About the author

Scott Reynolds

Scott Reynolds is in his 23rd year of covering the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as the vice president, publisher and senior Bucs beat writer for PewterReport.com. Author of the popular SR's Fab 5 column on Fridays, Reynolds oversees web development and forges marketing partnerships for PewterReport.com in addition to his editorial duties. A graduate of Kansas State University in 1995, Reynolds enjoys giving back to the community as the defensive line coach for his sons' Pop Warner team, the South Pasco Predators. Reynolds can be reached at: [email protected]

Related Articles

27 Comments

  1. 1

    CrackerBall

    The tough thing about being a vocal leader is having the gravitas to influence – otherwise Riley Bullough would be the leader of this team. McCoy will never be the vocal guy we want him to be. In the old days, we had Warren Sapp, Derrick Brooks and John Lynch – all vocal with the peaches to back it up. People respected them because they could bring it as well as preach it.

    Ah… the good old days.

  2. 2

    FLBoy84

    Definitely hit the nail on the head with GMC section Scott. He came out with another “I’m not good enough, thanks for the push, I hear you” tweet regarding not getting a single All-Pro vote last month. Believe Sapp would’ve been more like “F%$k you” instead of “thanks for the push”, which I believe more players respond too. That whole “do your job” and “us vs the world” mentality resonates more with players imo than the “come on guys, we can do better”. LIke Kwon, but just don’t see him as being that guy yet that can lead the entire team, though he does have the demeanor. Hard to see a rookie coming in and having that king of galvanizing effect as well. Seems it would have to come from a FA (like a Calais Campbell last yr), but not sure one like him is out there this year, (yet).

    1. 2.1

      Cody

      Who gets the better end of the deal if the Bucs trade their 7th pick for both of the Bills first rounders this year? I know they need a QB and we need to fill some holes so I feel like this may be a good trade. What do you think?

      1. 2.1.1

        FLBoy84

        Think you’re spot-on Cody. Would be down for that, as the value is comparable, though it would obviously depend on who’s there at #7 right? Lot’s of mocks out there have the top QB’s gone by #7 so, if the run on QB’s start early, Buffalo is probably calling Cleveland at #4. If we did make the move, good chance a G/C like Wynn or Price and a DL like Bryan or Hurst are there as well.

        1. 2.1.1.1

          Cody

          Yeah if Chubb somehow falls to us then I’d stay and take him at 7. But if we get those two first rounders from Buffalo then we could definitely get Hurst and maybe Josh Jackson as well or Harold Landry. I’d also be totally okay with taking Davenport at that point as well.

  3. 3

    TBChucky

    I agree on GMC and Fitzpatrick. He’s my least favorite blue chipper, for the Bucs anyway. Not saying that he’s not a good player. I think they’d probably prefer a true CB like Jackson from Iowa, or the kid from Ohio State. I’m hoping you’re right, and they fill that need through free agency. Focus on the lines and RB in the draft please.

  4. 4

    BucFanInNC

    Everyone clamoring for Baker & Ayers to be cut but what about Gholston? Dude was trash too.

  5. 5

    athans5

    I don’t understand why everyone is so hot on Fitzpatrick. I personally think that Derwin James is the better player of the two. I’m actually a Florida fan so I’m not a homer, I just think that guy has the abilities to be special. In my opinion, him, Nelson, and Barkley should be our top prospects at 7. Why does no one talk about Derwin? After the combine I guarantee he will be a top 10 pick in mock drafts.

    If you don’t believe me please refer to this http://www.nfl.com/news/story/0ap3000000844755/article/derwin-james-scouts-see-future-nfl-star-in-freakish-fsu-safety

    1. 5.1

      macabee

      Thought of you my friend when I saw this. Enjoy!

      https://www.cbssports.com/nfl/draft/news/2018-nfl-mock-draft-both-new-york-teams-get-qbs-49ers-give-jimmy-g-a-running-mate/

      Oh, btw, PFF has the same idea. Good luck on your picks. Go Bucs!

  6. 6

    surferdudes

    McCoy isn’t going to change as a leader, and he’ll never give up the C on his chest because he’s a media whore. It’s obvious his goal now is to make more pro bowls, and go on to a career at ESPN, or NFL Net when he retires. Eight years going on nine we hear the same song, and dance from McCoy, time to realize it’s all talk. If the Bucs don’t move on from Gerry then they better draft Vita Vea instead of a safety. Put a top ten D line talent next to McCoy to finally shut up the McCoy apologist’s who say he never had any help. Vea commands two, sometimes three blockers, if it really takes two blocking McCoy a blind D end, or L.B. should get more sacks. I still don’t get how all of a sudden calling Monken a real O.C. makes him one? You mean he was really only half O.C.? He was one cheek, Koetter the other, and together they formed one ass? Stop the nonsense I feel like I’m taking crazy pills!! If he doesn’t call the plays, or have final say on the game plan he’s NOT an O.C..

  7. 7

    Tampa 2.2

    I totally disagrees with your FAB 2. The great number of NFL executive of the year award having, HOFer William Patrick “Bill” Polian Jr. once said, “If you are drafting in the top 10 you must select a player who scores TDs, protect the passer blind side, sack QBs, take the ball away or score TDs.” In other words the only positions you should draft in the top ten are LT, QB, DE, RB, or WR. Offensive Guard Quenton Nelson or Defensive Tackle Vita Vea doesn’t fits Bill criteria to be selected with the Bucs 7th pick.
    Let’s take a look at Vita Vea and the offensive Guard position. 1st question: Does Vita sacks the QB?
    The answer is no or not nearly enough to be selected in the top 10. In 3 years of playing Vita have a grand total 9.5 sacks in 3 years. Point of reference Warren Sapp had 19.5 sacks and was drafted 12th overall by our beloved Tampa Bay Bucs. I don’t care how Vita performs at the NFL combine he still don’t deserve to be selected by the Bucs with the 7th pick. A trade down option in the teens then we can talk. As for Quenton, a really good player but he plays the guard position. When you look at the Guard position, you can draft a good to great guard later in the draft. Also guard is not one of them game changing positions. Let’s take a look at this year Pro Bowl guards and where they was selected:
    Kelechi Osemele 2nd round; David De Castro 1st 24th pick; Richie Incognito 3rd round; Zack Martin 1st round 16th pick; Brandon Brooks 3rd round; TJ Lane 1st 30th pick Trai Turner 3rd round and Larry Warford 3rd round. Bottom line a 5 and 11 team should not be considering drafting a guard with the 7th pick.
    Jason normally does well in the draft so I think the Bucs are considering drafting Bradly Chub, Sequon Barkley, MinKan Fitzpatrcik, Marcus Davanport or Arden Key with the 7th pick. If Jason selects Quenton Nelson or Vita Vea with the 7th pick, I hope Pewter Report is still hiring next year because Jason will need a new job. All jokes a side I expect Scott to never mock Vita or Quenton Nelson to the Bucs at 7th once he gets intel at the Combine in two weeks.

  8. 8

    JustaBuc

    The amount of criticism McCoy receives for absolutely nothing is frankly f*cking pathetic. You’d think the guy played every position on the football team. Dude’s done nothing but ball at an elite level for us, half the time injured and with no help, and the fanbase thinks he’s the problem. Lmao.

    People write about leadership like its some possession that McCoy can just dig out of his locker and hand to some louder rah-rah man since everybody should aspire to the masculine fantasy that being a hard ass is the de-facto best and only valid leadership style. Christ, let’s go hire Schiano again in that case I’m sure that’ll work out.

    If all these other guys SHOULD be leaders, why don’t they seize it themselves?

  9. 9

    Bucsfan1983

    Seriously Scott?

    The Bucs should absolutely not pass on Fitz, if the opportunity is there. There are 4 players they should be looking at #7, Chubb, Fitz, Barkley and James. If all four are gone, then look to trade down for Nelson, Davenport, Vea or whoever.

    I don’t think all 4 will be gone by 7, at least 3-4 QBs will be going before 7.

  10. 10

    stlbucsfan

    It makes no sense that we are still having articles written about GMC not being a vocal leader. Tony Dungy didn’t lead the same as Gruden but they both have the same amount of rings. Writing articles that even suggest that GMC is the problem is asinine. The problem with this defense is the guy who surrounded GMC with “top notch” talent like William Gholston, Robert Ayers, Chris Baker, Michael Johnson, Stevie T, George Johnson and I could go on but you get the point. GMC doesn’t need to be Warren Sapp to win in the NFL, plenty of players win Super Bowls ring that lead in their own way. Talent has and always will however determine outcome. We churn through coaches every 2 years because we spend more time looking at what other teams are doing versus evaluating what WE need to do better with the players we have. I can’t get behind any talk about one of our better and more productive defensive players being the “problem.” We have 99 problems but GMC aint one.

  11. 11

    RootsCrew

    Unfortunately, the Fab 3 likely won’t happen. Koetter is a dinosaur in terms of how he views football. Despite the overwhelming evidence that his defense couldn’t hold leads/or consistently hold the other teams offense, he still punted or called plays “not to lose” instead of going for the win. That’s just who he is. He thinks it’s still 2008. The lack of using the QB sneak has driven me mad since 2015. He’d rather go 5 wide on 3rd and 1 than use the sneak with Jameis.

    In regards to the Fab 2, I’m not against drafting Minkah dependent on who is left when our number comes up. If he’s BPA, we need to draft him. Derwin is a better box safety (with ability to play all over the secondary) to pair with Evans, but I doubt we take him. As you pointed out, Minkah is a good football player. We need more good football players. We need to get lucky and have 4 QB’s and Barkley go in the first 6 picks. That’ll leave Nelson or Chubb available at 7.

    1. 11.1

      RootsCrew

      And you really can’t compare teams when evaluating if McCoy elevated his teammates play. The talent is night and day different.

      1997: Sapp’s 3rd year
      Hardy, Brooks (HOF), Lynch (HOF worthy), Donnie, Culpepper, Upshaw

      1998: Sapp’s 4th year
      Hardy, Brooks, Lynch, Donnie, Culpepper, Upshaw, Ronde (HOF worthy)

      2000: Sapp’s 6th year
      Booger, Brooks, Lynch, Donnie, Ronde, Quarles, Robinson

      Contrast the supporting casts

      2012: GMC’s 3rd year
      LVD, 37 year old Ronde, Barron, Bennett, Foster, Ahmad, Miller

      2013: GMC’s 4th year
      LVD, Barron, Foster, Dashon, Clayborn, Revis, Banks, Akeem

      2015: GMC’s 6th year
      LVD, Kwon, Conte, Gholston, Jacquies, Lansanah, McDougald, Moore, Verner

      Does anyone really think GMC should be responsible for elevating those players to his level? Sapp greatly benefited from having a quality DT next to him his entire Bucs career AND HOF’ers roaming around behind him. Plus he had a genius DC in Monty. GMC has had avg to below avg players around him on defense his entire career. Especially on the DL. Plus he’s played under Sheridan/Lovie/Frazier as his DC’s. I just don’t buy this notion that somehow Sapp would elevate these putrid Bucs defenses because he was a nasty leader. A players greatness needs help to truly reach it’s potential. GMC has definitely not had that in 8 years in Tampa. How about we put good players next to him & in the secondary and then see how much his play/leadership elevates his teammates.

      1. 11.1.1

        Ken - Kfromfla

        Great players make plays when it counts. Great defensive players create stops on critical drives. Great player make plays. Ask Brandon Graham about his strip-sack, or Julian Edelman about his ridiculous diving catch in SB – 51, or Von Miller about his sack on Cam, or Malcom Butler about his Int. Great players make plays in when it counts.

        Now, name that play for McCoy in 8 seasons? Maybe the hurry on Ryan in 2016? I can’t think of another out of 109 games and a $100 Million dollar investment. Please name another. I’ll wait.

  12. 12

    Ken - Kfromfla

    I hate the subject of leadership on the defensive side of the ball because when I try to explain my issue with it, I get accused of McCoy bashing, when that is never what I set out to do. Gerald McCoy is one of the best DT in the game, but his position as team leader dramatically reduces his possible contributions. Let me explain.

    Football is a man’s man sport, alpha male trying to take the heads off of other alpha males, especially on the defensive side of the ball. Yet, the bucs are soft on defense, there is just no two ways about it. Name one player on the Bucs team that any offense should fear? I’m not talking about game plan for the player, but fear. In the past, Sapp would immediately come to mind up front while they had Lynch in the back. The psychological effect of the QB worrying about the mauling hit from Sapp, or a receiver worrying about the violent pop he will get from Lynch cannot be overstated. Name that player on the 2015 – 2017 Bucs team. I do not know of a single one. Sure there have been good players, but none bring the “I want to break you in half” crushing blows from guys like Fletcher Cox, Calais Campbell, and Ndamukong Suh, or the violent strikes of Aaron Donald. Soft is not an endearing label for a defense, and I do not know how that label can be avoided for the current Buccaneer defense.

    Recently, Barry Church’s hit on Gronk, while the heads did collide, it was not because Church intended, it was a case of Gronk leaning that caused the helmet to helmet contact. Church fearlessly took on a man a heck of a lot bigger than hi. That is setting the tone. In the Super Bowl, Eagles safety Malcolm Jenkins had the opportunity just to tackle Brandin Cooks, but he laid a hard hit on him that likely changed the outcome of the game. Football is a brutal sport and the Bucs have a bunch of softies.

    While McCoy is the designated leader, he is not they type of leader that makes people around him better, which is what is most needed. McCoy is almost a counterbalance to Kwon’s passion on the defensive side, displaying a more CEO type calmness rather than the passion of a football leader. Listen to his speeches and you will think he is leading a sales conference. It is fine that this is his personality, but having that type of player out front does not help anyone. McCoy is leading the team in the wrong direction.

    McCoy seems to be unhappy when criticized or challenged for the leadership role. So how do the Bucs find a leader on the defensive side of the ball as long as McCoy is in the locker room? I do not see McCoy giving up his role as the face of Buccaneer defense without a fight, and he is the last person, IMO that the Bucs need as their leader on defense. Let him lead off the field; he is fantastic at that, but in the locker room, McCoy is in the way of the passion, grit, and tenacity needed on the defensive.

    I just do not see how you fix it. McCoy is too good a player to let go, but too much of a drag on football spirit, that spunk that #99 bought every game to have at the lead dog position. None of this is McCoy’s faut either. He is who he is and McCoy is a great DT, doing what he is paid to do. McCoy is paid to play, and he played well in 2017. He is not paid to be a leader.

    It is management’s responsibility to recognized the leadership problem on the defensive side of the ball and find a solution. It is an awful conundrum for the Bucs, with no easy answers. JMHO.

    (Parts of this were previously used by me)

  13. 13

    owlykat

    Enjoyed your entire article. McCoy needs to up his leadership by example and pass the Captainship to the caller of the Defense who has the fire to do it. Licht’s failure to build from the trenches forward is the real problem!
    Koetter used to call QB sneaks when Jameis had the weight to pull it off but he should have never let Jameis lose his weight which led to his injury and increased fumbles. Koetter’s pampered practices does not prepare his teams to be strong enough to dominate. He needs to visit the Gator practices going on right now and take notes and watch how much better the Gators perform this year. It is how Ohio State dominates too. If Vea is gone at 7 along with Chubb, Licht needs to draft down and get more picks.

  14. 14

    martinii

    Fab 1 regarding Mc Coy and his leadership strategy absolutely makes me sick to my stomach. This site is beginning to remind me of another Hater site which I have all but stopped visiting. For all you experts on leadership the most basic form is by example. No he doesn’t have the fire and brimstone, no he’s not the animated spokes person or maybe he doesn’t have the Warren Sapp bravado, but every time he steps on that field opposing coaches and players are game planning for him with double teams. So go ahead trade hime, cut him, ridicule him because all he has done is give you 9 years of hard work and dedication. Tonight I am ashamed to be a Buc Fan and have to read this garbage from a Site I had learned to respect over the years.

  15. 15

    SaskBucs

    Fab 1- Agree. I never bash McCoy’s play but I have been in a locker room my whole life and if you can’t confront teammates or even the coach in a proper manner, you aren’t leading properly.

    Fab 2- Admittedly, I don’t understand the talents and projections of these college ballers as I don’t usually watch but I tend to agree with what you said and I am firmly in the camp of drafting for the trenches.

    Fab 3- Agree, but only if Koetter can stop telegraphing plays and targets. Get creative, sneak Winston, fake an end around to DJax and hit Godwin on a quick slant, Howard on a shallow cross, Evans on a quick out.. something has to work, look at those weapons listed minus Brate, Hump and a new RB.. it’s ludicrous.

  16. 16

    Garv

    It never ceases to amaze me how much crap Gerald McCoy takes from some fans. And of course the media inflames it for even more attention. He is himself, will always BE himself and that is an NFL Pro Bowl DT year after year after year.

    I do agree that Kwon and Jameis are the leaders now and that’s fine. I love their passion and drive to win the damn games. In fact their drive to win the damn games is, ironically, the very thing some fans were bitching about when they led the team to the final win against the Saints. How many times did we hear complaints about dropping in the draft?

    If the Bucs draft a CB, ANY CB, in the first or second round I’d be shocked. Barring trade down expect Barkley, Chubb or Nelsen to be the guy, whoever makes it to 7. In the second round? HAS to be a RB if Barkley’s gone at 7, doesn’t it?

    The eagles proved it. You play to freaking win the game! That includes going for it on 4th and short. Bucs get any kind of running game going and 4th and one is a call that would fire up their OL and show faith in Koetter’s players. I know we have a great punter but let’s score points!

    Nice 5 as always Scott.

  17. 17

    Alldaway 2.0

    Fix the lines.

    Passing superior safety talent in the 2018 draft isn’t a good idea but the Bucs don’t have that luxury with their o-line/d-line.

    Fix the lines.

  18. 18

    scubog

    I’m a little late reading the Fab 5 this week, but I’ll offer my take on the on going GMC debate. There are lots of ways to lead and certainly being one of the players to demonstrate how it’s done is one of them. It sure would be difficult to get folks to follow your lead when you don’t do things properly or take the easy way out yourself. Gerald and the great Lee Roy Selmon are great examples. But unlike #63, #93 rarely takes over a game or comes through when needed most like Selmon, Sapp, Brooks or my favorite example, Barber.

    Like Selmon, GMC just doesn’t have the personality of a Nickerson or Sapp that brought the ingredient that has been missing for so long……….swagger. But it’s not just about “getting in a teammate’s face”. It’s about getting after the opponent’s ass and scaring the shit out of them.

    It’s like that old cartoon with the little dog running around without fear because of his pal the big dog, “Go get em Spike”. We need Spike

  19. 19

    plopes808

    GMC’s leadership style is just fine. We already have Kwon bringing the fire on defense so having 2 of the same leadership style is a waste. Not to mention the fact that the “in your face” style is obviously not GMC at all.

    I hope we don’t reach on Fitzpatrick when clearly our most sure-fire hit would be to draft Nelson and put him next to Ali. Those 2 would bust gaping holes through D-lines and allow our backs to gallop through them. If we can land Michel in the 2nd round, our 2 picks would compliment each other very well. Add Crowell in FA and we’d have a nice rotation going with he/Barber/Michel. We’d guard against injuries as well with several options to choose from.

    As for RZ playcalling…I don’t think we can narrow it down to just the red zone. Playcalling has to change…period. I understand that Dirk is on his last leg and doesn’t feel comfortable putting his fate in the hands of Monken’s playcalling. But at the same time, “insanity is doing the same thing repeatedly and expecting a different result.”

  20. 20

    jp414

    Spend a first round, seventh overall pick on a G? Who does that? The last time anybody spent a pick that high on an OG was AZ taking Jonathan Cooper at pick #7 in 2013. How’d that work out for them?
    SF drafted Mike Iupati at pick 17 in 2010. Other than those two, no guards have been taken any higher than 23rd by any team for the last 15 years!
    This team needs a pass rush. And, CB help. And, a RB. And, maybe a LT & C. All of those – before OG.

  21. 21

    Dan.B

    Yes i totally agree that we should pass on Fitzpatrick with the 7th pick and go for either Vea or Nelson. both are mammoths that move extremely well and will be contributing players for a long time. I also think we should double up on big men with our 2nd round pick of the draft as well. if we take nelson, maybe the Florida DT taven bryan will be there in the early 2nd, or if we take Vea at 7, why not go for a solid OLinemen with our 2nd pick.

    the game is won and lost in the trenches, our trench fighters aren’t very good, we need to do our best to get bigger, an stronger up front on both sides of the ball.

Leave a Reply

© 2017 PewterReport.com All Rights reserved. Marketing Tampa | Visual Realm

Send this to a friend