About the author

Scott Reynolds

Scott Reynolds is in his 23rd year of covering the Tampa Bay Buccaneers as the vice president, publisher and senior Bucs beat writer for PewterReport.com. Author of the popular SR's Fab 5 column on Fridays, Reynolds oversees web development and forges marketing partnerships for PewterReport.com in addition to his editorial duties. A graduate of Kansas State University in 1995, Reynolds enjoys giving back to the community as the defensive line coach for his sons' Pop Warner team, the South Pasco Predators. Reynolds can be reached at: [email protected]

Related Articles


  1. 1


    Like the Vea call if Grubb goes to Colts and the Penny Pick was interesting and like the idea of drafting a DB over 6’0, We are not adding a lot to our sack deficiency but IMO Sacks are overrated. Need for QB pressures huge and it appears that is exactly what we are going to have to settle for in 2018. Long way to APRIL.

  2. 2


    My God….I hope this isn’t based on inside sources. If this is how the Bucs draft turns out, we can all look forward to a lot of F grades

    1. 2.1


      Other than providing more fodder for the “experts” to discuss to keep themselves employed, see no real-life implications of any of the grades assigned before any of the prospects have even played in a friggin’ NFL game yet.

  3. 3

    Easythe great

    LOL thank god Scott Reynolds is just a journalist and not a GM.

    1. 3.1


      So you’re saying you aren’t a fan of firing 3 head coaches in 6 years…or just this mock draft? 😂

  4. 4


    Poor mock draft for the Bucs! Unless the team is going to transition to a 3-4 as their base defense. Neglecting a true edge rusher in the first two rounds and the interior of their offensive line, this make no sense.

    Understand PewterReport has been pushing the switch to a 3-4 and Vea, however when you look at market share production data for Vea, defensively. His projections of speed score & market share fall short of historical benchmarks, to even be considered a Probowl caliber talent compared to peers since the 1989 NFL draft.

    While many are looking at Vea as a Dontari Poe clone, the two couldn’t be further apart. And if the Bucs are looking for someone like Poe, he is a free agent! Spend free agent dollars to acquire known production versus unknown. Use your draft capital to fill another need.

    Vea is not in the same class as Poe, Ngata, Wilfork from a production standpoint using market share. I just do not see him being worth the 7th overall pick.

    I digress.

    Not my draft , and would be a waste of a top 10 pick to take a space clogging two gapper.

    1. 4.1


      I concur, if we are looking at a later first round pick then I would be more comfortable with this pick.

      When considering a top 10 selection, the goal is a perennial Pro Bowler as the greatest share of any drafts Pro Bowl players are taken in that area. You don’t wing it with solid but unlikely to be spectacular players in the hopes that it works out for them.

      Star Lotulelei was a better prospect coming out and while he has played an important role for their defense I think you’d be hard pressed to say his impact has been Pro Bowl worthy or what you hope to get with a top 10 pick.

  5. 5


    When you hear 345 lbs you think the guy might be fat like big bellied Baker. Looking at Vea tho the guy is built. Don’t know why some are getting on you Scott, the fan base is to fixed on drafting a D end, they’re being blinded to the fact there just isn’t one worth taking at #7. I believe we have as much need at DT, as DE, and Vea would be an instant up grade. Quizz, Sims, and Martin need to go, and Penny would also be an instant up grade. If you’re first two picks are instant up grades that contribute right away it’s already a decent draft. Thinking you’re going to draft great players in every round is being unrealistic.

    1. 5.1


      You should look for a Pro Bowl quality player in the top 10 of the draft. If you don’t get one then your GM has ‘missed’ by historical trends.

      2 gap DT’s aren’t the same premium that a fast twitch DE is, as a result they don’t collect the same paychecks or merit the same draft status. There is a reason you don’t see these players breaking the bank, and you can find adequate replacements for marginal costs. Now if you think Vea is a unicorn of the position and staring down the barrel of multiple pro bowls as a 3 down space stuffer who NFL olines are game planning on how to pass defend, then I’m game.

  6. 6


    Yeah I’m not a fan of this one either. Vea could totally be a great player and so could Penny. But I really think one of the top 4 guys (Chubb, Fitzpatrick, Barkley, and Nelson) will fall to us at 7 and I would want that guy for sure. Vea isn’t a top 10 guy right now though so I don’t want him unless we trade down. Also, Sony Michel is a much better running back for the second round than Penny.

    Finally, Shaquem Griffin in the 6th or 7th round please. 🙂

    1. 6.1


      Like the idea of Griffin as a late round pick as well Cody. Guy plays with a heart and intensity that would mesh well in the LB room.

      1. 6.1.1


        Yeah I don’t think that he would fit in our scheme very well unless we’re for sure going to a 3-4. If Tampa or Jax doesn’t get him then I’d want him in San Fran, Seattle, or New England because I think he’d fit in there. John Lynch has already said some really great stuff about him and I could see him pulling the trigger. Belichick could also put him in a really great position to succeed as well.



          Agreed, all are great destinations for him. Was glad to see he received a Combine invite as well.

  7. 7


    Bucs 2018 Mock Draft V3

    Draft Strategy

    My draft strategy has been and remains to fix the defense. This draft is almost exclusively dedicated to fixing the defense. I’ve seen the experts prediction that DE Chubb will be taken by the Colts – not buying it yet. Just yesterday, ESPN’s Mike Wells believes Penn State RB Saquon Barkley will be in play for the Colts with the third overall pick (see Rotoworld). Lots of time left for things to change.

    RD1 DE Bradley Chubb/ NC State 6-4 275 4.80
    *This game wrecker needs no introduction. He is the #1 DE in the draft. The alternative pick is OG Quenton Nelson. The Pewter Poll says 71% of you agree.

    RD2 DE Marcus Davenport/UT San Antonio 6-6 251 4.77
    *Never thought he was a first round pick. Had him in the second round in my last mock. Will need development, but too talented to pass up here. DE/DT Taven Bryan/Florida 6-4 295 4.99 is the alternative.

    RD3RB Rashaad Penny/San Diego State 5-11 220 4.52
    *Penny will probably be drafted in the 2nd round, but I put him in the 3rd round because he can’t pass protect and he’s prone to fumble. But he’s such a weapon, you gotta have a threat like him on your team. RB Royce Freeman/Oregon 5-11 238 4.54 is the alternative.

    RD4 DT Nathan Shepherd/Fort Hayes State 6-4 310 5.04
    *Big Nate was impressive at the Senior Bowl until he broke his hand. I know that Trevor Sikkema was impressed with Nathan. DT Deadrin Senat/USF 6-1 305 5.12 is the alternative.

    RD5 FS Natrell Jamerson/Wisconsin 5-11 200 4.49
    *Natrell Jamerson was named Defensive MVP of 2018 East-West Shrine Game. FS/CB Dane Cruikshank/Arizona 6-1 206 4.50 is the alternative.

    RD6 K Eddy Pineiro/Florida 5-11 178 4.84
    *That’s right I said kicker. Lol. The Bucs need a kicker that is accurate and can kick deep – nailed an 81 yarder. This kid can do both (see his stats). He’s got a 4th round grade, but I researched two 7 round mocks (Draftsite and Drafttek) and couldn’t find him. Couldn’t blame Licht if he ran and hid if he were to read this, but ya gotta keep trying til ya get it right! This a low risk pick.

    RD6 OG Matt Gono/Wesley College 6-4 319 5.36
    *Gono was mentioned as the best offensive player at the NFLPA Bowl. This D-III standout (like Ali Marpet/Hobart) is a powerful run blocker with good technique that gets downfield quickly. This big fella is my sleeper pick. Could be another Arron Sears – plays like him.

    RD7 Complementary Pick
    *The Bucs do not have a 7th round pick. We traded our original 7th round pick to move up and select DT Stevie T in the 2017 draft. This is an anticipated comp pick. I did not select a player here as I expect the Bucs to use this pick to trade up as they usually do.

    1. 7.1

      Nicholas Micciche

      Love the thought process here and the alternate picks. Comp pick would be nice, totally forgot about us perhaps getting that. 3 D-linemen (2 solid and 1 a project) and a starting RB would be a nice haul!

      1. 7.1.1


        That’s a good idea, one defensive end prospect that i like as a developmental guy is Ade Aruna from Tulane, he’s big and athletic he just needs some refinement as he only started playing football his senior year of high school because he’s from Nigeria. He’s got all the tools to become a dominant guy that could surprise a lot of people. Big, strong, freakishly athletic, just needs technique.

    2. 7.2


      None of those guys are going to be available where you have them drafted, and fuck a kicker.

      1. 7.2.1


        Thant’s why it’s called a Mock. It’s like guessing. And for all we know, a good bit of them might be there. Few thought OJ would be there last year, and sure enough. Even fewer thought Godwin would be there in the third, sure enough, he was.

      2. 7.2.2


        Hey Mike,

        If I start to mock lingerie football, I’m going to take your advice! lol.


    3. 7.3


      +1, this draft is a heck of a lot better than Scott’s. I think we might be able to pick a 1st round faller instead of Davenport/Bryan but otherwise I can’t really complain.

      Everybody is so sure that Chubb won’t fall to us. I’m not so sure. I see the teams in front of us and say damn, there could be 4 QBs taken and trade ups are unlikely since all the teams on the top are QB needy. I think the Colts or the Giants are the only real threats to take Chubb, but the Giants need to have something ready for when Eli is done and I don’t think Matt Patricia is going to pass on Nelson when he NEEDS to get Luck on the field and keep him there.

      This reminds me an awful lot of the Howard speculation, where we were right the first time but kept betting against ourselves.

    4. 7.4


      Got the Eddy Pineiro idea from me.

  8. 8


    This mock only makes sense if Chubb, Nelson and Barkley are off the board and no one wants to trade up and take our pick. That said the 2nd round pick would definitely have to be either Wynn or Hernandez at guard to make sure the running game gets the help our offense desperately needs. My preference is Wynn because he excelled in the SEC playing LT which would bring much needed versatility to the OL. This is a deep RB class and we should be able to find a very good RB by trading back into the 2nd or seeing if we can wait it out til the 3rd. DE is a need but I have a feeling our FA will land Michael Bennett plus a Kony Ealy type player coupled with the hopeful return of Spence should lessen the glaring need we currently have at DE.

  9. 9


    Scott, I like your picks; it all makes sense to me based on your strategy. Go Bucs!

  10. 10


    Chubb, Nelson, or Vea are win/win/win to me. If we could trade back and land him even better. I have a feeling after the combine that Vita won’t look so much like a reach at #7. Impressive tape and movement for a huge man. Really digging Rashaad Penny as well, but I’m hoping for him in the 3rd round.. might be wishful thinking.

  11. 11


    Free Agency will certainly impact the draft, but I would not be unhappy with Vea in the 1st round. However, Penny seems like a reach with a high 2nd round pick.

    If the Bucs draft Vea in the first I’d rather the Bucs target in the 2nd round:
    Duke Ejiofor DE Wake Forest
    Sam Hubbard DE Ohio State
    Mike Hughes CB UCF

  12. 12


    Ugh. This looks like a Browns draft. Don’t put too much stock into Senior Bowl week OR the Combine. I think that there is going to be a mad rush for teams to grab their future QBs and the Bucs may very well be in a position to trade down. Buffalo makes a lot of sense. Trade down and pick up Billy Price & De’ron Payne.

  13. 13


    If the draft fell like this I’d probably be open to trading down if there’s a QB needy team looking to trade up. Can see Buffalo, Baltimore and Arizona as teams that might want to leapfrog Washington, Miami and maybe Cincy in order to grab a QB.

    1. 13.1


      I think you have some of the best and most educated comments on this site. I’d definitely be on board to trade back if Barkley, Fitzpatrick, and Chubb were all gone by 7.

      1. 13.1.1


        Thanks Cody, appreciate the props. Did just see a mock that had 4 QB’s taken in the top 6 and Chubb fell to us at 7, in which case screw the trading down idea lol. Hard to see that happening, but guess we can hope.

  14. 14


    If Jason Licht has this type of draft, we will make the playoffs next year. Its a draft made up of nasty players who love football. I’m happy you left out the H-back crew we seem to draft in the later rounds. The only thing I would do different is draft Nelson first. An interior line of Nelson, Marpet and Cappa would make Penny and Dion Lewis a dynamic duo. Go Bucs!

  15. 15


    I would like to see us go after Siran Neal from Jacksonville ST in the late rounds. Hybrid style player that I think would develop well next to Justin Evans and allow the defense to run more exotic looks

  16. 16

    Buc 1976

    Even if we were to draft Chubb he would help some.
    It usually takes a year or two for DE’S to learn some extra tricks of the trade.

  17. 17


    Ehh… Not really a fan of this mock. But if going with Vea and Penny with the first two picks, I’d do it like,

    Rd 1) DT Vita Vea
    Rd 2) RB Rashaad Penny
    Rd 3) DE Chad Thomas
    Rd 4) OT/OG Brandon Parker
    Rd 5) DE Jalyn Holmes
    Rd 6) K Eddy Pineiro
    Rd 6) RB/KR/PR Braxton Berrios

    1. 17.1


      In addition, if Chubb, Fitzpatrick and Barkley are all gone at 7. If I’m taking a defender here, it is Derwin James. Not Vita Vea. Fitzpatrick and James are the two best DBs in this draft.

  18. 18


    I swear the BUCS NEED TO PICK UP either Derwin James (6’2-3 S) or Tarvarus McFadden (6’1-2 CB) from FSU. Hell I draft them as 1 and 2 or 1 and 3

  19. 19


    I like this Draft, but we are going to need more corners.

  20. 20



  21. 21


    Everything hinges on FA but a RB in round 2 would be a terrible pick as things stand now. There are 10 runners in this class that could potentially help our backfield, taking one in the 2nd is reaching.

    Steelers- Bell*, Bengals- Mixon, Jaguars- Fournette, Texans- Miller/Foreman, Titans- Murray/Henry, Chiefs- Hunt, Chargers- Gordon, Bills- McCoy, Bears- Howard/Cohen, Vikings-Cook, Panthers- McCaffery, Saints- Ingram/Kamara, Falcons- Freeman/Coleman, Rams-Gurley, Cardinals-DJ, Cowboys-Elliott, Eagles- Ajayi.

    Leaves 15 teams including the Pats who run a stable and are unlikely to draft an RB high, including Browns,Giants,Colts, one of which will draft Barkley, and 2 other teams (Broncos,Redskins,Jets) in need of a QB. I know that is 3 teams but Cousins likely lands on one. At most, 13 teams are looking for a new runner, including the Bucs. 10 legitimate options in the class (or so I read) and with all the Bucs other holes this is my main reason for waiting on drafting an RB.

    Bulletproof logic it is not, obviously any of the teams I listed that have established runners could draft one at any time, but it is unlikely to be high. The Packers spent 2 picks on RBs last year… anyway… 2nd round is REACHING!!! Give me guys for the trenches please!

    And a CB

  22. 22


    I’ll give this Mock 2.0 a B grade. We fans need to realize the Bucs can only fill so many gaping holes in one draft. With our 2016 draft not living up to expectations and the OL experiment blowing up in our face, we’re in a sticky situation going into this offseason. Since we need DT, CB, DE, S, RB & OL help, I love the first 2 picks. Like the 3rd and think the 4th can be a solid player in a year or two. I don’t love going LB in the 5th. While I’d like to grab a CB (Jackson/Ward if we can trade down in 1st) in the early rounds, D.J. can play. But I’m a bit weary of his speed on the outside & size in our division. Basically could be another VH3 situation.

    In the end, as long as Bucs draft BPA in every round, we should be fine. Just gotta hope that the BPA also fills a big need. Would like to come out of the draft with a DE, CB, RB & G as top priority. DT and S just a tier below in importance, imo.

  23. 23


    Decent mock draft not a lot of complaints, rather see maybe a trade for the Bills two picks 22 and 23 to draft Harold Landry and a guard like Wynn or Will Hernandez to give us some nastiness. I’d like for us to take a look at McKinnon in free agency and draft a bigger back later in the draft like Bo Scarbrough from Bama. Like the pick for having a bigger corner as we could use some height, with that we could hopefully pull Talib in free agency and Edge rushing Bennett in free agency

  24. 24


    Okay … I get that this is an exercise in finding good players in “minor” programs (4 of 6), but please …

  25. 25


    We need more OL help than this mock provides. I know the defense sucks but I think we get 2 OL; 2 DL and 2 in the secondary. We got to keep Winston healthy. Nelson with the first pick is my hope.

Leave a Reply

© 2017 PewterReport.com All Rights reserved. Marketing Tampa | Visual Realm

Send this to a friend