Should Otton return...
 
Notifications
Clear all

Should Otton return?

64 Posts
17 Users
22 Reactions
1,341 Views
Avatar Of Firebowles2026
(@firebowles2026)
Posts: 6502
Captain
 

Posted by: @donkey_hunter

Posted by: @seekpar

Posted by: @donkey_hunter

Posted by: @biggs3535

Posted by: @jc5100

Yea let’s draft an offensive skill player and then crucify Bowles for the defense 

Five out of the last eight first picks have been on defense. Poor fella just can't get any help.

 

It’s just some miscommunication issues. 

Year 8 should be season we get it fixed. 

These things take time. 

 

Yeah, but I should get a chance to keep my job since I won three straight division titles...

 

"Check your sheets. I'm ballin"

 

Lmfao 

Toddis Winston 

 


 
Posted : Jan. 23, 2026 2:15 am
Avatar Of Olafsnowfake
(@bucsbits)
Posts: 10458
Captain
 

Josh Q

 

"The Cade Otton slander has to stop. This is not an advocacy for him as a top eight tight end in the league. But if you want the Buccaneers to move on from Otton I need to hear an upgrade plan. And that’s going to be harder than most people think.

If you want a flashy and explosive pass catcher (I’ve heard a lot about Atlanta’s Kyle Pitts in the last week with the arrival of new offensive coordinator Zac Robinson), that player will cost precious dollars that won’t go to the defense. Oh, and what’s the plan when the Bucs want to run the ball? Because that move guy ain’t blocking nearly as well as my guy, Otton."


 
Posted : Jan. 27, 2026 1:53 pm
Avatar Of Olafsnowfake
(@bucsbits)
Posts: 10458
Captain
 

Posted by: @bucsbits

Josh Q

 

"The Cade Otton slander has to stop. This is not an advocacy for him as a top eight tight end in the league. But if you want the Buccaneers to move on from Otton I need to hear an upgrade plan. And that’s going to be harder than most people think.

If you want a flashy and explosive pass catcher (I’ve heard a lot about Atlanta’s Kyle Pitts in the last week with the arrival of new offensive coordinator Zac Robinson), that player will cost precious dollars that won’t go to the defense. Oh, and what’s the plan when the Bucs want to run the ball? Because that move guy ain’t blocking nearly as well as my guy, Otton."

 

SR's counter is funny (to me) because its only about the money but doesn't provide an actual alternative saying only there must better blocker and a better receiver. Not ONE player who is better at both?

https://www.pewterreport.com/bucs-re-sign-cade-otton-point-counterpoint/

 


 
Posted : Jan. 27, 2026 1:58 pm
Avatar Of Seekpar
(@seekpar)
Posts: 1723
First Mate
 

Maybe if Otton hits the weight room and adds some bulk to hold onto the ball when it's thrown to him, and blocks a bit better...

Otherwise NO.


 
Posted : Jan. 27, 2026 4:37 pm
Mic
 Mic
(@mic)
Posts: 2176
Quartermaster
 

I don't mind Otton there is value in keeping in guy like Otton around who has also been developed in areas of his blocking. We'll see how the cap works out though i believe the cap goes up percentage every year with a 295m projected for 2026, 279m in 2025  2024 was 255m and 2023 was around 225m

 

So I think a 8m per year contract for Otton is a fair 2.71% of the cap

 

The league salary cap is projected to grow each year as our game grows

If we dont stay otton theres a few guys this draft that look solid for a tightend


This post was modified 2 months ago by Mic
 
Posted : Jan. 27, 2026 10:18 pm
Avatar Of Badabingbucs
(@badabingbucs)
Posts: 3885
Quartermaster
 

Posted by: @mic

I don't mind Otton there is value in keeping in guy like Otton around who has also been developed in areas of his blocking. We'll see how the cap works out though i believe the cap goes up percentage every year with a 295m projected for 2026, 279m in 2025  2024 was 255m and 2023 was around 225m

 

So I think a 8m per year contract for Otton is a fair 2.71% of the cap

 

The league salary cap is projected to grow each year as our game grows

If we dont stay otton theres a few guys this draft that look solid for a tightend

Not sure he is worth the $8M per year.  As an example that is what Kyle Pitts is making

some free agents available - Kyle Pitts, Dallas Goedert, Isaiah Likely, David Njoku, Darren Waller, etc

to me, Otton is an easily replaceable guy 

Pitts would be top target, Likely a sleeper, and the other guys past their prime but maybe better options that bumbling, stumbling INT machine Otton

 


 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 3:23 pm
Avatar Of Olafsnowfake
(@bucsbits)
Posts: 10458
Captain
 

Posted by: @badabingbucs

Posted by: @mic

I don't mind Otton there is value in keeping in guy like Otton around who has also been developed in areas of his blocking. We'll see how the cap works out though i believe the cap goes up percentage every year with a 295m projected for 2026, 279m in 2025  2024 was 255m and 2023 was around 225m

 

So I think a 8m per year contract for Otton is a fair 2.71% of the cap

 

The league salary cap is projected to grow each year as our game grows

If we dont stay otton theres a few guys this draft that look solid for a tightend

Not sure he is worth the $8M per year.  As an example that is what Kyle Pitts is making

some free agents available - Kyle Pitts, Dallas Goedert, Isaiah Likely, David Njoku, Darren Waller, etc

to me, Otton is an easily replaceable guy 

Pitts would be top target, Likely a sleeper, and the other guys past their prime but maybe better options that bumbling, stumbling INT machine Otton

 

 

I am not an Otton homer. If he was easy to replace SR probably names a couple replacement. He suggested it might take two players. Not because Otton is great but because he does do both which itself an advantage over 2.  

I can imagine the Bucs keeping him if they can. Especially true given other needs. 

 


This post was modified 1 month ago by OlafSnowfake
 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 4:59 pm
Mic reacted
Avatar Of Trask Force
(@catherder)
Posts: 2806
Quartermaster
 

You gotta have tight ends.  Otton is a good #2 TE.  He was a 4th round pick.  The fact that we don't have a #1 is not his fault, and the Bucs don't have to pay him like one either.   If we can slot him in for $6 or $7 mil that's great. Noah Gray makes $6 mil for example.  If Otton is going to get $10 mil or more on the market then you have to let him walk and go the free agent route.  


This post was modified 1 month ago by Trask Force
 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 7:07 pm
Avatar Of Donkey_Hunter
(@donkey_hunter)
Posts: 6262
Captain
 

Otton is a JAG. 

Can replace him in the draft. 


 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 8:52 pm
Avatar Of Firebowles2026
(@firebowles2026)
Posts: 6502
Captain
 

Posted by: @donkey_hunter

Otton is a JAG. 

Can replace him in the draft. 

He's barely a JAG. Get the comp pick 

 


 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 9:05 pm
Mic
 Mic
(@mic)
Posts: 2176
Quartermaster
 

Posted by: @bucsbits

Posted by: @badabingbucs

Posted by: @mic

I don't mind Otton there is value in keeping in guy like Otton around who has also been developed in areas of his blocking. We'll see how the cap works out though i believe the cap goes up percentage every year with a 295m projected for 2026, 279m in 2025  2024 was 255m and 2023 was around 225m

 

So I think a 8m per year contract for Otton is a fair 2.71% of the cap

 

The league salary cap is projected to grow each year as our game grows

If we dont stay otton theres a few guys this draft that look solid for a tightend

Not sure he is worth the $8M per year.  As an example that is what Kyle Pitts is making

some free agents available - Kyle Pitts, Dallas Goedert, Isaiah Likely, David Njoku, Darren Waller, etc

to me, Otton is an easily replaceable guy 

Pitts would be top target, Likely a sleeper, and the other guys past their prime but maybe better options that bumbling, stumbling INT machine Otton

 

 

I am not an Otton homer. If he was easy to replace SR probably names a couple replacement. He suggested it might take two players. Not because Otton is great but because he does do both which itself an advantage over 2.  

I can imagine the Bucs keeping him if they can. Especially true given other needs. 

 

 

I dont think any of us are otton homers, but I think its just we have bias that we get to see more bucs game. But Otton was 572 #15 in receiving yards for tightends this year and I think he was #16 the year before with 600. I think he has made improvements so as long as he continues developing he can find a role. We can't find a top 10 guy at every position so for what otton does its reasonable given the expectation.

One avenue I would like to explore is the mcvay 13 personnel he runs in goalline with 3 tightnends having culp/Kieft, durham, otton and mike on the outside. Mike can run the fade or the slant depending on corner leverage and keep heavy personnel as usually teams will man up in those heavy formations. Which is what we saw Rams do most of last season, even against us for a couple of td's with Adams instead of Mike

 


 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 11:34 pm
Avatar Of Trask Force
(@catherder)
Posts: 2806
Quartermaster
 

You gotta say Otton caught the ball in some tough spots.  Nobody catches them all, but he usually did and usually he was getting hit pretty good.  He certainly isn't flashy and he isn't a Mack Truck.  He wasn't great, but he was pretty dependable.  


 
Posted : Jan. 28, 2026 11:58 pm
Avatar Of Charles
(@manfromroom5)
Posts: 77
Master At Arms
 

otton sucks...loser


 
Posted : Jan. 29, 2026 2:38 am
Avatar Of Olafsnowfake
(@bucsbits)
Posts: 10458
Captain
 

Posted by: @firebowles2026

Posted by: @donkey_hunter

Otton is a JAG. 

Can replace him in the draft. 

He's barely a JAG. Get the comp pick 

 

 

what would that be?

 


 
Posted : Jan. 29, 2026 8:39 am
Avatar Of Olafsnowfake
(@bucsbits)
Posts: 10458
Captain
 

Posted by: @bucsbits

Posted by: @firebowles2026

Posted by: @donkey_hunter

Otton is a JAG. 

Can replace him in the draft. 

He's barely a JAG. Get the comp pick 

 

 

what would that be?

 

 

JQ;s comment on the draft option

 

"If your answer is finding Otton’s replacement in the draft. That’s a big resource to replace a complete player. Likely a first- or second-rounder. In the last three years, only one tight end drafted outside of the first round has stepped in as a rookie and played at a high level as a complete player. That was Chargers tight end Oronde Gadsden II."

 

Otton is sort of middle of the pack and he does both things which give the offense versatility.  Not that easy to replace

 


 
Posted : Jan. 29, 2026 8:56 am
Page 3 / 5
Share: