the year. Whoever is at quarterback needs more help from those around him – Irving excluded. Tampa Bay’s entire wide receiver corps has been a disappointment this year, but the offensive coordinator’s non-threatening passing scheme has been a major culprit as well.
The offensive line has played well at times, especially when the Bucs can run the ball successfully, but pass protection has been an issue, as well as several untimely penalties. And Tampa Bay’s tight ends have had an up-and-down season too, and have been non-factors in the passing game. Yes, everyone on offense outside of Irving and a few offensive linemen deserve plenty of scrutiny – Mayfield included. Jason Licht is going to have to focus on revamping the offense next offseason like he did the defense last offseason.
QUESTION: SR, what do you think are the chances that Zac Robinson comes back from the break having more crossers and rolling Baker Mayfield out where he excels? Watching an offense complete two passes on first and second downs and still have six yards to go is the definition of inefficient.
ANSWER: I have no idea if we’ll see more crossers, slants, skinny posts and digs and other short and intermediate routes designed to get the ball into the hands of receivers and tight ends with true yards-after-catch possibilities. I hope so, but we’ve seen too many hitches, which are typically 4-6-yard comeback routes and quick outs where sometimes the receiver only gets 2-3 yards of depth on the route in Zac Robinson’s offense, which is kind of worthless if you ask me.
I’d rather see Bucky Irving get 2-3 yards – and have a chance for more yards – on a run than for either Emeka Egbuka or Chris Godwin Jr. to catch a pass for two yards. And yes, we have seen too many occasions when the Bucs have two completions in a row and it’s still third-and-5 or third-and-6, which is just mind-boggling. This offense just seems to live for third downs – rather than trying to avoid them with longer passes.

Bucs WR Chris Godwin Jr. – Photo by: IMAGN Images via Reuters Connect
I think a huge part of the problem with this passing game is that there are too many shallow routes, such as screen passes and swing passes that go nowhere, or too many hitches and curls where receivers catch the ball with their back to the end zone. Whether it’s Godwin, Egbuka or tight end Cade Otton, none of them have the quick-twitch athleticism to turn and make a defender miss and pick up yards after catch. Every time it’s catch-and-tackle and no chance to get extra yardage after the reception.
So do I think much will change after the bye week? Probably not. This passing game has had nine weeks to change. It didn’t need a bye week to change, and all that really has changed so far is finally not throwing as many screen passes that seemed doomed from the start.
I would like to see more roll-outs and bootlegs from Baker Mayfield, but with him suffering a foot injury in Chicago, I doubt we’ll see that any time soon. Maybe if Jalon Daniels plays in Detroit we’ll see more of those types of calls from Robinson. We’ll see.
QUESTION: I echo my sentiment from last week. I wish we could keep Todd Bowles as defensive coordinator. The defense is solid, but any decision he has to make on the offensive side was just plain wrong. And his “reasoning” is pitiful and embarrassing. He’s not, and never has been, head coach material.
ANSWER: Todd Bowles is 38-39 has the Bucs head coach and has a 1-3 record in the postseason in four and a half seasons. He’s won three division titles, but has two winning seasons and two losing seasons and appears headed for a third losing campaign in 2026 with a 3-6 record coming out of the bye. By the way, Bowles is 1-3 after the bye week in Tampa Bay and 2-6 overall as a head coach when factoring in his 1-3 record with the New York Jets from 2015-18.
As a defensive coordinator, Bowles’ unit has been excellent this year and has gotten better as the season has progressed. Tampa Bay has an NFL-high 21 takeaways that has helped the team improve to a plus-7 turnover margin, which is tied for third in the NFL. The Bucs also lead the league with 16 interceptions and rank first in rushing defense, fourth in total defense, eighth in scoring defense and 10th in passing defense.

Bucs HC Todd Bowles – Photo by: Cliff Welch/PR
General manager Jason Licht also deserves a lot of credit for upgrading the talent on defense through free agency and the draft this past offseason. The two men have worked incredibly well in that regards.
But this is the fifth season in a row where Tampa Bay has had a three-game losing streak, and the second season in a row where the Bucs have lost four games in a row. That has been an absolute killer for this team to really take advantage of a poor NFC South and really take control of the division. Instead, the Bucs have struggled to win it due to losing games that were deemed winnable against lesser opponents, and the division winner always comes down to the final week of the season.
The only way Bowles could possibly stick around as defensive coordinator was if Bruce Arians were to come out of retirement to coach the Bucs again and all parties would agree to him taking over as head coach with Bowles stepping aside for that to happen – and staying on to call plays. I don’t think that ultimately will happen, but it’s the only scenario where it could.
Scott Reynolds is in his 30th year of covering the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as the vice president, publisher and senior Bucs beat writer for PewterReport.com. Author of the popular SR's Fab 5 column on Fridays, Reynolds oversees web development and forges marketing partnerships for PewterReport.com in addition to his editorial duties. A graduate of Kansas State University in 1995, Reynolds spent six years giving back to the community as the defensive coordinator/defensive line coach for his sons' Pop Warner team, the South Pasco Predators. Reynolds can be reached at: [email protected]



