Welcome, one and all, to PewterReport.com’s Bucs Franchise Fantasy Draft – boy, that was a mouthful.

To spice up the offseason a bit, and to hopefully make the time between now and training camp go by a little quicker, PewterReport.com’s “Big 3” that consists of publisher Scott Reynolds, editor-in-chief Mark Cook and Bucs beat writer Trevor Sikkema have come up with an exercise that will give all Bucs fans, young and old, something unique to read and follow along with. We set out to see who would draft the best Bucs team of all-time.

The rule of the Bucs Franchise Draft are simple. Each owner/GM will get one pick per round in an order that numbers in a snake style (meaning if you have the last pick of the current round you also get the first pick of the next round, etc.). Any player who played for the Buccaneers at any point in their career is up for grabs, but who you are selecting is the type of player they were as Buccaneers. That means players like Steve Young or Bo Jackson wouldn’t do your team any good. There can be some potential and chemistry assumed with different players playing from different eras, but most of what you’re drafting is from what we’ve seen these players do as Tampa Bay Buccaneers. New offseason additions like wide receiver DeSean Jackson, defensive tackle Chris Baker and tight end O.J. Howard were drafted – but only on potential.

Before the draft, at a top secret location, the three drew numbers and the order of the draft came out:

  1. Mark Cook
  2. Trevor Sikkema
  3. Scott Reynolds

Each owner/GM had to build their complete starting offense, defense, and also draft a kicker, punter and a special teams return specialist, so there were 25 picks in total. Each offense had to include two wide receivers, two running backs, one tight end, one quarterback and a center, two guards and two tackles, and each defense had to include two safeties, two corners, three linebackers, and four defensive linemen – no getting fancy with schemes. The three owners/GMs also selected a head coach from the Bucs history as well, and those selections will be revealed on Saturday at the conclusion of this PewterReport.com Bucs Franchise Fantasy Draft.

The draft will be divided into five days with five rounds being announced each day on PewterReport.com. On Saturday, the three Bucs fantasy draft teams will be listed side-by-side-by-side for you to view and vote on. We want our PewterReport.com readers in Pewter Nation to select which Pewter Reporter drafted the ultimate Bucs fantasy team.

Now into the final day, with rounds 1-5 rounds 6-10rounds 11-15, and rounds 16-20 official and on the depth charts, it’s time to round out the rosters with our final five selections.


  1. G George Yarno – Cook
  2. S Jermaine Phillips – Sikkema
  3. C Mayberry – Reynolds


  1. DE Noah Spence – Reynolds
  2. K Martin Gramatica – Sikkema
  3. LT Roman Oben – Cook


  1. P Bryan Anger – Cook
  2. C Jeff Faine – Sikkema
  3. K Connor Barth – Reynolds


  1. QB Brad Johnson – Reynolds
  2. KR Micheal Spurlock – Sikkema
  3. KR Clifton Smith – Cook


  1. K Michael Husted – Cook
  2. P Josh Bidwell – Sikkema
  3. P Tom Tupa – Reynolds

With all of the picks in, let’s see what each owner/GM had to say about their final selections, starting with Mark Cook.

Share On Socials

About the Author: Trevor Sikkema

Trevor Sikkema is the Tampa Bay Buccaneers beat reporter and NFL Draft analyst for PewterReport.com. Sikkema, an alumnus of the University of Florida, has covered both college and professional football for much of his career. As a native of the Sunshine State, when he's not buried in social media, Sikkema can be found out and active, attempting to be the best athlete he never was. Sikkema can be reached at: trevor@pewterreport.com
Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Alldaway 2.0
4 years ago

It is interesting to see how there are differences in terms of value of Bucs players from the round table regarding present and past players in terms of athleticism, leadership, experience (eg playoff/super bowl ) and stats.

4 years ago

Im surprised Michael Husted and Connor Barth were taken before Steve Christie and Donald Igwebuike..

Clearwater Buc
Clearwater Buc
4 years ago

I would have taken Kellen Winslow over O.J. Howard, Keenan McCardell over Kevin House, Randall McDaniel over J.R. Sweezy, Logan Mankins or Cosey Coleman over George Yarno, Jeff Christy over Joe Hawley, Dave Pear over Chris Baker, Dewey Selmon over Barrett Ruud, and Mike Washington or Ricky Reynolds over Brent Grimes. Just my opinion.

Mark Cook
Reply to  Clearwater Buc
4 years ago

Man you are right I dropped the ball forgetting about Mankins. Good call.

Clearwater Buc
Clearwater Buc
Reply to  Mark Cook
4 years ago

Hey Mark, if it’s any consolation, I think I would take your team over the rest. Scott has a close 2nd.

4 years ago

No Matt Bryant as the kicker, though he never really played for the Bucs, but at guard Carl Nicks, Scott Brantley or Dewey Selmon as an LB. Will you guys pick the coach of your team as well.

4 years ago

Brought back a lot of memories reading those names from the early Bucs teams. It was nice to see Trevor mixing some in with the more recent players.

I was hoping to see a final complete roster of Cook’s Crooks (always liked the nickname CrimiNoles), Sikkema’s Dreamas (as in the new term dreamers) and Reynolds’ Rappers (just too simple) .

This piece made me wonder what happened to some of those folks for whom I cheered “when I wore a younger man’s clothes” (words from Piano Man). Perhaps the PR gang can do a “Whatever Happened to _______________? series.